Tuesday, July 21, 2009

theories of justice

It's lesson day, boys and girls.

What is our current criminal justice system set up to achieve? Do we aim to punish the offender? To prevent the offender from committing the same crime in the future? To deter others from erring?

We're probably set up to achieve everything but the most important goal, in my mind: restoring the community and victims to where they were before the crime, or as close to it as possible.

I understand that violent crime requires more extreme measures on our government's part than, say, graffiti citations. But in either case, consider that our response is to separate the offender from the rest of society for a determined amount of time. Then, as sudden as an alarm clock, we spring them back into society and demand that everyone get along and hope that they've learned their lesson.

The first thing wrong with this scenario is that victims' needs aren't met. Yes, those affected may read "victim impact statements" at the very end of criminal trials, but that's the extent of it. There's no official way to address the upheaval in victims' lives that's connected to the offender herself.

The second thing wrong with this scenario is that the offender is presented with a faceless victim: the state. Criminal cases read, "State v. Johnson," or "The People v. Smith." It's not hard to imagine that feeling remorseful toward the real victims would be the last thing on your mind when faced with only police officers, the court, and then other offenders while you're imprisoned.

The third thing wrong with this scenario is that little rehabilitative purposes are met by merely separating offenders from everyone else. It's like a waiting period where nothing positive happens. The person in jail gets bored, and the victimized person has to deal with the consequences on his own. There's nothing wrong with a little cooling-off time, but even as a kid I remember thinking that my time-outs seemed pointless after awhile. The only thing they did was give MotherDearest some peace. But since we knew we all had to co-exist afterward anyway, by the end of the time-out LittleBoy and I would sometimes work our problem out ourselves.

And that is exactly my point. We all have to co-exist together afterward, and we should keep that in mind when creating a system to mete out intermediate fates.

In the best of all possible worlds, a neighbor annoyed with the college students holding a noisy party next door would call them and ask them to keep it down. The neighbor would explain to the students that it has a detrimental effect on her life, etc. The next day, the students can walk across the alley and apologize and offer to trim her hedges. Problem solved, and without involving the current criminal justice system.

In reality, this situation would come out like this: Students have noisy party, neighbor calls police who show up and cite the students for a noise violation. Students have to either pay a large fine or go to court. Students hate neighbor, neighbor hates students. And the vicious cycle continues.

Since we do have to deal with the real world (which includes transient residents and passive aggressive neighbors), ideally the criminal justice system would force the students and neighbor to sit down together and communicate. The neighbor would get a chance to explain why the noisy party made her angry, and the students would get a chance to apologize (and the citation would be removed from their records). Then together they could come up with a solution to restore some of the harm done. Ideally, they'd decide that the students should volunteer in the immediate neighborhood - painting houses, babysitting, etc. Not only does that directly benefit the crime "victims," but in general it builds community and accounts for the fact that no matter what, they all live there together. Mr. Rogers would be proud.

So would you change the entire criminal justice system, you ask? Well, yes and no. That depends on all of us. If it were possible to re-orient our society to be community and locally-minded, then yes (except for cases involving extreme violent crime where the offenders should be separated, perhaps indefinitely). But since communities vary in terms of transience, communication, and member activeness, it depends on where you are and who you're working with. If you'd turn away Jean Valjean because of his yellow papers, your community probably has a long way to go.

Regardless of the black and white "complete overhaul v. no reform" issue, I'm for working toward a system that more directly addresses victims' rights and rehabilitative purposes. Some of these efforts are already in play; if they are ineffective, we should first look at ourselves and our attitudes before deciding that they're pointless.

Also, eliminating poverty and racism would be good.

1 comment:

Jackson said...

In my experiences, those involved with noisy college parties aren't the people we want babysitting our children.....does it make sense to have irresponsible individuals who partake in drunken shananigans put in charge of the well-being of our neighborhood kids?

What if the angry neighbor doesn't like the drunken noisy nights because their niece was killed by a drunken college student who lacked the capacity to operate a vehicle, let alone their own two feet?

Justice is subjective. And clearly the system is too...