Well, I had 16 missed calls last night. Thanks guys.
Unfortunately, Bjorn had hidden the cell phone under the bed in a very sound-muffled place and I didn't hear it until DB called early this morning when I was actually in bed. (Hurrah!)
My gripe today is that the federal government via FBI requires us to list a person's race on their fingerprint cards. Why do they need to know? I understand that it's easier to find someone the more s/he is categorized, but I really think our entire governmental bureaucracy needs to enter the 21st century and realize that race is not an empirical denominator.
According to the FBI, people from the Middle East are "white." Said snarkily, "We certainly don't treat them that way, do we?"
Maybe they want to be able to look at data and say, "This group of people do this. And this other group here does it differently." I think maybe the FBI should use "primary language" as an identifier. Or something. Language is such a vehicle for cultural expression, is it not?
They even have a system to define skin tones. Why in any would would they need to know how well I tan? Grrrrrr!
My immediate problem was that I had a hispanic gentleman in front of me. And I had to tell him, "I'm sorry, 'Hispanic' is not listed. You are required to choose another category."
To the general population, "Hispanic" is indeed a category of people. What most of us don't realize is that to consider this group of people one race is a ridiculous idea. People from Spain are hispanic. And they are white-European. People from Central America are considered hispanic, even though they are largely indigenous "Native Americans." Spanish is their second language. Cameron Diaz is hispanic. Your mom might be.
What happens when "white" Europeans bring their "black" African slaves west to where (dare I say "yellow?") Asians once crossed a land bridge long ago and have lived for hundreds (perhaps thousands) of years, becoming "red" Native Americans? I don't know. You tell me. Alphabet soup?
Apparently the federal government does realize that "Hispanic" cannot be included in their definition of race. Yet, they still legitimize the racial construct as a way to categorize people and end up insulting and reducing a large number of people to names and numbers with which they do not identify.
Where do you draw the geographical lines? When do you draw the historical ones? Are Native Americans actually Asian? Are Turks white?
Should I just subversively leave the "race" box open on the FBI form?
No comments:
Post a Comment