Wednesday, July 8, 2009

the annual parent post

Seriously, I just want some data on a cross-section of American parents. Because I'm honestly appalled by a few of these at camp. Yes there are level-headed ones (out there somewhere), but the number of wackos I encounter makes me feel like 12 years ago someone just said, "Here, have a brown baby, they're all the rage now, go nuts." And they did.

In a cross-section of American parents, how many would follow their teenage daughter around camp with two cameras and a video recorder like British paparazzi? How many would U.S. mail her 8 letters even though they see her every day because they decided to volunteer at camp? How many would hand her counselor a camera and tell them to snap photos at night because they couldn't be there? I caught one mother following other campers around with her video recorder when she couldn't find her daughter. Talk about making your child feel like a freak. "Look at how Korean you are! Now dance for me!"

The whole thing just makes me very cynical.

I'm glad that these parents have decided to use half their vacation time for the year to let their kids attend a culture/identity camp. And MotherDearest pointed out that the parents also need affirmation (I always forget that parents aren't supposed to be invincible). But still, part of me just feels like the scenario is too often: Dress child up in colorful ethnic clothing (check), take lots of pictures of child doing ethnic things with other ethnic children (check), fulfill parental duty for the year (check). Finally, dismiss all adults who look like your child, except for the ones who might tell you how to stop said child from getting tattoos and being angry later (check). (This happens. The fact that the camp is run by parents means that it's run by white people, which has the effect of making even adult Koreans less authoritative. We all know who's in charge.)

Except for that last ridiculous part, I know I'd probably do the same thing if I were one of the parents. They don't know that they look really awkward to adult adoptees because many don't see their children's ethnic heritage as an inherent part of their identity, not something to pull out once in awhile and dust off. (And we know that that's often how it works, because their kids talk.) If I were an adoptive parent I'd try to get to know adults like my children will be. If there weren't any in my area, I'd move. (And if you can't move, you shouldn't have applied for a brown child in the first place. I'm sorry, that's just how it is.) And lastly, I most certainly would NOT stalk my child with two cameras and a video recorder. Sheesh, lady.

2 comments:

Brenna said...

Two cameras and a video recorder is a bit much, but it's nice to know that some parents are so interested in the lives of their children. I'd think that most parents send their kid off to camp and then rejoice in having a week to themselves, free from having to be a parent. And while I've never had the experience you have of going to a Korean heritage summer camp, from what I can infer from your own posts, you seem to feel that your time there has been very influential to your own identity and worldview. Given its importance, why wouldn't a parent wouldn't want to document such an event? Granted, doing it to a teenage girl might only instill more self-consciousness than self-confidence, though.

But I think it might be similar to visiting Korea itself with other adoptees and their parents. Parents recognize it as being a moment filled with emotion and significance and will take pictures for both themselves and for their children to treasure later. When I visited Korea, all of the adoptee kids bought hanboks for the last day of the trip and wore them, and I didn't feel at all like a zoo animal when my parents insisted on taking my picture in it. Instead, I guess I felt somewhat elated that my parents were so excited to be a part of the experience with me. I never felt that they brought up my Korean heritage only once a year as an obligation. It was always an open subject for us to discuss if I ever felt like it, but I didn't need a production to be made of it year round either because in truth, I am and will always be more American than I am Korean-American.

But I agree with you that it is exceedingly more difficult for an adopted kid to not feel like an outsider when they're surrounded by white children who've never seen another Asian in person before. I think the answer is less for parents to move and more for cultural education among all people and communities. I don't really like the idea of small "hot zones" of brown people clustered together. It seems to me that it'd only make all Asian-Americans seem more like foreigners to the general white American public than they do already.

1234 said...

yes, i guess a lot of these parents are happy that their kids are in their element and want to share it with them (and that's a good thing), but i'm honestly reacting to the annual post-camp realization that my parents were not the norm. i never noticed before. yes mine took lots of pictures on the last day, but they mostly let my brother and i determine what camp and korean culture meant to us; they didn't push it or appropriate it. it was ours. don't imagine your parents in my post; trust me when i say that i'm guessing ours were the best of the bunch. i really didn't know that all parents weren't like mine, and it makes me sad.

basically, on the brown people hot zones thing, i'm against using children as the color spreaders when they don't have brown parents with them as support. cultural awareness-spreading should be left to those who can choose to do it, not forced on the weakest members of our society.