Proponents of transnational adoption want to reduce the issue to individual stories ("How many ponies do you have?"), to not see systems of oppression and injustice. They sound like most white Americans talking about racism. Or republicans talking about poverty.
The transnational adoption conversation should not be limited to a discussion of individual experiences. Even though a proponent will argue, "But you love your family, and think of all the things you could do because you grew up here," what they're essentially saying is, "You lucked out and got good parents. Be grateful." I've said before that everyone who has good parents should be grateful - but the "family lottery" that sends children overseas for economic profit shouldn't even happen in the first place. Any reason you have for prioritizing transnational adoption over domestic adoption or single parent support (in each country, respectively) fails if you consider the rights of the original families and the children. Adoption agency financial gain? No. Evangelizing and making more Christians? No. Getting children for couples who want them? Close, but no cigar. Where do you think that many children come from? Why are they "available?" It's not just individual stories. It's systemic.
The Voice of Love campaign is a lobby strategy aimed at the South Korean government, which has declared (repeatedly... although the deadline keeps moving) that it will end foreign adoption from South Korea by 2016. A Korean-American pastor asks adoptees to send in their "success" stories via YouTube video so that the campaign can send them to the South Korean government. The prompting question is, "How has adoption blessed your life?" Not only does this campaign ignore all the systemic injustice and structural issues contributing to adoption (by requesting token stories), but most of the people responding to the video are adoptive parents. These parents are taking away their children's voices by responding for them. I'm glad you're happy, but if you think beyond yourself there is so much more at play. Listen, South Korean government. Your duty is not to these adoptive parents. Your duty is to the small citizens you discard every day.
No comments:
Post a Comment