Tuesday, November 8, 2011

clarification: korean adoption is political

This is a complex issue to talk about, simply because there are so many different forces at play and I don't know which ones have blown you around, but in short, I'd like to clarify my position on Korean adoption. Again. I know I do this like every six months or so.

For some reason (actually, I know the reason), the issue - as it were - has gotten framed in a way that is personalized to adoptees themselves, respectively. I can't have an opinion without someone attributing it to my experience as an adoptee. In others' eyes, because I want to address injustices in the Korean adoption phenomenon, I must be "angry," as an identity. It must be that either my adoptive parents failed, or I am just inherently messed up. I am not allowed to separate my personal experience from my analyses of the geopolitical forces causing my existence. Many adoptees themselves shy away from thinking more deeply about their origins because of this polarization.

While I am often very frustrated by the actions of adoptive parents, this is a minor subcategory in the big topic of "should Korean adoption occur." The merits (or not) of adoptive parents in America have wholly to do with white privilege and American race-relations, and their effects on the respective identities of the children adopted. When I am angry because of parents, I am frustrated because of two things: poor personal choices (they are accountable for these) and collective public ignorance, usually race-based. 

But on to the bigger picture. There are many reasons why I, personally, am here in a sunny Minnesotan coffeeshop drinking a dairy beverage. One of them is that my Minnesotan adoptive parents decided to adopt a child from an Asian country. But even had they not decided that they were multicultural global citizens who wanted to enlarge their family of 2, I would still have ended up in a western, predominantly white nation. Probably the U.S., but maybe somewhere in Scandanavia. This is what I'm really focusing on. And this is what scares people, and makes them label me an "angry" adoptee. Because I see the origins of my synthetic identity, and I hold that they are unjust. 

Because I believe that Korean adoption has to end, I am dismissed as angry. My logical conclusions are disregarded and pathologized. In people's simple mental schemas, I cannot both love my family and believe that in a better world I would never have known them. And so the work that I do to transform the Korean adoption trend is considered an act against the family I have today.

This issue is too nuanced (you'd be surprised) for many to grasp. It might be easiest to explain by answering a few basic questions that I have heard.

(God meant for you to be here.) Well, I guess I'm not going to answer the God part. There's too much of a Western superiority complex going on there. And too much helplessness. And superstition (which is the same thing as helplessness, in my opinion). 

(Aren't you grateful to them for taking you in?) Ultimately, yes. They didn't have to. And just as anyone is grateful to their parents for feeding, hugging, and listening to them, I am also. But - and this will make them sad - I think I am a little more grateful to them for doing those things than someone born to the parents who raised them, because it was always a choice. The problem with asking this question at all is that it limits to the issue to that of personal experience, and it presupposes that I was an orphan just floating around in space, waiting for a family. That I was born an orphan. What I am currently working to change are the forces that made me and many others into "orphans." An orphan I was not. My birth mother was alive. The word itself is manipulative.

Most people presuppose that, just as they can decide to wear brown socks with their brown shoes, most choices they make in life are personal. And while it ultimately was a personal decision to adopt (and for some birth mothers a personal decision to relinquish their children), there are always socio-political forces at play affecting the viability and attractiveness of certain choices. For many reasons (including American race-relations, the worries of black social workers, American Indian tribal rights, the after-effects of war on the Korean peninsula, a socially conservative Korean society, a militaristic Korean budget that dwarfed social welfare policies, American imperialism, financial incentives for private agencies in an unregulated adoption industry, and Christian actors)... Korean children became available, and western families became aware of them. In the early 1980's when I shipped out, Korean adoption was in full swing. It's far too simplistic to say that I ended up here because my birth mother "couldn't" keep me, and my adoptive parents wanted to enlarge their family. To state it in those terms is to deny that Korean adoption is political. Let me say that again: Korean adoption is political. So my main point under this paragraph is that at the very end of the process, after all those other geopolitical forces had their way with me, I was lucky to end up with a high-quality family. Who perhaps naively didn't think about any of these things back in the early 1980's, but my perspective is that you can't blame people for what they don't know, as long as they keep trying to know and have the best intentions. No one should be judged forever on the first decision they make, as long as they continue to make decisions. 

(Isn't it better here?) In Minnesota? In America? Undoubtedly, millions of people try and have tried to get here, and I got here with no effort of my own before I even knew what was up. But again, this is the wrong question. Rather than framing the issue as no Barbie dolls vs. 20 Barbie dolls and the Barbie mansion (which I  actually had), we should remember that the first priority of families is to remain together. In war, in peace, in poverty, in wealth, over time, and through internal differences, families try to remain together. It's a sign of societal health if families who want to achieve this actually do. It's a sign of societal failure when a country ships out, nay sells, its children. Adoption from South Korea has generated over $6 billion in revenue. The South Korean government, which spends the least of all OECD nations on social welfare, pays single mothers less than $50/month in support of their children. Top that off with social mores that belong in 1950's America and you have an extremely oppressive situation for single mothers. If anything, it's better here in Minnesota than it is in Korea for family preservation. I am extremely angry with South Korea not only for its internal social failures, but for its manipulative use of children as goodwill ambassadors to the Western nations on which it relied for support after the war and beyond.

Adoption from South Korea, as a system, has to stop. Adoption from other countries needs to be reformed to comply with international standards for child welfare, like the Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (which the U.S. has not signed by the way, because we are unilateral turds). That teenage Guatemalan child you have? Probably stolen. Just saying. I'm sure she loves you, but somewhere out there there's a Guatemalan family with a big hole in their hearts. And the only way for adoptive parents to know that bringing someone else's child into their family really was for the best is to work toward transparency and higher standards in the transnational adoption process. Honestly, I don't know how anyone could disagree with this.

It is irresponsible, and almost evil, to behave like the end justifies the means in completing your family. My choice to examine the bigger picture is not a rejection of the blessings my adoptive family has given me, but is actually the use of those gifts for good.

No comments: