I've expressed an opinion or two about modern art before. I still think the Weisman has "evil metallic orifices" and the Walker is nothing more than "a giant silver ice-cube with rippled edges, poised to roll down the hill onto unsuspecting drivers making their daily commute along I-94."I'm going to alter my position and place it into a larger context. One that allows me to hate modern art but still maintain my forward-thinking self worth.
The family went to the Minneapolis Institute of Art on Sunday to celebrate MotherDearest's birthday. After we appreciated Rembrandt and the "Holiday Traditions" tour we stumbled into the modern gallery. Everyone except LittleBoy did an about-face upon seeing the garbage-bag tapestry and the notebook paper string.
LittleBoy, in his excitement, managed to attract the attention of a poorly-groomed museum docent who insisted on explaining his understanding of the meaning of modern art to us while we nodded and edged toward the door. Pretty much it boiled down to, "You can't tell that it's art because you live in it. Wait 50 years. Campbell's Soup cans."
My theory: Modern art is art, but not because someone has pulled an explanation out of their ass that's good enough to fool critics. And/or the public. Modern art is art because people experience it whether the explanation is good, bad, or nonexistent.
Slight digression - the First Amendment protects most human expression, which includes both speech and conduct. (The limits on what it protects have to do with public safety and things like that. No "expressing" your freedom by making death threats.) In order for something to be considered "expression," someone has to intend to communicate. It all revolves around the human experience.
Similarly, I think that art is only art because people experience it. If art happens in a forest and no one is there to hear/see/feel/smell it, it didn't really happen. This is how "found art" can be art - it becomes art the minute a human decides it affects his/her experience of life. That it means something. This is why the Weisman and the Walker are art. Because they give me nasty feelings.
I can appreciate someone's ability to bullshit their way through an explanation of why an entirely blank canvas is art, but I don't have to think it's great or that they have any artistic talent at all. They might have experiential talent, in that they can make themselves feel expansive by staring at nothing. But I reserve the right to recognize that ability and not their painting skills.
I also reserve the right to dislike modern art as an entire genre and still appreciate the experience that art in the modern world gives me. My school's architecture? Love it. The design of my easy-to-use wallet? *Almost* priceless. The trees in my neighborhood? Perfect "found art."
David's backside: a much better surprise than the plastic bag tapestry.
1 comment:
Looked at from the right angle, the Walker is really and ARF (Angry Robot Face). You've inspired me. I'm gonna write my own essay on modern art. I've got quite a few things to say about it.
Post a Comment