Apparently you lose your "street cred" when people find out you have white parents. I'm not really Asian? Then what am I? I'm definitely not white. And no matter who my parents were, I still feel personally targeted when a professor says, "What sort of people might an organization be discriminating against if it requires applicants to be able to lift 100 lbs?"
Student: "The elderly?"
Professor: "Riiiight... and Asians!"
The class is dumbfounded. The professor continues. "Because they're small!" She notices an Asian girl in the front row, and says, "Oh, sorry!"
The white students laugh nervously and brush it off. Later, the Asian students in class tell other Asian students, and they all conclude that, "That is wrong in so many ways."
I do agree that having white parents gives me an inside look into the dominant American culture. That's an edge, especially when knowing what people in power care about or expect of you gets you an interview. I speak Minnesotan, but it's becoming my own flavor of Minnesotan. And while I know I can probably find something in common with almost everyone (like my case partner who is male, white, blonde, obsessed with pro sports teams, voted for John McCain, and has never left the country but who I do like), I have a preference for people who the world treats similarly, or who treat the world similarly.
In different situations sometimes this is women (but not all women or no men). Sometimes it is people of color (but not all people of color or no whites). Sometimes it is students (but not all students). I guess the more I distinguish myself, the less "like other [women/Asians/students]" I will be.
I am most comfortable with people "like me" (who isn't?) and it is disturbing to hear that I am not, in fact, who I think I am. Or that suddenly my arguments carry less weight. If someone told my mother that she couldn't be a good authority on motherhood because she didn't actually give birth to me, she'd have to laugh at them. She's certainly a mother, and mine specifically.
I have similar feelings about being told that I am not really Asian, or that I can't provide any valid insight into the Asian-American experience. I'm just a farm girl running around the big city, all excited and trying to jump on the persecuted bandwagon. (It would be more apt to describe my fellow Catholic students who constantly bring up their perilous position in the world that way. While they might have sympathy for overseas Christians in repressive societies, complaining makes them look silly here.)
I am acquainted with living proof that having Asian parents does not make one more knowledgeable or reflective about being Asian. Yes, my friend can tell you about her life if you ask, but her experience is just that: hers. And we are treated similarly by sometimes well-meaning (sometimes not) individuals who see both of us as "other."
Until they find out that I have white parents, in which case I can hear them thinking, "Oh, you're just like me inside!" No, I'm not. My physical appearance and personal history have compelled me to seek out enlightening/disturbing knowledge that further informs my experience, marking me forever "inside." I see the world differently. Don't touch it.
"You don't seem like other Asians" will never be a compliment. In so many ways.
No comments:
Post a Comment