I recently attended a Unitarian Universalist service with my parents and DearlyBeloved. This was printed on the back of the bulletin:
We covenant to affirm and promote:
- The inherent worth and dignity of every person
- Justice, equality and compassion in human relations
- Acceptance of one another and encouragement to spiritual growth in our congregations
- A free and responsible search for truth and meaning
- The right of conscience and the use of the democratic process within our congregations and in society at large
- The goal of world community with peace, liberty, and justice for all
- Respect for the interdependent web of all existence of which we are a part
The living tradition we share draws from many sources:
- Direct experience of that transcending mystery and wonder, affirmed in all cultures, which moves us to a renewal of spirit and an openness to the forces which create and sustain life.
- Words and deeds of prophetic men and women which challenge us to confront powers and structures of evil with justice, compassion, and the transforming power of love.
- Wisdom from the world’s religions which inspire us in our ethical and spiritual life.
- Jewish and Christian teachings which call us to respond to God’s love by loving our neighbors as ourselves.
- Humanist teachings which counsel us to heed the guidance of reason and the results of science, and warn us against idolatries of the mind and spirit.
- Spiritual teachings of Earth-centered traditions which celebrate the sacred circle of life and instruct us to live in harmony with the rhythms of nature.
In keeping with the church’s commitment to freedom of individual belief, no creedal test is required of those seeking membership.
Perfect! I thought.
Later, DB and I got into a discussion about how to raise children. *pause*
We both grew up in semi-small ELCA (Lutheran) churches with great communities and events and support. All the non-familial adults I knew when I was little were from school or church or both. Many of my parents’ close friends were fellow members. My formative memories of large gatherings include a pitch-fork fondue, Christmas Eve church in our barn, and an Advent Event with a variety of ethnic food including fresh lefse and once, taffy. You could easily say that both DB and I are culturally Lutheran. We like our potlucks.
DB was concerned about raising children in a UU church. “It would be a community sharing similar beliefs just like in a Lutheran one,” I said. DB was concerned about religious structure and opening too many doors at once. “If you decide that you’re Lutheran, you can even raise them in the Lutheran tradition,” I offered. “We could be Lutherans who attend Unitarian church.” Indeed we could. Unitarianism and Universalism (they started as separate traditions) have Judeo-Christian origins even though anyone practicing any religion who feels that UU is for them may join.
Most of my theological education is in the Christian tradition. I just cannot, and will not, teach my children to believe something that I do not. If my husband believes and teaches it I’m perfectly fine to help. But I can’t facilely repeat the one-liners we all tell children. Not to my own.
This will obviously make it more difficult to rear our children. We won’t have the backlogs of stored, “Jesus died for your sins because he loves you,” and “God sent His only son,” to easily regurgitate. And I learned that regurgitation is automatic when I nannied for those 3 infamous and oh-so-cute Catholic children. It’s ridiculously easy to say what pops out first. It’s ok if the children are being raised in the Christian tradition. But if they’re not… we’ll have to come up with a very specific and intentional game plan. Because children are smart. And if you’re unprepared they’ll definitely suffer for it in the long run.
I bet it will take us years to figure this out. I have a vague idea of what a solid perspective to offer might look like. I’d start with the idea that there is a God who loves people and creatures and nature and that “good” is what happens when everything interacts in harmony for the benefit of the entire system. I’d offer that we come to knowledge through experience and learning about others’ experiences and thoughts, and that we should use reason to help us interpret what the meaning of all that information might be.
What children should know for sure: that they are loved, that they are capable of loving, that they are valuable for who they are, that reasoning through things can lead to the best solution (but which still might not be the right solution), and that they can offer so much to make the world a better place.
Ours should also learn about how the Judeo-Christian tradition works as well as what great things many faith traditions have to offer. They won’t all be presented as equal. What a strange thought- that would be impossible unless you took them incredibly lightly. I can't imagine not respecting faith traditions enough to claim that their elements all have the same merit and meaning. There are great and terrible things inherent in all traditions, I think. It doesn’t mean you shouldn’t practice them, of course. It does mean that you should be aware.
But we won’t do what many fear from “relativist” parents: we won’t raise our children and then one day proclaim, “Choose one.” As if that could ever happen. If we raise our children right, they will come to believe that one set of beliefs is most right. They won’t be able to “choose,” in the randomly selective sense of the word. And perhaps they will end up believing something entirely different than I or DB. That would be fine.
No matter what, I wish this for my children: that they arrive at a worldview in which they can live, thrive, and grow wiser in harmony with everything else that exists.
5 comments:
I took at look at the beliefs that you posted from the back of your bulletin. They seem problematic.
Is it truly possible to affirm the values of all people? No, it's actually impossible. Some people think that genocide is a plausible solution for people whose worldviews collide with their own. Some people think that killing their unborn children is a good way to prevent them from having to deal with the responsibility associated with reproduction.
You cannot affirm the loving attitudes taught by Christ, without also acknowledging the fact that without the redemptive work of Christ on the cross, we are all just sinners, and no peace is possible.
All this is merely to say that I cannot imagine trying to raise a child within the Universalist mindset. It's impossible to reconcile their viewpoint with the reality of the world and the sinfulness of mankind.
I love the fact that you are thinking about how to raise your children. My parents, had no such thoughts. I had no faith upbringing and while I turned out alright I did "just choose". I am at peace with my choice but it would have been nice to have had some background in a faith tradition.
Hello David, I take it you found me from "Unmitigated Nonsense?" Thank you for your comment- I think many of my frequent readers skip posts like these.
First- I think you have thrown quite a few "straw man" accusations my way. I never claimed to affirm the values of all people. I affirm that all people have values, but whether or not I agree with them is quite another thing. What I do promote is the discussion surrounding our differences in values and worldviews in the hope that we might all grow wiser in our own.
Also, I do not subscribe to Anselm's Satisfaction Theory. It's too medieval, too rooted in who owes whom what - feudalism.
I also do not start from the same place as you- I do not believe that we need look beyond ourselves and our world for redemption. And while I find his life and teachings to be of incredible importance, I do not believe that Jesus of Nazareth was the Christ, the anointed one, the Savior of the world, the son of God, fully human and fully God. Chances are, many UU individuals would disagree with me. I find that perfectly fine.
So, while it is very hard to have a conversation about this (as you and I frame our conversations and starting points very differently), I nonetheless thank you for providing another worldview. I most certainly do not agree with yours, but I support your search for truth.
When did you stop believing that "we need look beyond ourselves and our world for redemption?"
The statement you make implies either that redemption can be found in this world, or (more likely) since everyting in this world is imperfect, redemption cannot ever be attained (a sad thought).
You postulate that " 'good' is what happens when everything interacts in harmony for the benefit of the entire system." If you assume "everything" to encompass all of reality (or even a small sample of reality), then you have to conclude that good is impossible to attain.
I suppose one response to this problem would be to simply be content living in an imperfect world and futily striving to be a little better.
I find this to be an extraordinarily frustrating endpoint, since Christ presents such a perfect solution. I would encourage you to read Pope Benedict's new book "Jesus of Nazareth" before trying to re-invent the wheel.
Finally on the topic of raising children, I respect your desire to teach you not wanting to teach your children what you do not believe (who would?) My final questions for you: what do you believe, and how do you distill that down into simple answers that you can tell your kids (and that will stick with them as they grow up into adulthood)?
Leo:
I think it was a gradual realization. And when I say "realization," I don't mean that I'm right. I mean that I believe I'm right (I can only know as much as I know, but the point is to keep thinking about it). The pope could be right. My main point is that to me, it's absurd to claim that you are absolutely right, in any possible world.
I choose your option A: redemption can be found in this world, but in the sense that we have no "original sin" tainting us from the start from which we need redemption. (I'd feel like a "buy one get one free" coupon.) I use the word "redemption" and actually shouldn't; it's just the easiest way to express to Christians what I mean by self-actualization (too selfish), the realization etc. of all that I think we are capable of becoming and doing.
Next: I agree that "good" is difficult to attain but I must refuse to say that it is impossible. I agree that we should strive for "good" even if the odds are against us.
The realization that we live in an imperfect world is an important one. Then we have to understand that we can individually and collectively do something about it. (We can.) Your faith tradition may say similar things (with different reasons or ends).
Has anyone ever thought that -even with all its trappings and underpinnings and complex theological ideas- that the very premise of God sending someone to save us (ta daa...)is sort of like a Deus ex Machina, in the Greek drama sense of the word?
Last: As I write, I am in the process of figuring out what I believe. As I said in several earlier posts, the point is to preserve the question. I want to instill the right tools in my children (absorbtion, reflection, examination) so that they not only learn from the Judeo-Christian tradition from which we (DB & I) came, but that they grow into the best versions of themselves. Right now I believe this is the best way to do it. I also said earlier that my opinions will likely change; however, my methods won't. It will certainly be more difficult to do it this way, rather than subscribe to one faith tradition. But since the stated is impossible for me I really have no other options, have I? Sometimes, like when boating, wheels are a hindrance. The best option would be to have both wheels and a hull like the Wisconsin Dells Ducks, eh? Just kidding.
It'll definitely be more work. And we do know we need to have a game plan in place before we pop out little Meow's and DB's. This is me beginning to work out my game plan. Thanks for helping.
Post a Comment