
I have some white friends who are thinking of adopting. Children, that is.
I think they would be great parents for white children, because they live in a white community and have mostly white peers, and they are very kind and loving people. They are both Irish-American and are extremely proud of their Irish heritage. Which is all well and good. Until you give them brown children, and then we have more to discuss.
If you want children so that you have more workers to keep the farm running, then so be it. Everyone knows there are cows to be milked, and the deal is clear. Do what you have to do and I will stay out of it as long as you feed and clothe them.
But if you want children because they will make your life happy and fulfilling, then there is more that you should be prepared to do if you have brown ones. They (and thus, you) have the best chance of being happy if you take an extra second to consider what their best interests are. I know I sound presumptuous, but I'm guessing I know a few more brown people with and without white parents than you do. Also, I am one. With white parents, that is.
Anyway, in situations where you want your children to be real members of your family - love is not enough. Stop telling yourselves that. Love is always necessary, but it is not enough. And if you're going to raise them like you love them (not like they are extra farm hands), then you have to do what is actually in their best interests, not just what you want their best interests to be. Think carefully about it. You will not be happy if they are not happy, so really consider what will help them to be happy. You do not know everything you need to know (how could you? you're white), and you should not give them the impression that you do. It will stunt their personal growth.
My number one rule about raising brown children is this: You must not.
-Unless you are willing to have real, deep friendships with adults of your prospective child's race and culture. And by culture I don't necessarily mean that they have to be fresh off the boat. They have to be someone who knows what it's like to be a child, teenager, and adult of that race and hyphen-American culture in the U.S., and they should have some ties to others here like them. In other words, unless you can provide something like a permanent aunt and uncle for your children, you are turning them into ghosts.
Living in an urban neighborhood is useful, but it doesn't accomplish anything close to what a nearby aunt and uncle could. I have three goals for you.
1. Your kids should see you enjoying interactions with adults of their own race on an equal and mutually respectful level. Even if you work with brown children on a daily basis, your own peer social life should reflect your child's future social life. If you can't handle adults of your child's race, do not pass Go, do not collect $200.
2. You will benefit from having a relationship with adults of your child's race. Your interactions with your child will be informed by what you learn from others. You will therefore be less focused on the historical funny-hat-wearing ancestors of your children, and more aware of modern real people. Your child will not grow up thinking they are the product of an antiquated irrelevant place.
3. Your kids will benefit from having a relationship with adults of their own race. Maybe these adults will also have children for them to play with. Your children will get a chance to see how their peers are parented, and then they won't be blindsided by the differences once they are adults. But my main point is this - young people need to see older models for who they could potentially be as they grow up. This is a powerful opportunity for you to influence who your child's role models are. Don't mess it up.
If you can't find anyone who fits this description to be real friends with you, then you should not adopt brown children. Maybe your two races don't often have positive interactions - which will lead to problems for your kids in the future when they try to interact socially with people whom they identify with, and will always run the risk of an initial rejection. Or maybe you in particular are the sort of person that brown people don't want to be friends with. It's a possibility that you should consider. Are you insultingly blind to racial issues that are real events in others' lives? Do you ever wonder why most of your friends are white? Whether it's because you prefer whites (which should be a big neon sign to you NOT to adopt brown children), or because brown people don't prefer you, please consider this carefully.
My main point is that you should be willing to jump into your child's life - not the reverse. Immerse yourself in what is best for them. "But I didn't ask for all this work," you might say. Well, then don't tell them they're anything more than farmhands. If you tell them they are special, that you love them, and that God loves them... etc... they will be confused when everyone else thinks they are farmhands. Because they won't have met any adult role models of their race and culture, because you didn't introduce them to any.
The fourth thing that I didn't include in my "three goals" for you is less about your behavior than it is a one-time choice. My last rule is this: If you meet all three goals and adopt a brown child, you must adopt at least two, and they must be from the same place of origin. There's no need to send them surfing the white tide by themselves.
Here's the other thing: I know there are a lot of children who need homes. I am glad that they are getting hugs and food in their white homes. But never presume that that is enough, if you are going to give them the impression that they are important People. If they are truly important to you, you will do what is in their best interest - you will participate in their future lives
now.