Thursday, February 9, 2012

marriage amendment, my ass

I am terribly, horribly nervous about the MN marriage amendment on the ballot next November.

It will read, "Shall the Minnesota Constitution be amended to provide that only a union of one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in Minnesota?"

On its face it sounds only mildly discriminatory, as if the amendment is merely asking voters to affirm that marriage between a man and woman is, in fact, a marriage, and any incidental exclusion that occurs is unfortunate but a minor issue.

NO!

How is my grandmother supposed to know to vote "no" on this? If you sat her down and asked point blank, "Should we change our state constitution to say that your grandson should never ever be able to marry his partner? This is nearly impossible to revoke, and there are already Minnesotan laws against same-sex marriage," she'd say no.

If you asked her, "Is real marriage between men and women?" she'd say yes. Because those marriages are real. Also.

Why the hell is this on our ballot?

Issue 1: One should never legislate by subjecting the human rights of a minority to the passions of the majority.  This is where famous civil rights court cases come from. There is a reason why we put smart people in the judicial branch - so they can hold onto their heads when the rest of us are on fire. Stupid, unconstitutional laws exist. Judges are there to say so, and the rest of the reasonable people understand after a few decades of justice. Loving v. Virginia. Brown v. Board of Education. And for a current example, see the University of North Dakota's return to using "fighting sioux" as its mascot. In a 2007 study, 21 Native American related UND programs opposed the use of this image and name, and none supported it. But it was put to a state-wide vote, which statistically means that the tribes were subject to the whim of the 94.6% North Dakotans who are non-Native. If that wasn't a foregone conclusion, I dont know what would be.

Issue 2: This. Is. Permanent. There is already a MN law that exists stating that marriage is only between a man and a woman. This constitutional amendment would only serve to kick people that are already down. And it is nearly impossible to "un-do" constitutional amendments. This is an extreme measure that only accomplishes one thing - discrimination. There's no economic benefit. There's no social benefit.

Issue 3: Governing via constitutional amendment lacks serious foresight. Look what happened to California after they decided to amend their constitution to limit property taxes. All of a sudden, no money! (And they were surprised?) Years later, after they studied economics, they realized that all the variables they'd depended on had changed and they'd made a poor decision. If we want our constitution to last for all time, then we have to stop enshrining partisanally-motivated trendy taglines in it. Bigger picture, people.

So why is this amendment on our ballot? Pure hate? Ignorance? I think it's a combination of the two, plus ego - local republicans want to leave a permanent mark, so they're trying to pee all over our constitution like it's their personal fire hydrant. Also, they have to appease the crazies if they want enough votes to win republican seats in future elections.

And one final thing. Catholic Archbishop Nienstedt. Buddy needs to chill out. A far cry from the much-loved, incredibly wise Archbishop Harry Flynn, whose shoes were too big for Nienstedt to fill. This current archbishop has made it is very personal, very specific goal to crush same-sex-marriage. If it's the last thing he does, he's going to make sure the whole state lives his way. He's deliberately inciting his sheep to believe that same-sex marriage will encroach on religious liberty, as if the government was planning to somehow force priests to perform religious ceremonies.

Whenever LGBT rights come up, somehow the discussion veers into the weird terrain of whether homosexuality, in general, is ok. Really, that's what we're talking about? But yes. So when kids in Michele Bachmann's school district begin to commit suicide in double digits because their district lives under a "neutrality" policy that bars teachers from interfering with sexuality-based bullying, the school board stands by its policy because otherwise "the kids will think homosexuality is normal." No you idiots, what your children are learning is that it's ok to bully the weaker kids until they die. And the weaker kids are experiencing that even their teachers think they don't deserve to live. Bullying is bullying, no matter the underlying reason (which is a terrible one to begin with).

When LGBT employment rights like wrongful termination come up, or when any other normal human issue arises for this particular group, all of a sudden the conversation grows to include a debate on the morality of an identity. Seriously, seriously hijacked.

Under federalist principles (which republicans purport to be big fans of), the national government is the bottom line when it comes to rights, and the states may add to the list of enumerated rights, but they may not subtract them. Now whether the rights exist somewhere in the Constitution in the first place has always been a struggle throughout history (women's suffrage, brown people's rights, etc.), but something is definitely out of whack when certain people go to a lot of effort to limit a specific group of other people's rights. This is never ok, unless your membership in those groups can evolve (for instance adults changing teenagers' rights to drink or smoke) or unless the members of the affected group can't think for themselves.

And that's not what the republicans are saying, is it? That LGBT people are lesser human beings who can't make their own decisions or think for themselves? Are they, by definition, doing anything dangerous that needs limiting (like drugs)? No. So it must be that republicans don't think LGBT people do laundry, or pay taxes, or have families. Because everyone knows that the gays are contagious, and if they were doing those things then everyone in the state would be doing laundry and paying taxes, and god knows that doesn't happen. Laundry especially, if you look at some of my coworkers.

When the discussion suddenly becomes about "whether gayness is ok," people like my grandma lose sight of what is actually going on with the amendment business and get drawn into irrelevant discussions. The issue is: Should Minnesotans ban all same-sex marriages forever via a redundant and permanent constitutional amendment?

The answer, if you didn't catch my drift, is no.

No comments: