This place looks awesome. If you can't see the FB link because you have successfully avoided THE social network, then congrats.
It's a small, no-reservations restaurant in... Robbinsdale, MN. They make foie gras, red snapper, duck, rabbit, lamb, beets, and whatever else they feel like putting on the menu that week. A few of my friends have gone and raved about it. It's affordable too - a 10 course tasting menu for two for $60 is a steal around here. And Bon Appetit magazine ranked it 4th nationwide for best new restaurants.
Another place I want to try is Pizzeria Lola in south Minneapolis. The chef is Korean and her husband runs the business-side. They have galbi pizza. Normally I'm suspicious of fusion because it's been used as "lite" versions for the weak to feel exotic and adventurous, and because it can be mistaken for being the (often better) authentic flavor, but my friends say it's good. So I'm headed there tonight.
figuring out what's real at the intersection of race, gender, and transnational adoption in america... this involves some serious discussions about food and my cat, roger.
Thursday, March 29, 2012
Wednesday, March 28, 2012
getting through it
I can tell I'm stressed out beyond something that a yoga session can cure when people try to joke with me and I either don't get it, or I can't come up with the proper vocabulary to respond in kind. It's kind of embarrassing and it makes me look really ditzy. I was tested for some kind of mental deficit in high school because this kind of thing kept occurring - I'd have inappropriate responses to stimuli or I'd completely miss instructions by a teacher or coach because I'd blank out, even while trying hard to concentrate. In retrospect, I think my system was just over-taxed. For me, social interactions are the first thing to leave.
It has been really nice to have Mr. BearCat during all of this. He may not entirely understand why I do what I do in a way that would compel him to make the same choices, but he understands that I have to because I am me. And he's good at helping me sort through my arguments. But most of all, he's very grounding. When I was upset and lashing out at him the other night, instead of getting huffy too he gave me a hug and asked me what was wrong. And then I realized I was ok, even if I was sad.
I've been very lucky to have had two things for almost my whole life. The first is unconditional love, which you know you have when the people around you listen to you even when you're driving them nuts. Everyone deserves and needs this.
The second thing that is perhaps specific to my own needs is intelligent people. I need to know individuals who are capable of grasping the things I want them to understand. They don't have to agree with me, but I don't feel right until I feel like a particular concept has been realized in the minds of the people I'm talking to. And the people I've talked to most frequently have been in my family. I'm not sure how I'd handle having parents who aren't logical. That was a good fit (or is it a chicken-egg issue?). After a few recent run-ins with non-logically-wired friend brains, I am ever so grateful for the critically-thinking family members I've been blessed with. While some people might be "I want you to feel what I feel" types, I am an "I want you to know what I know." Analysis is my therapy. I feel better about things after I (and you) understand them.
May the next month be better. And the force be with you.
Tuesday, March 27, 2012
everyone's afraid to question their own work
I'm becoming increasingly frustrated with Korean adoptees. Actually, that's too specific. I'm frustrated with people who are rash and/or self-important and/or not intelligent.
Any of those things would be fine (who doesn't have flaws?) if they weren't tied to Korean adoptee advocacy community actions. There are too many large egos floating around - too many people so focused on their own contributions and legacies that they lose the forest for their own personal tree. When these people are rash, the forest burns more quickly. And when these people are not intelligent, well there's no way to explain that the forest didn't have to burn at all in the first place.
But if you try to say any of that you risk being chucked into the ocean as an example of someone who's "hard to work with."
There's a lot of anti-intellectual sentiment permeating the Korean adoptee community, and it's becoming more and more frustrating to do this work. Not only do I feel less effective as an advocate (when my target population keeps misunderstanding my positions), but it's dangerous to my personal reputation.
I'm not sure where all the infighting started, but Korean adoptee advocates have a long history of stabbing each other in the back. It's strange, especially when compared to the other advocacy communities I've worked with where there are definitely personalities who don't get along but they're generally able to put their issues aside with the greater good in mind. This doesn't happen here. I inhabit some weird island of co-destruction.
Anyway. I've been invited to join the discourse in a much more public way by an individual who is influential, in his own way, but who I believe has problematic tendencies. I'm afraid to work with him. But if I don't, he'll see it as taking a stance against him. (It's not. I am totally in earnest when I say that I wish everyone well even if we disagree, as long as they're doing what they believe is best.)
Also, I don't want to put myself (my personal story, my name, my contact information, my opinions) out there for public consumption. I'd like to contribute objective ideas and research to the public forum, but not anything that would propel me forward as a token luminary - open to personal attacks.
Also, I'd like to publish in peer-reviewed journals and more established locations.
But I'm being called out by people who don't see long-term, who aren't strategic, and aren't respectful in their working interactions. I'm worried.
I guess it was naive to think I could stay anonymous indefinitely.
Any of those things would be fine (who doesn't have flaws?) if they weren't tied to Korean adoptee advocacy community actions. There are too many large egos floating around - too many people so focused on their own contributions and legacies that they lose the forest for their own personal tree. When these people are rash, the forest burns more quickly. And when these people are not intelligent, well there's no way to explain that the forest didn't have to burn at all in the first place.
But if you try to say any of that you risk being chucked into the ocean as an example of someone who's "hard to work with."
There's a lot of anti-intellectual sentiment permeating the Korean adoptee community, and it's becoming more and more frustrating to do this work. Not only do I feel less effective as an advocate (when my target population keeps misunderstanding my positions), but it's dangerous to my personal reputation.
I'm not sure where all the infighting started, but Korean adoptee advocates have a long history of stabbing each other in the back. It's strange, especially when compared to the other advocacy communities I've worked with where there are definitely personalities who don't get along but they're generally able to put their issues aside with the greater good in mind. This doesn't happen here. I inhabit some weird island of co-destruction.
Anyway. I've been invited to join the discourse in a much more public way by an individual who is influential, in his own way, but who I believe has problematic tendencies. I'm afraid to work with him. But if I don't, he'll see it as taking a stance against him. (It's not. I am totally in earnest when I say that I wish everyone well even if we disagree, as long as they're doing what they believe is best.)
Also, I don't want to put myself (my personal story, my name, my contact information, my opinions) out there for public consumption. I'd like to contribute objective ideas and research to the public forum, but not anything that would propel me forward as a token luminary - open to personal attacks.
Also, I'd like to publish in peer-reviewed journals and more established locations.
But I'm being called out by people who don't see long-term, who aren't strategic, and aren't respectful in their working interactions. I'm worried.
I guess it was naive to think I could stay anonymous indefinitely.
Monday, March 26, 2012
golden birthday
When I was younger I was always envious of the kids who had golden birthdays in their teens. I thought I'd be so old and boring by the time I had mine that it would be pointless. I actually envisioned myself sitting in a chair, wearing a red shirt (no idea why), and being lame.
While I might sit in a chair on my birthday, red shirt or not, I don't think I'm old and boring yet. In fact, I've gotten to the point where I question whether that ever even happens as a result of age rather than general disposition. I think that if you're going to act old and boring, you'll probably start doing it in your teens (I'm talking to you Amber F with the granny bubble in 2002). If you're not old and boring, then you're just not... until your knees stop working, and then Jay Leno starts to look more appealing.
Anyway. My point is that I am neither old (still have my knees) or boring (don't know where I'll be living in 6 months, much less what I'll be doing).
I was right about one thing though. I have a cat.
Happy golden birthday to me this week! It still matters.
While I might sit in a chair on my birthday, red shirt or not, I don't think I'm old and boring yet. In fact, I've gotten to the point where I question whether that ever even happens as a result of age rather than general disposition. I think that if you're going to act old and boring, you'll probably start doing it in your teens (I'm talking to you Amber F with the granny bubble in 2002). If you're not old and boring, then you're just not... until your knees stop working, and then Jay Leno starts to look more appealing.
Anyway. My point is that I am neither old (still have my knees) or boring (don't know where I'll be living in 6 months, much less what I'll be doing).
I was right about one thing though. I have a cat.
Happy golden birthday to me this week! It still matters.
Sunday, March 25, 2012
carp out of water
My supervisor used the phrase, "like a Chinese wall," in training and then looked at me awkwardly. I have no idea what he meant but now I'm paranoid. I jumped when he said "VC" later.
VC? Viet Cong? There's no way to know.
This company is way out in the suburbs, and it shows. Physically. My coworkers are all living out the stereotype - white, overweight, and old. This environment weighs so heavily on me that the air feels thick. Anytime anyone mentions something Asian-ish they look at me. It doesn't help that a lot of the documents we're looking at have Korean writing on them. Which I can't read.
VC? Viet Cong? There's no way to know.
This company is way out in the suburbs, and it shows. Physically. My coworkers are all living out the stereotype - white, overweight, and old. This environment weighs so heavily on me that the air feels thick. Anytime anyone mentions something Asian-ish they look at me. It doesn't help that a lot of the documents we're looking at have Korean writing on them. Which I can't read.
Thursday, March 22, 2012
things i am saving up for
A trip to Arizona to eat the things Mr. BearCat keeps telling me about.
A trip to San Fran for "activist camp." Har har.
A soft duvet. Mine is 15 years old and has started developing spontaneous holes, not just the ones Roger makes. :(
Glasses.
Plain black Ultimate jersey.
Raincoat that is both cute and functional.
Green jeans. (Cigarette, mid-rise, ankle, 28)
Indigo jeans. (Cigaregge, mid-rise, full-length, 28)
Black fleece jacket to block wind.
Sundresses. One playful, one polished.
On a semi-related and depressing note, I discovered that I earned less last year than my "garbage man." And s/he probably gets health care.
A trip to San Fran for "activist camp." Har har.
A soft duvet. Mine is 15 years old and has started developing spontaneous holes, not just the ones Roger makes. :(
Glasses.
Plain black Ultimate jersey.
Raincoat that is both cute and functional.
Green jeans. (Cigarette, mid-rise, ankle, 28)
Indigo jeans. (Cigaregge, mid-rise, full-length, 28)
Black fleece jacket to block wind.
Sundresses. One playful, one polished.
On a semi-related and depressing note, I discovered that I earned less last year than my "garbage man." And s/he probably gets health care.
Wednesday, March 21, 2012
overbearing sister alert
LittleBoy responded to one of my emails. At the end, he tacked on a question.
"BTW, know of any fine single ladies who like nerds? Ha ha ha! Ha... ha... sadness."
I instantly perked up. Oh joy of joys! An opportunity to be helpful! Also, an opportunity to throw the sort of women I like at him. Because obviously this is all about who I want him to date.
I gave him some tips for meeting quality chicks. I told him if he wanted to meet people he had to go out in public (!) on a regular basis and build friendships.
It's too bad Ultimate summer league registration is over. Because it's the perfect haven of progressive, nerdy, somewhat athletic women. And the forum is great for meeting people - the league holds a draft and everyone on your team is new to one another. Ultimate is a cooperative activity that forces interaction and pleasant feelings of teamwork... and everyone goes to a pub afterward to hang out. It's not a downtown meat market scene at all, but rather a bunch of sweaty recreational players drinking Surly, eating nachos, and talking about their pets, gardens, and maybe politics.
But registration is over. So there's always... kickball? I doubt they hold drafts for that. I think you have to sign up with a team, and that kind of defeats the purpose.
I texted a few friends (sshh...) for suggestions on meeting slightly nerdy women. They suggested community cooking classes, reading groups at the library (although sci-fi might be split by gender, unless men have suddenly developed a passion for sparkly vampire spin-offs), adult night at the Minnesota Science Museum, and bowling league. I don't think LittleBoy likes bowling. But I think he could find a few hobbies that involve leaving the house. Compulsory interaction is the key.
I also suggested joining civic groups with causes he cares about, or volunteering somewhere. If I asked him what sort of things his ideal lady friend would like to do he'd probably say, "Cook, read, watch movies, gaming," and other quiet at-home activities. Well, that's nice. But there's no way they're going to meet each other if they each stay cooped up in their respective houses. Also, I think he should date someone who cares about things.
Someone who cares about things.
I know that sounds ridiculous, but some people don't care about things. They really don't. And I don't mean his dates have to be out burning their bras every weekend, but I really do think that the most sustainably interesting people pursue activities and ideas that force them to engage with elements of the outside world in a way that generates new activities and ideas. If you're not growing, you're just biding your time. And no one should bide their time for years upon years.
And if you want to hang out with an interesting sort of person, you should have something to contribute too (or they will think you're boring). So I recommended a few volunteer opportunities with causes I like (because I am the important one here), such as Minnesotans United for All Families. But there are also the cooking classes, library clubs, wine clubs, and community events. There's so much out there. Even reading, depending on what it is and how one engages with it.
LittleBoy hasn't been single for such a long time that he probably doesn't have much experience with fellow single competent adults who have careers, pay their taxes, have hobbies, and who pick up on adult social cues. I'm not knocking his core group of friends, but they haven't given each other any reason to brush up their Shakespeare. For the last 5 years. I think he'll be excited to see what's out there.
I want to tell him: The woman you are looking for does not live in the suburbs. You need to move back to an area where good citizens use sidewalks. She is progressive, and optimistic, and quirky. She cares about things. She thinks you are funny. She wants to do activities with you, like go for a bike ride and visit the Science Museum and make dinner with ingredients she's never tried before. She neither seeks you out because you are Asian, nor initially avoids you because you are Asian. And before you find her, you should go on a few dates. Because you're going to have to get some skillz back.
You can do it.
"BTW, know of any fine single ladies who like nerds? Ha ha ha! Ha... ha... sadness."
I instantly perked up. Oh joy of joys! An opportunity to be helpful! Also, an opportunity to throw the sort of women I like at him. Because obviously this is all about who I want him to date.
I gave him some tips for meeting quality chicks. I told him if he wanted to meet people he had to go out in public (!) on a regular basis and build friendships.
It's too bad Ultimate summer league registration is over. Because it's the perfect haven of progressive, nerdy, somewhat athletic women. And the forum is great for meeting people - the league holds a draft and everyone on your team is new to one another. Ultimate is a cooperative activity that forces interaction and pleasant feelings of teamwork... and everyone goes to a pub afterward to hang out. It's not a downtown meat market scene at all, but rather a bunch of sweaty recreational players drinking Surly, eating nachos, and talking about their pets, gardens, and maybe politics.
But registration is over. So there's always... kickball? I doubt they hold drafts for that. I think you have to sign up with a team, and that kind of defeats the purpose.
I texted a few friends (sshh...) for suggestions on meeting slightly nerdy women. They suggested community cooking classes, reading groups at the library (although sci-fi might be split by gender, unless men have suddenly developed a passion for sparkly vampire spin-offs), adult night at the Minnesota Science Museum, and bowling league. I don't think LittleBoy likes bowling. But I think he could find a few hobbies that involve leaving the house. Compulsory interaction is the key.
I also suggested joining civic groups with causes he cares about, or volunteering somewhere. If I asked him what sort of things his ideal lady friend would like to do he'd probably say, "Cook, read, watch movies, gaming," and other quiet at-home activities. Well, that's nice. But there's no way they're going to meet each other if they each stay cooped up in their respective houses. Also, I think he should date someone who cares about things.
Someone who cares about things.
I know that sounds ridiculous, but some people don't care about things. They really don't. And I don't mean his dates have to be out burning their bras every weekend, but I really do think that the most sustainably interesting people pursue activities and ideas that force them to engage with elements of the outside world in a way that generates new activities and ideas. If you're not growing, you're just biding your time. And no one should bide their time for years upon years.
And if you want to hang out with an interesting sort of person, you should have something to contribute too (or they will think you're boring). So I recommended a few volunteer opportunities with causes I like (because I am the important one here), such as Minnesotans United for All Families. But there are also the cooking classes, library clubs, wine clubs, and community events. There's so much out there. Even reading, depending on what it is and how one engages with it.
LittleBoy hasn't been single for such a long time that he probably doesn't have much experience with fellow single competent adults who have careers, pay their taxes, have hobbies, and who pick up on adult social cues. I'm not knocking his core group of friends, but they haven't given each other any reason to brush up their Shakespeare. For the last 5 years. I think he'll be excited to see what's out there.
I want to tell him: The woman you are looking for does not live in the suburbs. You need to move back to an area where good citizens use sidewalks. She is progressive, and optimistic, and quirky. She cares about things. She thinks you are funny. She wants to do activities with you, like go for a bike ride and visit the Science Museum and make dinner with ingredients she's never tried before. She neither seeks you out because you are Asian, nor initially avoids you because you are Asian. And before you find her, you should go on a few dates. Because you're going to have to get some skillz back.
You can do it.
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
doctor
I asked my doctor what my life expectancy was. He said that someone who lives like me - who eats well, exercises, doesn't smoke, drinks in moderation, takes her medicine, and is Asian and female - will live longer than someone who is the opposite. I guess Asian doesn't have an opposite - but the statistics are worst for black men.
I'm just going to pretend I'm going to die in 10 years anyway. That way the next 10 will feel like a bonus. I mean, why not? As long as I don't do anything dumb financially.
Monday, March 19, 2012
diversity week
The University of Minnesota's Asian law student association recently held a program called "Adoption and the Law in Minnesota" for Diversity Week.
"It will be a panel of four speakers who are adoptive parents, adoption attorneys, and an international adoption social worker. One of the women has been very involved in international Asian adoptions, and one of the men is both an adoptive parent of a Korean-American and specializes in adoption law."
I received this email through the Asian bar association listserv. That was the entire description. I gaped, horrified.
This event is obviously only for white people. Why would they invite the Asian bar association? It's like saying, "Hey, we're going to talk about how we get your babies. You should totally come."
Seriously.
If that wasn't bad enough, why is the Asian law student association talking about this for "Diversity Week?" What the hell?
And lastly, there were no adoptee voices on the panel. If they're going to talk about "how to" transnationally adopt, the conversation must by nature include a discussion on ethical issues in the process. Hello, you'd have to be living under a rock if you haven't read about all transnational adoption abuses in news in the last decade. A conversation about how to do things the right way must include ethical issues. And any discussion of ethical issues must include knowledge gained by the adult adoptee community.
But no. The panel just consisted of the people who speak for us, who make decisions for us, and who dismiss us as "angry" and "having bad parents" when we gain our voices, so they can explain to prospective parents that their children won't turn out like us if they raise them well. "Things have improved so much over the last 30 years," they'll say. As if there is a "right" way to ensure that specifically-Korean babies grow up well. (Thank you, Mrs. Han.)
The whole thing makes me feel sick.
"It will be a panel of four speakers who are adoptive parents, adoption attorneys, and an international adoption social worker. One of the women has been very involved in international Asian adoptions, and one of the men is both an adoptive parent of a Korean-American and specializes in adoption law."
I received this email through the Asian bar association listserv. That was the entire description. I gaped, horrified.
This event is obviously only for white people. Why would they invite the Asian bar association? It's like saying, "Hey, we're going to talk about how we get your babies. You should totally come."
Seriously.
If that wasn't bad enough, why is the Asian law student association talking about this for "Diversity Week?" What the hell?
And lastly, there were no adoptee voices on the panel. If they're going to talk about "how to" transnationally adopt, the conversation must by nature include a discussion on ethical issues in the process. Hello, you'd have to be living under a rock if you haven't read about all transnational adoption abuses in news in the last decade. A conversation about how to do things the right way must include ethical issues. And any discussion of ethical issues must include knowledge gained by the adult adoptee community.
But no. The panel just consisted of the people who speak for us, who make decisions for us, and who dismiss us as "angry" and "having bad parents" when we gain our voices, so they can explain to prospective parents that their children won't turn out like us if they raise them well. "Things have improved so much over the last 30 years," they'll say. As if there is a "right" way to ensure that specifically-Korean babies grow up well. (Thank you, Mrs. Han.)
The whole thing makes me feel sick.
Sunday, March 18, 2012
voice of love
It is mind-boggling to me how un-politicized transnational adoption is in the minds of the adoptee community. We can't see beyond ourselves and our own personal stories, and we fall right into the hands of the individuals who want to use us for their own ends. Inherently political ends, when they aren't economic.
Proponents of transnational adoption want to reduce the issue to individual stories ("How many ponies do you have?"), to not see systems of oppression and injustice. They sound like most white Americans talking about racism. Or republicans talking about poverty.
The transnational adoption conversation should not be limited to a discussion of individual experiences. Even though a proponent will argue, "But you love your family, and think of all the things you could do because you grew up here," what they're essentially saying is, "You lucked out and got good parents. Be grateful." I've said before that everyone who has good parents should be grateful - but the "family lottery" that sends children overseas for economic profit shouldn't even happen in the first place. Any reason you have for prioritizing transnational adoption over domestic adoption or single parent support (in each country, respectively) fails if you consider the rights of the original families and the children. Adoption agency financial gain? No. Evangelizing and making more Christians? No. Getting children for couples who want them? Close, but no cigar. Where do you think that many children come from? Why are they "available?" It's not just individual stories. It's systemic.
The Voice of Love campaign is a lobby strategy aimed at the South Korean government, which has declared (repeatedly... although the deadline keeps moving) that it will end foreign adoption from South Korea by 2016. A Korean-American pastor asks adoptees to send in their "success" stories via YouTube video so that the campaign can send them to the South Korean government. The prompting question is, "How has adoption blessed your life?" Not only does this campaign ignore all the systemic injustice and structural issues contributing to adoption (by requesting token stories), but most of the people responding to the video are adoptive parents. These parents are taking away their children's voices by responding for them. I'm glad you're happy, but if you think beyond yourself there is so much more at play. Listen, South Korean government. Your duty is not to these adoptive parents. Your duty is to the small citizens you discard every day.
Thursday, March 15, 2012
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
switch
I am still weighed down by the grief that comes from realizing that everything you trusted in has in some way betrayed you. Even if it tried to assuage the damage, even if it didn't know that it was the original cause, it has still betrayed you, and things are less real than they seemed before you knew.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted if Korea occupied the U.S. and lobbied for a regular supply of lucky American babies to be sent over and raised by Koreans, and you were one of those babies.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel misused if the U.S. and Canada, once colonized by Mexico, were freed by Korea only to be occupied and used as Korea's strategic military post in the west from the end of WWII until now. If the U.S.' weapons didn't work without Korean systems. That you wouldn't feel impotent if after being freed, the U.S. held its own democratic elections only to have its leaders assassinated by the Koreans in favor of ideologically Korean puppets. Don't tell me you wouldn't feel wretched if the U.S. became the site of an ideological war where the Koreans (who couldn't tell the Americans apart from the Canadians) bombed the entire country until it was in shambles and dropped 50,000 lbs of napalm a day. If your relatives were undoubtedly among those killed in the bombing. If the Koreans saw this as "helpful" to Americans, even while it mainly served Korean ends. If the American army, under the conservative puppet leaders, massacred the protesting Hawaiians and enacted a National Security Law to squelch any dissent from the left (not even communist) and to outlaw any mention of the Hawaiian massacre, and that National Security Law still existed today.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel dehumanized if Koreans used token American orphans as mascots to express their own humanity. If all the pictures you saw of American children in the war were of bodies, or were of American children being clothed, carried, and petted by benevolent Korean soldiers, who will go home and tell their wives that "those little guys were just so cute, almost like real Korean boys."
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted to learn that America didn't want to take care of mixed-race babies descended from Korean soldiers sleeping with American women, and sent them to Korea to be raised there. And then realized that all socially-burdensome babies could be sent abroad for a profit. And continued to do so until the industry grew to 220,000 babies and multiple billions of dollars in revenue. Don't tell me you wouldn't feel betrayed if you were one of those babies bought and sent to Korea to be raised by a family who loved you so much they didn't think the circumstances of your existence mattered more than their love for you. And you loved them back, and you loved Korea, your adoptive country. You felt wholly Korean, and proud of it, until pieces of you began chipping away as Koreans questioned your Koreanness and you didn't see anyone with a face remotely like yours in romantic comedies (a guilty national pleasure), and you got sick of trying to find clothing that fit your body the right way. And then you looked deeper and realized that you're not really an "orphan," but rather a casualty of ongoing militaristic policies in America that enable the adoption economy. As a modern nation, America had more than enough money to care for you but it refused to support your family either morally or economically. So your adoptive country, Korea, is still allowed to create American orphans and then scoop them up to satisfy its adoption industry, which maintains that they are better off being raised by Koreans. Especially Buddhist ones.
You realize that the Hague, which is supposed to be an internationally-recognized body of law protecting children, expresses no substantive values and is actually a protocol for opening adoption in new countries and maintaining it in old ones. It is a Free Trade Agreement for moving small humans across borders. And you are one of those humans.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted if your Korean family was alive during the war while your American family was being torn apart. If your spouse's grandfather fought in that war and you had to listen to him talk about "traveling" and buying things, and other people talk about his bravery. You know that soldiers never have a choice about where they go or what they do while they're there, but the fact still makes you physically nauseous. Every time he looks at you you wonder if he sees destitution. Prostitutes.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted if you realize that you are a physical manifestation of multiple kinds of violence.
Ludicrous. I know. Because you're American, and it feels absurd to suspend reality like this. But the events are true, and the fact that this is how I identify with my countries of birth and adoption is true.
This may not make much sense to you in light of how the Korean war was taught (or not) in school, and how it is presented in the media, especially after Bush II branded North Korea an "axis of evil." (Which did wonders for our relationship with it... or not.) But if you think critically about North Korea's behavior from the time immediately following WWII 'til today, its foreign and domestic policies are not unintelligible. Unlike the image and jokes we are fed by the media and our politicians (and Christian fundamentalists), the real North Korea has a functioning political system, policies which it follows, and defined interests - self-reliance, survival, and economic growth. It has reached out on multiple occasions without clear benefit to itself (like the time it made that startling kidnapping admission to Japan) in genuine attempts to engage in dialogue. It has presented South Korea with a plan for a unified peninsula under two states with separate economic systems. It has done much, much more.
Whether or not you're skeptical, you must realize one thing, and that is the fact that all Koreans want reunification. Why else would both regimes have spent 3/4 a century competing with each other for legitimacy? They see the peninsula as one, and it will be so eventually, but not without great struggle. In order for reunification to be successful, all interested parties (U.S., China, Russia, Japan, South Korea, North Korea) must engage each other in real discussions about economic growth, domestic policies, political systems, and strategic military plans (like whether the U.S. would really give up its foothold in the Asia-Pacific region when it wants to be able to face off with China). No dialogue is going to happen if we keep pointing fingers at North Korea, which honestly believes that its nuclear program is the only thing holding the U.S. back from more aggression. Naive perhaps, but we've given it no reason to think otherwise.
It all seems like too much to handle, much less accomplish. Identifying as an American adopted from Korea feels like my left hand is possessed and gripping a knife that's slowly sawing through a self-destructive right hand. Everything I do feels like an act of betraying myself.
I carry an entire country's grief on my shoulders. I didn't realize what this was until someone pointed it out to me - it is han.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted if Korea occupied the U.S. and lobbied for a regular supply of lucky American babies to be sent over and raised by Koreans, and you were one of those babies.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel misused if the U.S. and Canada, once colonized by Mexico, were freed by Korea only to be occupied and used as Korea's strategic military post in the west from the end of WWII until now. If the U.S.' weapons didn't work without Korean systems. That you wouldn't feel impotent if after being freed, the U.S. held its own democratic elections only to have its leaders assassinated by the Koreans in favor of ideologically Korean puppets. Don't tell me you wouldn't feel wretched if the U.S. became the site of an ideological war where the Koreans (who couldn't tell the Americans apart from the Canadians) bombed the entire country until it was in shambles and dropped 50,000 lbs of napalm a day. If your relatives were undoubtedly among those killed in the bombing. If the Koreans saw this as "helpful" to Americans, even while it mainly served Korean ends. If the American army, under the conservative puppet leaders, massacred the protesting Hawaiians and enacted a National Security Law to squelch any dissent from the left (not even communist) and to outlaw any mention of the Hawaiian massacre, and that National Security Law still existed today.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel dehumanized if Koreans used token American orphans as mascots to express their own humanity. If all the pictures you saw of American children in the war were of bodies, or were of American children being clothed, carried, and petted by benevolent Korean soldiers, who will go home and tell their wives that "those little guys were just so cute, almost like real Korean boys."
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted to learn that America didn't want to take care of mixed-race babies descended from Korean soldiers sleeping with American women, and sent them to Korea to be raised there. And then realized that all socially-burdensome babies could be sent abroad for a profit. And continued to do so until the industry grew to 220,000 babies and multiple billions of dollars in revenue. Don't tell me you wouldn't feel betrayed if you were one of those babies bought and sent to Korea to be raised by a family who loved you so much they didn't think the circumstances of your existence mattered more than their love for you. And you loved them back, and you loved Korea, your adoptive country. You felt wholly Korean, and proud of it, until pieces of you began chipping away as Koreans questioned your Koreanness and you didn't see anyone with a face remotely like yours in romantic comedies (a guilty national pleasure), and you got sick of trying to find clothing that fit your body the right way. And then you looked deeper and realized that you're not really an "orphan," but rather a casualty of ongoing militaristic policies in America that enable the adoption economy. As a modern nation, America had more than enough money to care for you but it refused to support your family either morally or economically. So your adoptive country, Korea, is still allowed to create American orphans and then scoop them up to satisfy its adoption industry, which maintains that they are better off being raised by Koreans. Especially Buddhist ones.
You realize that the Hague, which is supposed to be an internationally-recognized body of law protecting children, expresses no substantive values and is actually a protocol for opening adoption in new countries and maintaining it in old ones. It is a Free Trade Agreement for moving small humans across borders. And you are one of those humans.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted if your Korean family was alive during the war while your American family was being torn apart. If your spouse's grandfather fought in that war and you had to listen to him talk about "traveling" and buying things, and other people talk about his bravery. You know that soldiers never have a choice about where they go or what they do while they're there, but the fact still makes you physically nauseous. Every time he looks at you you wonder if he sees destitution. Prostitutes.
Don't tell me you wouldn't feel conflicted if you realize that you are a physical manifestation of multiple kinds of violence.
Ludicrous. I know. Because you're American, and it feels absurd to suspend reality like this. But the events are true, and the fact that this is how I identify with my countries of birth and adoption is true.
This may not make much sense to you in light of how the Korean war was taught (or not) in school, and how it is presented in the media, especially after Bush II branded North Korea an "axis of evil." (Which did wonders for our relationship with it... or not.) But if you think critically about North Korea's behavior from the time immediately following WWII 'til today, its foreign and domestic policies are not unintelligible. Unlike the image and jokes we are fed by the media and our politicians (and Christian fundamentalists), the real North Korea has a functioning political system, policies which it follows, and defined interests - self-reliance, survival, and economic growth. It has reached out on multiple occasions without clear benefit to itself (like the time it made that startling kidnapping admission to Japan) in genuine attempts to engage in dialogue. It has presented South Korea with a plan for a unified peninsula under two states with separate economic systems. It has done much, much more.
Whether or not you're skeptical, you must realize one thing, and that is the fact that all Koreans want reunification. Why else would both regimes have spent 3/4 a century competing with each other for legitimacy? They see the peninsula as one, and it will be so eventually, but not without great struggle. In order for reunification to be successful, all interested parties (U.S., China, Russia, Japan, South Korea, North Korea) must engage each other in real discussions about economic growth, domestic policies, political systems, and strategic military plans (like whether the U.S. would really give up its foothold in the Asia-Pacific region when it wants to be able to face off with China). No dialogue is going to happen if we keep pointing fingers at North Korea, which honestly believes that its nuclear program is the only thing holding the U.S. back from more aggression. Naive perhaps, but we've given it no reason to think otherwise.
It all seems like too much to handle, much less accomplish. Identifying as an American adopted from Korea feels like my left hand is possessed and gripping a knife that's slowly sawing through a self-destructive right hand. Everything I do feels like an act of betraying myself.
I carry an entire country's grief on my shoulders. I didn't realize what this was until someone pointed it out to me - it is han.
Tuesday, March 13, 2012
the dream crusher
You've probably heard of micro-lending, especially after Muhammad Yunus wrote a book about it and won the Nobel Peace Prize. It's touted by conservatives and progressives alike as the route to successfully developing poverty-stricken populations in 3rd world countries. Conservatives like that it works on an individual basis and incentivizes hard work, and progressives like that someone is actually investing in 3rd world countries.
My main point is: It's not the solution to everyone's problems. I can't believe it won the Nobel Prize (I also can't believe Obama won it either before he actually did anything, but that's another story). What's up, Oslo?
But when I bring up downsides and things to watch out for, everyone gets all sour. After some thought, I've decided that it's probably because everyone likes simple answers and solutions. For instance, after watching the KONY 2012 marketing video the entire western world went, "Hey, let's send American troops to go get this guy, and then all the Ugandan children will be saved!" as if spontaneously sending American troops somewhere has ever worked out well for us. Has the practice of critical thinking escaped us all? Even before I went online to get more background on the issues, the video made me so uncomfortable. It was obviously directed at white people with white guilt who love jumping on Kumbaya bandwagons to express how tolerant they are. I watched it and just felt ashamed for all the people of color in the video. "Look how nice these white people are to you," I thought. "Aren't you grateful?" And yes, it's great that everyone cares (because these problems are real), but do you really think the issues are so clear-cut? Did you ever stop to wonder what Ugandans have to say about the issues in their region? Whether the Ugandan army can even be trusted? What sort of power vacuum would open up if Kony were taken down? How old are these events? And while Kony has been torturing and killing people, what other factors have contributed to the Ugandan people's suffering and deaths? Also, the video had a distinctly Christian flavor. Not in its content, necessarily, but how everything was done. It reminded me of the time I put in as an undergrad member of Campus Crusade for Christ. Lots of charismatic people telling you how to care. I'm not sure what to do with that feeling, but it added to my unease.
Back to my point - people don't like gray area. They want clear-cut solutions with direct action, high-tech marketing campaigns, and awareness bracelets. Even though it's probably going to hurt the populations they purport to care about.
Microlending can be highly dangerous if not done the right way. If you're going to invest in a microlending organization, make sure it's a nonprofit. Just because something is an NGO (Non-Government Organization) doesn't mean that it's not trying to generate a profit for its owners. Look into the local business practices of affiliates of the microlending organization you're supporting. What are their real goals? Do they bully borrowers? What happens to borrowers who can't repay their loans? In Bangladesh, one of the women I met bought a cow with a micro-loan. The cow died from disease. She went even further into debt because her interest rates were so high and she had no time or resources to pay back her loan. The same story repeated itself over and over as I interviewed people. Whoever's still touting it as The Solution is not telling the whole story.
Please let me crush your dreams. It's better this way.
Some good Kony articles:
Harry Verhoeven on Facebook
Joshua Keating at Foreign Policy
Racialicious Blog
Some good microlending articles:
The Boston Globe
Bloomberg Business Week
My main point is: It's not the solution to everyone's problems. I can't believe it won the Nobel Prize (I also can't believe Obama won it either before he actually did anything, but that's another story). What's up, Oslo?
But when I bring up downsides and things to watch out for, everyone gets all sour. After some thought, I've decided that it's probably because everyone likes simple answers and solutions. For instance, after watching the KONY 2012 marketing video the entire western world went, "Hey, let's send American troops to go get this guy, and then all the Ugandan children will be saved!" as if spontaneously sending American troops somewhere has ever worked out well for us. Has the practice of critical thinking escaped us all? Even before I went online to get more background on the issues, the video made me so uncomfortable. It was obviously directed at white people with white guilt who love jumping on Kumbaya bandwagons to express how tolerant they are. I watched it and just felt ashamed for all the people of color in the video. "Look how nice these white people are to you," I thought. "Aren't you grateful?" And yes, it's great that everyone cares (because these problems are real), but do you really think the issues are so clear-cut? Did you ever stop to wonder what Ugandans have to say about the issues in their region? Whether the Ugandan army can even be trusted? What sort of power vacuum would open up if Kony were taken down? How old are these events? And while Kony has been torturing and killing people, what other factors have contributed to the Ugandan people's suffering and deaths? Also, the video had a distinctly Christian flavor. Not in its content, necessarily, but how everything was done. It reminded me of the time I put in as an undergrad member of Campus Crusade for Christ. Lots of charismatic people telling you how to care. I'm not sure what to do with that feeling, but it added to my unease.
Back to my point - people don't like gray area. They want clear-cut solutions with direct action, high-tech marketing campaigns, and awareness bracelets. Even though it's probably going to hurt the populations they purport to care about.
Microlending can be highly dangerous if not done the right way. If you're going to invest in a microlending organization, make sure it's a nonprofit. Just because something is an NGO (Non-Government Organization) doesn't mean that it's not trying to generate a profit for its owners. Look into the local business practices of affiliates of the microlending organization you're supporting. What are their real goals? Do they bully borrowers? What happens to borrowers who can't repay their loans? In Bangladesh, one of the women I met bought a cow with a micro-loan. The cow died from disease. She went even further into debt because her interest rates were so high and she had no time or resources to pay back her loan. The same story repeated itself over and over as I interviewed people. Whoever's still touting it as The Solution is not telling the whole story.
Please let me crush your dreams. It's better this way.
Some good Kony articles:
Harry Verhoeven on Facebook
Joshua Keating at Foreign Policy
Racialicious Blog
Some good microlending articles:
The Boston Globe
Bloomberg Business Week
Monday, March 12, 2012
strange relationship twist
I had a really uncomfortable experience this weekend. I went out for "girls' night" (a weird phrase, but what else are you going to call it) with fellow adoptees I've been friends with for six years or so. They're not politicized and their perspective on being adopted is mainly that it's important to learn about Korean culture and figure out who you are - as something that you can "succeed" at dealing with. Except for two of them, they're in their late 30's, are wealthy, and stay at home to raise the kids they have with their white husbands. (The other two are in their early 30's, are not wealthy, have no kids, and are not dating anyone.)
Mr. BearCat was also out and about downtown Minneapolis with his friends, and since he was so close I thought it would be fine for him to stop in and say hello. My friends had been bugging me to meet my "boyfriend" for a long time and I'd demurred, since honestly he has nothing to do with them and it would just be a meeting for curiosity's sake, but on the other hand I wasn't going to go out of my way to avoid it.
So he stopped in. And except for one friend, they all dismissed him. I didn't know what to do. What do you do when your friends are assholes?
I could tell that he wasn't what they were expecting, but I gave them the benefit of the doubt and didn't feel the need to "prep" them. Honestly, if they were really paying attention to me they'd realize that I'm not superficial in the slightest, truly. If I require any credentials that could also be considered superficial, they are not superficial to me. For instance, I want to be with someone who thinks interesting thoughts and can flesh out ideas and build theories. Often, people who frequently engage in this are college educated. Does that make me superficial or snobby? Do I require an actual degree? No, but a degree - especially a graduate degree - demonstrates that someone might be the type of person who is also interested in ideas. It's a good initial indicator. I'm not looking for the degree for the degree's sake - I'm looking for what it might mean about the person who holds it. The same goes for physical fitness - I am attracted to people who take care of themselves, and that's not something I can help. I don't want the title (example: to say, "He runs marathons," as a point of pride rather than interest) for its own sake, but rather for what it indicates.
So I'm not superficial. And Mr. BearCat, who I really like and respect, is not rich. He is not traditionally handsome and does not turn heads on the street. He is not taller than me. He does not have a deep booming voice or a commanding presence. But he is a great person, and I'm insulted that anyone might think that I am "putting up with" his nontraditional qualities; rather, they were never the most relevant qualities to me in the first place. (If they were, I would have stayed married.) Further, even if my friends can't understand why I like him, after a year and a half they can't possibly not see that I do like him, and that is the relevant point. Unless he is abusive or has a drug problem or some other objectively wrong thing, they should support my happiness. They don't have to be friends with him, but they should respect his presence in my life and be kind to him in person when he's there.
I don't understand at all. The only conclusion I can draw is that my friends are superficial and mean. And that's not a conclusion I want to draw.
Actually Mr. BearCat has always thought they were dumb, but he was very respectful to them in person. I've defended them but maybe it's time to stop. It sucks that his friends are a lot cooler than mine.
They came with him to meet up with me, and while I'm sure my friends weren't expecting to meet a whole group, they could have been more gracious. I hadn't expected to have certain additions to my group when I planned ladies' night but I accepted them politely nonetheless. Ultimately what ended up happening is that a group of housewives (married to white men) was rude to a group of (brown male) attorneys. Include the parenthetical information if you think it's relevant. The situation's straight facts are humorous, but I'm so ashamed. I have always, and still do, hate having others' behavior reflect on me. I was all too conscious of how my behavior reflected on my family earlier in my life.
Reasons to not be married, and reasons to not have jerks for friends. Too bad I can only predict one of those.
They came with him to meet up with me, and while I'm sure my friends weren't expecting to meet a whole group, they could have been more gracious. I hadn't expected to have certain additions to my group when I planned ladies' night but I accepted them politely nonetheless. Ultimately what ended up happening is that a group of housewives (married to white men) was rude to a group of (brown male) attorneys. Include the parenthetical information if you think it's relevant. The situation's straight facts are humorous, but I'm so ashamed. I have always, and still do, hate having others' behavior reflect on me. I was all too conscious of how my behavior reflected on my family earlier in my life.
Reasons to not be married, and reasons to not have jerks for friends. Too bad I can only predict one of those.
Sunday, March 11, 2012
brooms
Apparently the "solar flares" (?) made it possible lately to stand a broom on its end... that's what Facebook said anyway. So we tried it. I think it was a hoax (your broom will do this every day), but it's still creepy.
Thursday, March 8, 2012
my holiday
"I might be going to Chicago over St. Paddy's day weekend," said Mr. BearCat.
"You're going out in public on St. Paddy's day?" I asked.
"It's the only weekend my college friends had free, and that's where everyone is going," he said.
"Well... take a picture of the green river for me then, I guess."
FantasticHussy invited me to a St. Paddy's day party at her condo downtown St. Paul, which I have wanted to visit for awhile, but I am ambivalent about going. Showing my face on a holiday when everyone is trying to look as white as possible is not only awkward, it's sometimes scary. Because everyone is drunk and they say things they'd normally keep inside. But you know this.
I still, however, feel like this is my holiday, because before my brain fit into my body I really loved celebrating it. So I keep buying shamrock window decals and putting them up in my various apartments because they make me feel happy. Alone. At home. They wouldn't make me feel happy in public.
"Does your roommate celebrate St. Patrick's day?" a confused Korean friend asked me when she was visiting.
An unfortunate side effect of being raised to love things that don't match your face means that you have to hide parts of what would normally be considered your public self, at home.
"You're going out in public on St. Paddy's day?" I asked.
"It's the only weekend my college friends had free, and that's where everyone is going," he said.
"Well... take a picture of the green river for me then, I guess."
FantasticHussy invited me to a St. Paddy's day party at her condo downtown St. Paul, which I have wanted to visit for awhile, but I am ambivalent about going. Showing my face on a holiday when everyone is trying to look as white as possible is not only awkward, it's sometimes scary. Because everyone is drunk and they say things they'd normally keep inside. But you know this.
I still, however, feel like this is my holiday, because before my brain fit into my body I really loved celebrating it. So I keep buying shamrock window decals and putting them up in my various apartments because they make me feel happy. Alone. At home. They wouldn't make me feel happy in public.
"Does your roommate celebrate St. Patrick's day?" a confused Korean friend asked me when she was visiting.
An unfortunate side effect of being raised to love things that don't match your face means that you have to hide parts of what would normally be considered your public self, at home.
Wednesday, March 7, 2012
jeju-do
I took a moment today to mourn. Gureombi, the volcanic rock shore near Gandjeong village on Jeju island off the southern tip of South Korea, is being blasted away so that the South Korean military can construct a naval base. Jeju island is a UNESCO world heritage site. It is home to unique varieties of fish and coral reefs. Gureombi beach is like a family member to Gangjeong village residents, who live on and eat from the ocean, and who have spent their entire lives visiting the volcanic rock. 94% of Gangjeong residents are against the naval base and have spent years campaigning against it, but the government has proceeded anyway, claiming that it followed all legal processes for gaining permission to build there. The island residents' trauma is exacerbated by their living memories of the massacre that took place on their island, when tens of thousands of citizens were killed by the government in response to their "left-leaning politics" following WWII. A national security law was passed, most of which still holds today, which allowed for the imprisonment of anyone who mentioned the Jeju massacre.
Why does the government was a naval base there so badly? It maintains that it is not for strategic missile defense, but if you look at Jeju island's position on a map, the reason is obvious.
This is another tragic example of the effects of militarism on the Korean peninsula. These destructive policies are visited on the bodies and minds of the people and on the land itself. As a fellow physical manifestation of the ongoing Korean war, I say the war needs to end, now.
Why does the government was a naval base there so badly? It maintains that it is not for strategic missile defense, but if you look at Jeju island's position on a map, the reason is obvious.
This is another tragic example of the effects of militarism on the Korean peninsula. These destructive policies are visited on the bodies and minds of the people and on the land itself. As a fellow physical manifestation of the ongoing Korean war, I say the war needs to end, now.
Tuesday, March 6, 2012
no post today because...
I had to finish watching Season 2 of "Downton Abbey" before PBS took the streaming episodes off its website today. Priorities, people.
Monday, March 5, 2012
the happiness project
A friend who also works in the legal sweatshop field asked for my address one day. A week later, this book appeared in the mail. I looked at it suspiciously. A self-help book? By a lawyer who clerked for Sandra Day O'Connor before launching a successful career as a writer? There can't possibly be anything wrong with her life.
Also, I am happy, dammit.
As it turned out, there was nothing wrong with her life. She has a nice husband, two daughters, a great job doing what she loves, and she lives in a nice apartment in New York City. But just like me, she has Type A tendencies to overthink things, to forget that people are more important than deadlines, and various other disability-abilities. So obviously she launched a thoroughly-researched, well-planned endeavor to increase her happiness level. And she documented every bit of it for one year.
She covered a specific area of her life every month - money, love, health, etc. - and cumulatively by the end of the year she was supposed to have "succeeded" at everything. I'm not sure how she did because I haven't finished it yet, but the book spent a year on the New York Times bestseller list so we know that her career category was a win.
I appreciated how methodical she was. It will drive you nuts if you are the sort of person who thinks taking photos detracts from the moment, or if you don't keep a personal calendar. But if you alphabetize your music collection and write, "Brush the cat," in your planner every Sunday, then you will probably appreciate her style too.
The one nagging thing I couldn't forget while I was reading it is that she is incredibly privileged. Sometimes it seems like she has no idea what's out there for people who are less intelligent, attractive, motivated, wealthy, and white than her. Some of the things she worries about are pretty shallow. Also, the idea of the project itself could only have been generated by someone who has time to believe that happiness is A) attainable, and B) something she deserves. Who can think about being happy when there are so many other things to worry about? But she comes from the perspective that this is her life, so she is going to approach happiness her way, and well... I can't stop her. Privilege at its finest.
Her research was interesting, her writing is good, and I will finish the book if I can find the time.
Also, I am happy, dammit.
As it turned out, there was nothing wrong with her life. She has a nice husband, two daughters, a great job doing what she loves, and she lives in a nice apartment in New York City. But just like me, she has Type A tendencies to overthink things, to forget that people are more important than deadlines, and various other disability-abilities. So obviously she launched a thoroughly-researched, well-planned endeavor to increase her happiness level. And she documented every bit of it for one year.
She covered a specific area of her life every month - money, love, health, etc. - and cumulatively by the end of the year she was supposed to have "succeeded" at everything. I'm not sure how she did because I haven't finished it yet, but the book spent a year on the New York Times bestseller list so we know that her career category was a win.
I appreciated how methodical she was. It will drive you nuts if you are the sort of person who thinks taking photos detracts from the moment, or if you don't keep a personal calendar. But if you alphabetize your music collection and write, "Brush the cat," in your planner every Sunday, then you will probably appreciate her style too.
The one nagging thing I couldn't forget while I was reading it is that she is incredibly privileged. Sometimes it seems like she has no idea what's out there for people who are less intelligent, attractive, motivated, wealthy, and white than her. Some of the things she worries about are pretty shallow. Also, the idea of the project itself could only have been generated by someone who has time to believe that happiness is A) attainable, and B) something she deserves. Who can think about being happy when there are so many other things to worry about? But she comes from the perspective that this is her life, so she is going to approach happiness her way, and well... I can't stop her. Privilege at its finest.
Her research was interesting, her writing is good, and I will finish the book if I can find the time.
Sunday, March 4, 2012
cebull. cebull be racist. be, racist, be.
Did you hear about the federal judge in Montana who sent an email with a racist joke involving bestiality and Obama's mother to six "old buddies?" If you didn't, now you have.
Of course there's the expected post-event battle between supporters of the judge and offended groups, but neither seems to be communicating the real problem very well. Sure, Judge Cebull is probably a very personable, collegial man, and he probably has enough sense not to make racist jokes in public, and one mistake should not define a person's entire life.
But Judge Cebull stated that he "didn't send it as racist, although that's what it is. I sent it out because it's anti-Obama." Later, he said, "If anything, it's political." He argued that his conduct over the years has shown that he is not "a racist."
And that, my friends, is exactly what is wrong.
In the minds of the general public, racism consists of individual outward acts. Behavior. People believe that if you can manage to overcome your initial behavioral urges (like clutching your purse when a black man walks by), you have "overcome racism." This task is now considered one of many things the modern individual must do to be considered morally right. "Racist" has somehow ended up in the same category as "wife beater" and "communist." It has been too easy to relegate real evaluations of this issue to a black and white moral dichotomy with a simple test: Am I mean to brown people and not white people?
And in fact, I'd go so far as to say that some people do not even keep this test in mind, but rather expect that "racism" would physically manifest itself somewhere on their body like a health issue. If you don't ever "come down with it," or if you don't see a malignant growth on your foot, you don't have it. So you don't have to think about it. It's something that troubles other, less fortunate people, and since you don't hang out with any racists you couldn't possibly have contracted it.
Another form of the test is: Do I have any brown friends or family members? Yes? Then I couldn't possibly have racism. Whew. I can use this as proof when other people ask.
This seems to be the depth of the discussion surrounding Cebull's behavior. People are searching for examples of his prior behavior, scanning for indicia of racism. Since he is a federal judge, his potential bias as the decider of people's lives is relevant. But the discussion has an obvious outcome, and that is this: Cebull is racist. Does that mean he has been a bad judge? Not necessarily. It appears on the surface that he has successfully managed his own tendencies in the decisions he's written on the federal bench. But the mere fact that he sent that email without considering that comparing a black man to an animal who mated with a white woman (resulting in the President of the United States) is a horribly offensive, racially-charged scenario... means that he's racist. If you don't have any second thoughts about something so obvious, then your view of the world is skewed. And that particular brand of "skewing" is known as - you guessed it - racism. Will he be a good judge in the future? All this incident has shown us is that, like 90% of other judges, he has realized that it is personally beneficial to avoid any outward signs of racism. And in his caseload as a judge, he will try not to take any actions that clearly demonstrate his racism. Is that safety net good enough?
For this conversation to be productive and for his apology to mean anything, needs to own his racism and stop telling everyone that he is not "a racist." What do racists look like? Not all of them have swastika tattoos. We all need to own our racism. It's not the end of the world. Very few people get disowned for being racist. It's a very serious issue, but somehow the seriousness of it has created a culture of avoidance - we give it such a wide berth that no one knows what it looks like any more. We only recognize it in its extremity, and that is a travesty. It's like deciding that only cancer deserves our attention, when the flu affects more people, is still awful, and also has the potential to kill you.
There's not an easy fix like some seem to believe (ex: the behavior test above), but it is clear that choosing not to see it only harms people. And that is the real moral test. Are you willing to work further on yourself instead of merely changing some outward behavior and calling it a day?
If everyone got to the point and just agreed that yes, Cebull exhibited racist behavior (and thus is racist), then they could move on to the more pressing issue: what should be done?
Of course there's the expected post-event battle between supporters of the judge and offended groups, but neither seems to be communicating the real problem very well. Sure, Judge Cebull is probably a very personable, collegial man, and he probably has enough sense not to make racist jokes in public, and one mistake should not define a person's entire life.
But Judge Cebull stated that he "didn't send it as racist, although that's what it is. I sent it out because it's anti-Obama." Later, he said, "If anything, it's political." He argued that his conduct over the years has shown that he is not "a racist."
And that, my friends, is exactly what is wrong.
In the minds of the general public, racism consists of individual outward acts. Behavior. People believe that if you can manage to overcome your initial behavioral urges (like clutching your purse when a black man walks by), you have "overcome racism." This task is now considered one of many things the modern individual must do to be considered morally right. "Racist" has somehow ended up in the same category as "wife beater" and "communist." It has been too easy to relegate real evaluations of this issue to a black and white moral dichotomy with a simple test: Am I mean to brown people and not white people?
And in fact, I'd go so far as to say that some people do not even keep this test in mind, but rather expect that "racism" would physically manifest itself somewhere on their body like a health issue. If you don't ever "come down with it," or if you don't see a malignant growth on your foot, you don't have it. So you don't have to think about it. It's something that troubles other, less fortunate people, and since you don't hang out with any racists you couldn't possibly have contracted it.
Another form of the test is: Do I have any brown friends or family members? Yes? Then I couldn't possibly have racism. Whew. I can use this as proof when other people ask.
This seems to be the depth of the discussion surrounding Cebull's behavior. People are searching for examples of his prior behavior, scanning for indicia of racism. Since he is a federal judge, his potential bias as the decider of people's lives is relevant. But the discussion has an obvious outcome, and that is this: Cebull is racist. Does that mean he has been a bad judge? Not necessarily. It appears on the surface that he has successfully managed his own tendencies in the decisions he's written on the federal bench. But the mere fact that he sent that email without considering that comparing a black man to an animal who mated with a white woman (resulting in the President of the United States) is a horribly offensive, racially-charged scenario... means that he's racist. If you don't have any second thoughts about something so obvious, then your view of the world is skewed. And that particular brand of "skewing" is known as - you guessed it - racism. Will he be a good judge in the future? All this incident has shown us is that, like 90% of other judges, he has realized that it is personally beneficial to avoid any outward signs of racism. And in his caseload as a judge, he will try not to take any actions that clearly demonstrate his racism. Is that safety net good enough?
For this conversation to be productive and for his apology to mean anything, needs to own his racism and stop telling everyone that he is not "a racist." What do racists look like? Not all of them have swastika tattoos. We all need to own our racism. It's not the end of the world. Very few people get disowned for being racist. It's a very serious issue, but somehow the seriousness of it has created a culture of avoidance - we give it such a wide berth that no one knows what it looks like any more. We only recognize it in its extremity, and that is a travesty. It's like deciding that only cancer deserves our attention, when the flu affects more people, is still awful, and also has the potential to kill you.
There's not an easy fix like some seem to believe (ex: the behavior test above), but it is clear that choosing not to see it only harms people. And that is the real moral test. Are you willing to work further on yourself instead of merely changing some outward behavior and calling it a day?
If everyone got to the point and just agreed that yes, Cebull exhibited racist behavior (and thus is racist), then they could move on to the more pressing issue: what should be done?
Thursday, March 1, 2012
coworkers at large
One of my coworkers clipped his nails at his desk yesterday. His desk is 3 feet away from me. I am sure I got hit with errant nails.
Another coworker brought a copy of the "Magnificat" to work, and no it does not look like this:
Another coworker brought a copy of the "Magnificat" to work, and no it does not look like this:
That coworker also wears the Catholic saint necklace tags around his neck. I don't know how else to explain them. When I was in grade school I noticed my best friend's grandma wearing them and the best explanation I got was, "If you die in your sleep and you're wearing these, you'll go to heaven." Like the Catholic version of holy underwear, I guess. They look like rectangular portraits covered in plastic, backed with felt, and you wear them under your shirt front and back.
Over half of my coworkers are grossly obese. I don't mean pleasantly plump like a grandma. I mean they look like they would have to buy 2 airplane seats. And while I know that A) some people have thyroid and other disorders, and B) it's a free country and you can eat whatever you want, it makes me very anxious. Very anxious. Why are there so many giant people? Why are they all working with me? The predominance of one sort of person in what should be a fairly neutral work environment should make you consider the idea that something else might be going on. Is it because we are in the suburbs? I get weird looks from drivers when I go for a 30 minute walk at lunch every day. Moving yourself from one place to another via your own physical power does not seem to be very popular out there.
The man next to me - I kid you not - leaned over today and said angrily, "Did you have to park further from the door this morning? It's that damn new project, all those people are here."
There are probably only 20 more cars in the giant lot, which meant that he had to walk at most 15 feet extra this morning. He looked at me expectantly.
"Um, yeah, I think I did," I said.
I have to get out of here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)