Idealistically, I started making (what I thought was going to be) a short list of the essential questions for a dating site. I knew the list was absolutely unscientific, because I have only seen one dating site and that was 5 years ago when I helped a friend create a profile. But I thought that if everyone was honest about these things (and included a photo), there would be hope.List:
A) How funny do your friends think you are on a scale of 1-10?
B) How funny do strangers think you are on a scale of 1-10?
C) How kind are you on a scale of 1-10?
D) How athletic are you on a scale of 1-10?
E) How competent at life management are you on a scale of 1-10?
F) What ratio of "adventure" to "routine" activities would you prefer in your life?
G) How energetic are you on a scale of 1-10?
H) Do you have any criminal convictions? What are they?
I) Have you ever intentionally hit another person outside of an athletic activity? If so, why?
J) List your allergies
K) On a scale of 1-10, how likely to bring up a disagreement?
L) What ratio of personal time to social time do you prefer?
M) How satisfied are you with compromise on a scale of 1-10?
N) Do you engage in any religious rituals?
O) Income range
P) Sum of your debts
Q) How often do you visit / speak with family members?
R) Race / ethnicity
S) Hobbies
T) Height & Weight
U) Current / aspired number and type of pets
V) Education level
W) Current / aspired number and gender/age of children
X) Why did the chicken cross the road?
Y) Personal hygiene level on a scale of 1-10
Z) What was the length of your longest prior relationship? Have you ever been engaged or divorced?
I started out with very general lifestyle preference questions, but then realized that very specific items might be dealbreakers for some people, so I lengthened my list to include things like race/ethnicity, religion, or smoking habits. Then I derailed into trying to figure out what dealbreakers might be. I thought it was enough to list them and let people self-select out of dating vegetarians, but then I realized that a lot of people don't know themselves well enough to understand what is actually a dealbreaker for them. What you think is a dealbreaker might actually become your bread and butter. I wouldn't date a smoker, but I did date one and didn't mind it. I have no idea if I would date a guy with kids. It would probably depend on the guy and the kids.
I tried answering for Mr.BearCat. Would I choose to meet him? Maybe. Maybe not. The pretend answers I attributed to him were still so vague that I couldn't figure out what sort of personality would be attached to a nonsmoking Asian lawyer whose friends think he is funny. By trying to avoid specific and limiting questions ("Do you like to hike?") I had actually created an extremely nondescript profile generator.
My conclusion is that unless you have very narrowly tailored interests that take up all your time (video games, marathon running), encompass all your life goals (Catholicism and 10 kids), or you never leave your house, you're better off meeting people in person. Online dating sites are good for weeding out the weirdos but not good at all at predicting matches, because there's no real way to account for personality unless everyone wrote an essay (and then some people don't prefer writers). And since you can weed out weirdos in person... you might as well leave your house, if you're capable of such things.
The only downside to meeting people in person is that there is no physical signifier for "dating." Just because someone isn't married doesn't mean they're looking for a significant other.
So, there is no real conclusion. Just, "Good luck LittleBoy. I wish there was more control I could exert over the universe to make the world make more sense for you." Also, "Invest in a good haircut and some nice shoes."













