Tuesday, December 20, 2011

kim jong-il

Not "Kim Jong Two" like a small-town radio station reported, but "Kim Jong-Il," the Dear Leader of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea. Update: Rick Perry just made the same gaffe.

Kim Jong-Il may have made decisions that had disastrous consequences for his people, but let's remember that the U.S. (we?) isn't blameless either. How did we end up here, a place where U.S. Facebook pages erupt in posts like, "Ding dong the witch is dead" and "I'm ronery" when the leader of a country we inadvertently created dies?

At the end of World War II, someone suggested splitting occupation of the Korean peninsula between the U.S. and the Soviet Union along the 38th parallel and bam, it was done. No deep thoughts about the ramifications, and no one consulted the Koreans, who obviously opposed another foreign occupation after enduring years of Japanese oppression (see: comfort women, who are now in their 80's and 90's). As cold war tensions increased, communication was cut off between the northern and southern halves of the peninsula and each half was pressured into the political ideology of its occupiers. When I say "pressured" I actually mean forced - in the south, the U.S. assassinated the Korean democratically-elected leader and put its American-educated dummy, Syngman Rhee, in power, along with reinstating the ruling Japanese that remained and their Korean collaborators. The U.S. basically stepped right into the oppressive infrastructure that the Japanese created, and we (they?) never left. You know the U.S. military base near Itaewon shopping district in Seoul? Built by the Japanese.

Obviously a lot of other things happened in this time period too, like uprisings and the resulting massacres, the U.S. reneging on its agreement with the Soviets, and things like that. But above are the main points.

With the hope of unifying the peninsula (and ridding it of Japanese collaborators, who were now back in charge in the south if you recall), the north invaded the south. A lot of bad things happened. Obviously. You're probably aware of the fact that the front line moved up and down the peninsula like a tide. I think that's what shows up in the history books. At the end of this U.S. "police action" (brilliant, Truman), 2.5 million Koreans and 37,000 Americans were killed. 97% of the infrastructure in the north was destroyed. During the war the U.S. dropped a quarter of a million pounds of napalm on Korea every day. We (and South Korean collaborators) massacred thousands of civilians fleeing the north because of an anti-communist U.S. military policy guided by paranoia and racism. We massacred civilians for no reason at all, most notably at Sinchon. One of my friends who has visited North Korea went to the Sinchon memorial - it looks like the Holocaust museum in D.C. - and spoke with two of the three survivors still living. The north committed its fair share of ideologically-based atrocities, but came nowhere near the U.S. and the south's crimes, either in frequency or scale.

And at the end of all this? The U.S. and North Korea signed the 1953 armistice treaty. South Korea was not party to it, and everything you hear in the news about the Koreas still being at war is inaccurate - the U.S. and North Korea must sign the peace treaty ending the war. WE are at war with North Korea. We have no interest in signing a peace treaty - the armistice provides the U.S. an excuse to remain heavily involved in the region. As Secretary Clinton recently said herself, America has enduring interests in Asia and intends to stay. In fact, the head of the South Korean military is not a Korean but in fact an American. Given the recent death of Kim Jong-Il, I'm guessing that any plans to hand control back to the Koreans have gone out the window.

Consequences of the war: the most heavily-militarized border in the world today is in Korea. Both Koreas, governed by nationalist hawks (obviously in the north, but less-obviously in the south), spend most of their domestic budgets on military expenditures. South Korea was pretty much a military dictatorship until the 1980's, when real democratic elections happened for the first time. And because of all that military spending, South Korea's social welfare budget is almost nonexistent. The right word might be "laughable" if the consequences weren't so specific to me. If only single mothers could afford to keep their children, and if only Korean culture weren't mired in militaristic paternalistic obsession. If only real dissidents were given a voice and society loosened up. (South Korean news sources are forbidden, under the National Security Laws, to say anything good about North Korea. These laws are used to silence any sort of progressive movement for peace.)

So that's how we ended up here. Korea was a cold war test case, a peninsula caught in the middle of paranoid superpower swagger. Obviously, we didn't learn anything by the time we went to Vietnam, which is the war that sticks in our collective memory but which was far less relevant in terms of its lasting effects on U.S. foreign policy and military structures and strategies.

And today we still do not do right by the Korean peninsula. Conservatives and evangelical Christians are calling for regime change in North Korea, and while their focus on starvation and individual [religious] freedoms has merit, there are right and wrong ways to do things, and let me just get this out there in case you weren't clear: whenever the U.S. goes anywhere for its own ends and takes matters into its own hands, it's a disaster. It is possible to support the Korean peninsula (reunification!) without going batshit crazy on it like we (you) did 60 years ago. I won't go into too much detail on it right now because I have other points I want to make, but food aid is a start. And yes, the food does get to the civilians. It's a gross-tasting corn-soy blend that no one but the starving would want to eat, so it can't be diverted to military ends. Also, aid groups have developed accountability systems to make sure it goes to the right mouths. KoreAm article here. We've seen this situation in the past - denying food aid and applying sanctions only hurts the most vulnerable. This siege approach violates the Geneva Convention and constitutes a war crime. How about we stop doing that.

"After scanning through FB posts ranging from 'Ding dong the witch is dead' and calls for Kim Jong Eun's head, I just can't stomach the blood-drenched war hawk cries of fellow adoptees, adoptive parents who benefited from U.S. militarism (lest we forget where adoption came from in the first place!), and the painful dearth of historically responsible analysis." - Colleague1

So what would you do if you knew the U.S. had it in for you and from everything you and everyone you know has experienced, you believed the U.S. couldn't be trusted? I'm not saying Kim Jong-Il wasn't a terrible person, but the way he is depicted by our government and in our media echoes everything we've done in the past to dehumanize our enemies in order to legitimize our unconscionable behavior toward them. Whatever the Dear Leader was, I'm saying that we're not all bright and shiny either. We try to forget that Kim Jong-Il was a real person. He raised his kids as he saw fit, liked film, and had a giant ego, probably because everyone told him he was awesome all the time (this was also my problem at an early age). Policy-wise, he formed the Three Charters for National Reunification and proposed a two-system single-state model for a Korean federation. The south's Sunshine Policy (much-derided, but it opened up the DPRK to outsiders) emerged on the heels of this work and the adoption of the June 15 Joint Declaration soon followed. (Credits to Colleague1 for this analysis). Also, I'm pretty sure the Sunshine Policy wasn't "inherently flawed," but rather South Korean president Lee Myung-Bak killed it.

So I am more than perturbed to see Facebook and Twitter go all exultant on the news of Kim Jong-Il's death. It's comparable to when we captured Saddam Hussein, and actually the death of either will have little effect on the future lives of the people they ruled. In Kim Jong-Il's case, the power structures his father put in place and which he solidified are still in place. He has been planning his succession for awhile; everyone there knows what to do. In Saddam's case, the power structures in Iraq had already been demolished. And yet in both cases the stupid American people feel like all of a sudden their lives are different and it's time to run around all gleeful. What has changed now, in reality, is only a small potential - one more check on a checklist.

And again, we're forgetting about who started all of this. Our glee is misplaced. It's as if we think the U.S. never had anything to do with the suffering of the North Korean people, and we were just waiting here all this time for an opportunity to show them our benevolence and goodwill. Also, our satire.

F*ck that.

The whole thing kind of makes me hate myself for adopting the U.S. as my country. I identify as an American. And that confuses me, because the American part of me killed the Korean part of me. More than once.

No comments: