Thursday, February 2, 2012

komen vs. planned parenthood

A fellow law school alum posted this link as her Facebook status:
Live Action Applauds Komen Defunding Of Planned Parenthood.

She said: "FANTASTIC!! Goooood job, Komen, well done! PLEASE stop what you are doing right now and write to news@komen.org and say (in English please): 'Thanks for defunding Planned Parenthood!' That's all you have to say! And it will make a huge difference :)"

I almost barfed.

ArtsyChef, one of my coworkers (also a fellow alum) turned beet red and started shaking. I watched it happen.

Texts from other women we graduated with started pouring in. Apparently our classmate managed to aggravate all of us.

Comments on her Facebook post, in order:

ArtsyChef: "Yeah, cancer screenings and education are the worst!"

Me: "But I only speak Spanish."

EarthMadre: "For the record, I personally have received breast cancer screenings from Planned Parenthood, during a time when I certainly couldn't have afforded other care. If that was Komen fundraising - thanks! Sorry you're stopping. And the notion that two organizations can't work together on one goal just because they also have individual goals is absurd. That kind of attitude is why Republicans and Democrats can't get anything done in Congress!"

And then our classmate's conservative friends jumped in with a bunch of arguments about how terrible abortion is. "Planned Parenthood, with a sucking tube, purposefully dismembers and decapitates thousands of unborn babies every day. Think I am lying? Think I am extreme? Watch an ultrasound of an abortion procedure and then tell me I am extreme. I dare you."

They kept going. In their eagerness to sensationalize their pet project, they missed our point (well, the other alumni's point... I was responding to the inanely racist ownership of the message). Our point was not "abortion is awesome." Do you know what Planned Parenthood does? I just want to tell them listen. Idiots. This is not a "win" for the pro-life movement. The number of abortions it will stop, if any, is probably under 5. And if Komen wanted to stop funding Planned Parenthood for logistical reasons (one of its arguments) then so be it, but it's still a travesty for the women who relied on that funding for their health. There are probably lots of other places you can get mammograms, but Planned Parenthood is such a well-established organization that reaches so many women. Why not help their already-existing population?

Even if you're adamantly pro-life and are celebrating the detrriment to an organization that 2% of the time does things you think are evil,  I think a baby and bathwater analogy would be appropriate here. Our point, which the crazies missed, was that:
More breast cancer checks for the poor = good
Less breast cancer checks for the poor = bad

EarthMadre kept trying to reason with them. She noted that Planned Parenthood served as a good safety net for women who weren't thinking of other aspects of their health. Women walk in to get contraceptives and then realize they should get a whole medical workover, thus catching their breast cancer early.

Texts:

EarthMadre: My god I'm annoyed.

Me: Your logic is impeccable. The only problem is that it's directed at idiots.

EM: Yes. Yes it is. I should stop. Last Word Syndrome ends in pain.

Me: They make me want to scream and throw things. At the very least, any sane readers will pick up on the fact that you make better points than the other commenters. And any insane readers were lost causes to begin with.

EM: "But they are MURDERERS!!!"

Me: Genociders.

EM: I bet Planned Parenthood slaughters puppies at the employee Christmas party.

Me: Of course they do. They worship Satan, and Satan eats puppies.

EM: Let's eat Scarlett for dinner.

Well played, dear roommate. Well played.

1 comment:

mushroom planet said...

ARGHHH!

Planned Parenthood. It just occurred to me what a good name that is.

Margaret Sanger is rolling, rolling in her grave.