I've probably said this before, but I'm constantly beleaguered by young white progressives for whom "not racist" is a part of their identities in the same way "nice" is for many Minnesotans. Being nice says more about the person who is nice than the person they are being nice to. We aspire to be nice not necessarily because we care about strangers specifically, but because understanding ourselves as "not nice" would be too devastating to our psyches. The same with being racist.
While these unconscious behaviors have their own use (see: the successful creation of a nationwide MLK day), they actually limit real development of human connections and understanding. Really respecting me as an Asian person doesn't just mean remembering not to call me "oriental." It means finding out why "oriental" is a troubling word. The "why" behind a lot of PC rules is often more important than the rules themselves, and we forget to actually think about the person we're being nice to, or not racist to, in our selfish robotic efforts to "solve" our not-niceness or racist tendencies with quick appropriations of proper identity elements.
The same young white progressives who feign horror (or really believe that they're horrified, even if they don't know why other than that they were taught "it's wrong" because it violates our current social code) when someone says "chink," still make North Korea starvation jokes, still ridicule the characters in Korean music videos for their specifically indecipherable and "quirky" Asian content, and still lump Asian Americans together when they throw us under the bus in an effort to seem reasonable during affirmative action discussions.
"Don't be mean because it's awkward, and because you are not a mean person," serves a purpose when dealing with people who can't process any sort of why, but it limits the application of the real respect toward others that the rest of us are currently feigning. "Not racist" is a part of young white progressives' identities because it's complimentary to those identities, not because racism is actually bad.
In legal terms, the truth of the matter asserted ("How racism is harmful") should be much more important than how it is asserted ("You are/are not a racist."). But we keep on focusing on the assertion itself, because we're lazy and self-centered.
Do these young white progressives get points for trying to be on the right side of history? Maybe. Even if it's only for the sake of their egos, it's still ultimately useful. But it's also limiting. And worse (for me), it doesn't stop me from feeling alone. Knowing that anti-racism is all about their identities (and not mine) makes me feel like collateral damage when these same people make North Korea jokes.
Their decision not to be racist doesn't change my reality. Trying ≠ Justice. Right now, it's like apples and oranges. Their decision to not be racist is limited to what effect it will have on their own perceptions of themselves.
Real allies would dig in and try to understand at a level deeper than just prevention of name-calling. You have to earn the right to call yourself an ally.
No comments:
Post a Comment