ON WOMEN:
I think an unacknowledged barrier to women’s advancement in the profession is older women who have “made it” and who clench tightly to their achievements so as not to lose sight of what they did accomplish in the even more unfriendly environment of past decades. I have had three women mentors. One is a judge, one is a partner at a local firm, and one is a recent graduate who works in a nonprofit. Both the judge and the partner were adamant that women these days have it too easy and we should essentially “suck it up” and work harder than the men to achieve what they have. Instead of mentoring us, they see our success in easier (but still, not perfect) territory as a threat to the prestige of their positions. If we will not be like them, we must not be good enough.
This reflects a phenomenon I’ve read about in the context of poverty, race, and violence – when oppressed or disadvantaged, a group will eventually try to rise up and throw off its oppressors, who react with even harsher oppression. The disadvantaged group eventually internalizes the presence of barriers to its power and operates/lives within the realm the more powerful group allows it to have. Problems arise when there is more than one disadvantaged group – these similarly situated factions begin to commit violence on one another; they see each other as rivals for the limited resources and opportunities inside the “realm.” So instead of providing mutual support in their struggle for power/space/opportunity equal to that of the dominant group, they waste energy dragging each other down. From my experience with older women mentors, they see themselves as a separate group from younger women… to the detriment of both, but mostly to the younger women.
ON BROWN PEOPLE:
I’m involved in multiple (they sometimes blend) minority / Asian / Korean / women / attorney groups. There are monthly lunches, dinners, occasional happy hours, and even an Oscars-watching party. Most are purely for the purpose of socializing, networking, and supporting each other – there’s no advocacy or official business on the agenda. And while I am grateful that firms occasionally sponsor our activities, I hope they don’t stop their diversity support efforts there. Because while these gatherings are useful for mental peace and sometimes for careers, the fact remains that women (and especially women of color) are not the major decision-makers in many client-organizations. So we may keep each other sane, but this type of acquaintance does not bring in business – a major factor in who makes partner. And women are still excluded from many minor interactions peripheral but oh-so-necessary to work (like golfing, running, discussions about sports teams, friendly competitions, etc.) where men might not even be consciously excluding us. When women rule the world we’ll have to evaluate the power of book clubs; until then everyone needs to be aware of the golf/sports/running club club club.
ON BROWN WOMEN:
Being a member of the “double whammy” group is a funny thing. Our high numbers of attrition from firms is counterintuitive – you’d think that some statistically-minded person at the top would realize that retaining us means the firm gets to count its diversity levels twice. At the very least, looking good ought to motivate some people, if rightness won’t.
NATIONAL & LOCAL STUDIES:
Women account for 30% of attorneys in the U.S. and 50% of all law students; women of color account for only 3% of the profession.
Minority women are the most likely to begin their careers in public interest jobs. (5.7%)
3.5 % White women
3.3 % Minority men
1.5% White men
Minority women leave law firms at an alarming rate. 12.1 % leave within their first year of practice, and 75% leave within the first five years.
Although most attorneys in the majority do not recognize bias as a major or moderate problem, most attorneys rate themselves as more sensitive than other people to the rights and needs of attorneys in diverse communities.
When firms employ diverse attorneys, they may feel overused to attend and present at diversity events, to serve on diversity committees, and to participate in other activities that do not accrue toward billable hour objectives. (The number of hours you bill per year determines your "rank" at the firm because it signifies how much money you earned for your firm. Bills go to clients; because there is no client at diversity initiatives, essentially it's a drain on your expensive time.)
Women of color state that they were allowed to meet with clients only when their race or gender would be advantageous to the firm; they frequently were not given a substantive role in those meetings.
Many complained that they received "soft evaluations" which denied them the opportunity to correct deficits and gain experiences that could lead to promotions and partnership.
"This study clearly evidences that if women of color are not viewed as separate from women in general or people of color in general, your ability to recruit, retain, and advance them is impaired." - Recommendations to firms by the Commission of Women In The Profession.