In one of the adoptee-based studies I've participated lately, I was asked for my definition of "family."
I think people usually come up with positive-feelings-based definitions, maybe commonly used phrases like "home is where the heart is," but because this is something I been confronted with on a regular basis, I think my understanding of family is a little more nuanced.
Family is a fact. It is not by definition good or bad (although hopefully it is good). It either exists or it doesn't. It has more to do with obligation, identification, and factual events than hugs. Many different forms of families can be "real," and a person can have more than one family.
Family is a feeling in the sense that it's a tie that can't be broken without breaking part of yourself in the process. You can decide that you're not going to have anything to do with your family members, but you are still biologically tied to them and/or you feel a specific pull toward them. This is evidenced in the fact that children in the foster-care system most often want to return to their original parents, even if those parents beat or neglected them, and even if their foster parents gave them daily hugs and a personal pony. That deep feeling of "your mother is your mother" is almost impossible to shake. The feeling itself is
irrational - its initial occurrence is not a decision. I have that feeling about MumDear and DadCat, my adoptive parents. Our family is a fact - we've shared years of formative experiences that no one else in the world has. We've become a real family. I feel obligation toward this family, and I know that if I ever have to take care of them I will. (I might not like every bit of it, but I don't have a real choice, because they're my family.) Luckily, I also love this family.
I have another family. It doesn't look like a family in any traditional sense because I don't know them and they possibly don't know each other, but they're still my family. If I ever meet them we may not like each other, and they may be strangers, but we are biologically related and they exist in both reality and my inner knowledge of our connection. If they ever needed anything from me I would either give it, or I would break myself by my decision to withhold it.
It's possible to feel like your family members are really your family members while simultaneously feeling like you don't belong there.
I think a lot of adoptees feel betrayed by their feelings about their adoptive families. Some of them refer to their adoptive parents as their "white people." The people who told them their birthmothers were prostitutes, that Koreans were heathens that Jesus wanted to save, and that Koreans and Korean food smell bad. Regardless, none of these things would cause as much pain as it does if their adoptive families didn't feel like their real families, in a very sad but still real sense. Maybe this connection was formed because there was no other connection available to make at an early age, but for individuals who realize that this connection must be broken - I see them break themselves in the process of separation. It's often for the best, but it's not without internal casualties.
Sometimes the adoption process doesn't form a family.
Gay families are families. These bonds transcend gender.
At my adopted friend's wedding last weekend, I could see that he'd formed that bond with his adoptive mother. I completely understood that it was real, regardless of the color of their skin and the difference in their features. But I also don't want that bond to be perceived as mutually exclusive to the existence of his other/first/additional family. Adoptive families are not as much of a replacement family as they're often marketed as - they are an addition.
No comments:
Post a Comment