I received the top grade in my class on one of my midterm exams.
I feel so validated. It's a long way from how lost I felt when I started this thing.
First midterms, then... the world!
Elle: "It has come to my attention that the maintenance staff is switching our toilet paper from Charmin... to generic. All those opposed to chafing, please say 'Aye.'"
Entire Sorority Group: "Aye."
figuring out what's real at the intersection of race, gender, and transnational adoption in america... this involves some serious discussions about food and my cat, roger.
Thursday, March 19, 2009
too much, all the time
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
the snob

Notice the water glasses and pitcher --->
I realized I am a huge food snob when three of us from The Cities walked into a tavern "up North" and tried to order dinner. I looked at the menu and had a heart attack at the mere prospect of eating anything on it.
The waitress arrived. "What can I get ya?"
"Do you have a salad?"
"Nope."
"Do you have anything with vegetables?"
"We got onion rings," she offered helpfully.
I balked. I considered the fact that the last time I'd ordered a hamburger was over a year ago, that I hadn't eaten fast food in over 2 years, and it wasn't just the grease that bothered me; it was that nothing was whole wheat or organic.
Bad Meow! I cringed and ordered a hamburger. It tasted good, but I felt sick later because I wasn't used to any of the refined products involved. I am apparently one of those people. Bring on the Evian.
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
car squak
Also Known As: Riding in Cars Next to Idiots
THE HONKER
One night last month while I was driving home in the dark, I pulled off the freeway to my neighborhood streets and then noticed a dark pickup behind me.
"Freak," I thought. "Who needs a pickup in this area?"
Well, I got plenty of time to muse about it because it followed me through multiple turns for a good 10 minutes. Then, about 2 miles from our apartment, it suddenly began honking like crazy and tailgating me. Did I have a flat tire? Was I dragging my tailpipe? I didn't know, but I knew enough to wait to stop until I was somewhere safe. The truck finally left me when I turned off the last main street to go home. I parked in the garage, and mentally thanked whoever invented garages. There was nothing wrong with my car.
ALL-AMERICAN REJECTS
LittleBoy was driving home from work recently when a car full of little punks decided to pull up next to him on the freeway and make chink faces. He was not impressed.
DR. EVIL
This week I drove home from school early (in broad daylight) and was peacefully listening to MPR when I heard a honk behind me. I looked back to see a middle-aged man in a trendy sedan.
"Seriously, jerk, we're at a stoplight. Is your girlfriend 9 months pregnant? No, I didn't think so."
I returned to the news. All of a sudden I was blinded by a brilliant green light and in shock, I looked into my rearview mirror to see this guy shine a green laser through his windshield, through my rear window, to my rearview mirror, and into my eyes. As the stoplight changed I began driving forward but he kept waving it. Luckily at the next light he turned the corner and left me, giving one last green flick as he exited. Me? I was still seeing visions of that stupid green laser long afterward.
It was a creatively invasive act, but remniscent of a certain bald man in a midlife crisis who entertained visions of world domination through the use of progressively larger phallic technologies. I wanted to stick my hands out the RedDevil's sun roof and yell, "Lay-ser!" in a nasal voice while making quotation marks in the air.
Prognosis
DearlyBeloved suggested that I make a "PISS OFF" sign to hold up whenever one of these jerks offends, but since they already spend too much energy being nuts I think if I antagonize them any more I'll probably end up in a trunk somewhere. Yeah, I know that whole thing about kicking out the tail lights and waving your arm in the breeze to get attention, but I'd rather not risk it. I'm pretty claustrophobic.
THE HONKER
One night last month while I was driving home in the dark, I pulled off the freeway to my neighborhood streets and then noticed a dark pickup behind me.
"Freak," I thought. "Who needs a pickup in this area?"
Well, I got plenty of time to muse about it because it followed me through multiple turns for a good 10 minutes. Then, about 2 miles from our apartment, it suddenly began honking like crazy and tailgating me. Did I have a flat tire? Was I dragging my tailpipe? I didn't know, but I knew enough to wait to stop until I was somewhere safe. The truck finally left me when I turned off the last main street to go home. I parked in the garage, and mentally thanked whoever invented garages. There was nothing wrong with my car.
ALL-AMERICAN REJECTS
LittleBoy was driving home from work recently when a car full of little punks decided to pull up next to him on the freeway and make chink faces. He was not impressed.
DR. EVIL
This week I drove home from school early (in broad daylight) and was peacefully listening to MPR when I heard a honk behind me. I looked back to see a middle-aged man in a trendy sedan.
"Seriously, jerk, we're at a stoplight. Is your girlfriend 9 months pregnant? No, I didn't think so."
I returned to the news. All of a sudden I was blinded by a brilliant green light and in shock, I looked into my rearview mirror to see this guy shine a green laser through his windshield, through my rear window, to my rearview mirror, and into my eyes. As the stoplight changed I began driving forward but he kept waving it. Luckily at the next light he turned the corner and left me, giving one last green flick as he exited. Me? I was still seeing visions of that stupid green laser long afterward.
It was a creatively invasive act, but remniscent of a certain bald man in a midlife crisis who entertained visions of world domination through the use of progressively larger phallic technologies. I wanted to stick my hands out the RedDevil's sun roof and yell, "Lay-ser!" in a nasal voice while making quotation marks in the air.
Prognosis
DearlyBeloved suggested that I make a "PISS OFF" sign to hold up whenever one of these jerks offends, but since they already spend too much energy being nuts I think if I antagonize them any more I'll probably end up in a trunk somewhere. Yeah, I know that whole thing about kicking out the tail lights and waving your arm in the breeze to get attention, but I'd rather not risk it. I'm pretty claustrophobic.
Monday, March 16, 2009
strange
An acquaintance from a long time ago emailed me. She is writing a book about her life and wants me to send her 5 Questions a reporter might ask her so that she can answer them.Ha.
Who would buy a book about her short life? When so much information is free and unsolicited... only celebrity or substantive content and actual skill sells, so unless she has suddenly acquired proper punctuation she is just being egotistical, because she sure isn't famous.
Sunday, March 15, 2009
can't
To my subsequent dismay, I tried again this year. And failed, miserably. I truly own a naive element that refuses to learn the hard way. Note to self: I am not Irish. And not only am I not Irish, I don't look Irish. Worse, my presence reminds white people who are not Irish that they are not Irish, on a local day (weekend) of white people celebration. They look at me in my green beads and suddenly remember that "Kiss me I'm Irish" doesn't belong on their shirts or their babies' jumpers. With our non-Irish heritages, I have as much a right to wear my beads as they do, and that unsettles them.I'm sure St. Patrick's day happens all over the world, but whether or not entire countries or other states celebrate, where I live it feels like a national holiday. It's a local national holiday. And I love holidays - especially ones that involve costumes and food. Unfortunately, this one is tied to physical appearance (specifically: not ethnic heritage). Why can't I participate in this holiday? I want to get together with friends and feel involved in the celebration. I love Ireland the country. I love Irish food and Irish music, and while I haven't developed a similar appreciation for Irish literature, the whole thing makes me feel excited and festive. (Anyway, who reads Joyce on St. Patrick's day? No one. It's not an important element of Irish appreciation on March 17th.)
This is my holiday; I'm not a transplant from another country who can sit back, watch the strange Americans drink Guinness, and enjoy the cultural exchange. I am wholly Minnesotan-American, and that encompasses both Korean adoption and soda bread, dammit.
I am forced to face the sad truth that on this particular holiday I'm an outsider. And if I don't want to interact with people who can't help but make me feel that way, I should just stay home.
Only I can't. My friends are Irish and have St. Patrick's day gatherings. I want to support anyone who is Irish-American in celebrating their identities. And anyway, not only would knowing I'm hiding at home and ignoring the date make other people sad, it would make me sad. (Note: I have, however, learned the hard way not to interact with members of the public on St. Patrick's day. There is no way in hell I'd follow my friends to the bars.)
At the moment I'm surprised that every year I forget how sad I am on this holiday. It's like being dunked in a tank of cold water for the first time, every time it rolls around. You'd think I'd develop either a thicker skin or the resolve to stay home. But I don't. I keep naively trying to participate in my holiday.
Friday, March 13, 2009
Thursday, March 12, 2009
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
friend-volution
I am convinced that the only people who carry their high school friends as their closest support network into adult life are the ones who were actually attractive when they were in high school.
Are they trying to re-live the glory days, or did they really achieve friend-vana such that they could respectably quit there?
Or maybe everyone else developed outside survival skills during high school which they put to use when they left, so they ended up making more friends.
Maybe I will know I've made it when I stop wanting to meet people.
Are they trying to re-live the glory days, or did they really achieve friend-vana such that they could respectably quit there?
Or maybe everyone else developed outside survival skills during high school which they put to use when they left, so they ended up making more friends.
Maybe I will know I've made it when I stop wanting to meet people.
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
high school jumps up and bites me in the butt
A friend from school mentioned that she went to undergrad with a guy who went to high school with me. Recap:
I went to high school with X.
Friend went to college with X.
Friend goes to law school with me.
She'd run into him recently and mentioned me in their conversation. His response was something along the lines of "Oh [Meow], she's so [silly]."
When I heard that I was annoyed. "He doesn't even know me. It's been 8 years."
"Well, that's what I told him," she said.
How dare he assume that he has grown as a person while I have remained the exact same? Even the people who remained in BavarianCornscape to work at the factory have changed, somewhat. From Facebook it appears that their lives now revolve around their children (and the bar) instead of themselves (and field keggers). And actually in that family context, they seem like nice people who love their children. Maybe they post too many blobby baby pictures, but it's mostly out of joy, right?
Further, I am sad that this conversation confirms my status as a nonperson in high school. When I say no one listened to me even while I was extremely distinctive (Asian female hockey player) and involved (musicals, choir, band, AP courses, clubs) I am not kidding. I was irrelevant. The guy I thought was my best male friend probably wouldn't have cared if I wasn't around unless I disappeared in a "something horrible happened" way and he had to feel sad. I didn't have perfect wispy white girl hair, I didn't have a chest, I didn't drink, and I didn't think the same things were funny. It wasn't a cool vs. uncool crowd thing (my group was on the homecoming court); it was more that I didn't relate in a way that other teenagers wanted to relate. I did realize this to some extent - my New Years' resolutions in 2000 and 2001 were, "Stand up for yourself but stay nice to others." I was both naive and too educated about the wrong things. Guys (my friends' boyfriends, sometimes) made fun of me.
I would probably laugh if someone called me unassertive now.
I see these rude people on Facebook, and they are probably not all that rude. They run off to Holden Village to experience God and travel to Mexico to work with children and do other liberal white people sort of things, probably all in an effort to save the world. They're well-educated, and they like classical music and acoustic guitar and work in nonprofits. Most have evolved past high school and have made new, more, friends. But apparently at least one of these jerks can't grasp the idea that other people grow too, and that they have feelings.
It's frustrating that high school can still jump up and bite me in the butt. Not only do I wish it didn't still hurt eight years later, but people making derisive remarks about me harms my current credibility. Which affects my now-life, and which makes me very angry. How dare he. Not only does he think that I am still the same person I was in high school, he misjudged that person when he was right next to her.
Now it's apparent that his human judging apparatus is still age 16. You haven't grown, buddy. I hope you realize it.
I went to high school with X.
Friend went to college with X.
Friend goes to law school with me.
She'd run into him recently and mentioned me in their conversation. His response was something along the lines of "Oh [Meow], she's so [silly]."
When I heard that I was annoyed. "He doesn't even know me. It's been 8 years."
"Well, that's what I told him," she said.
How dare he assume that he has grown as a person while I have remained the exact same? Even the people who remained in BavarianCornscape to work at the factory have changed, somewhat. From Facebook it appears that their lives now revolve around their children (and the bar) instead of themselves (and field keggers). And actually in that family context, they seem like nice people who love their children. Maybe they post too many blobby baby pictures, but it's mostly out of joy, right?
Further, I am sad that this conversation confirms my status as a nonperson in high school. When I say no one listened to me even while I was extremely distinctive (Asian female hockey player) and involved (musicals, choir, band, AP courses, clubs) I am not kidding. I was irrelevant. The guy I thought was my best male friend probably wouldn't have cared if I wasn't around unless I disappeared in a "something horrible happened" way and he had to feel sad. I didn't have perfect wispy white girl hair, I didn't have a chest, I didn't drink, and I didn't think the same things were funny. It wasn't a cool vs. uncool crowd thing (my group was on the homecoming court); it was more that I didn't relate in a way that other teenagers wanted to relate. I did realize this to some extent - my New Years' resolutions in 2000 and 2001 were, "Stand up for yourself but stay nice to others." I was both naive and too educated about the wrong things. Guys (my friends' boyfriends, sometimes) made fun of me.
I would probably laugh if someone called me unassertive now.
I see these rude people on Facebook, and they are probably not all that rude. They run off to Holden Village to experience God and travel to Mexico to work with children and do other liberal white people sort of things, probably all in an effort to save the world. They're well-educated, and they like classical music and acoustic guitar and work in nonprofits. Most have evolved past high school and have made new, more, friends. But apparently at least one of these jerks can't grasp the idea that other people grow too, and that they have feelings.
It's frustrating that high school can still jump up and bite me in the butt. Not only do I wish it didn't still hurt eight years later, but people making derisive remarks about me harms my current credibility. Which affects my now-life, and which makes me very angry. How dare he. Not only does he think that I am still the same person I was in high school, he misjudged that person when he was right next to her.
Now it's apparent that his human judging apparatus is still age 16. You haven't grown, buddy. I hope you realize it.
Monday, March 9, 2009
without
I outed myself. "I'm adopted."
The Muslim Pakistani woman cocked an eyebrow and waited.
"I have white parents."
"Then how did you develop your racial identity as an Asian-American woman?" she asked me.
Hmmm. Good question. I realized that mostly, it was from reading books and processing my experiences in light of the arguments inside. Kinda lame.
"I don't know," I said, which was even more lame.
Later I realized that since I have no substantive racial identity (I don't culturally identify with any Asian tradition), mine is almost purely a reaction to not being white in America. I am, if you will, wholly "not something." Which is really stupid and is nothing to build on. It just means that "I" am a product of individual racist experiences and racism in general (because we do not live in a post-racial world).
One could say similarly that women's identities used to be a reaction to not being men, but now I'd argue that we can choose to define ourselves if we wish, how we wish. I am as much myself because of DB as he is himself because of me. We are not "man and wife," but "husband and wife" (or "man and woman," but in that case we should spell it "womyn"). I reject the Christian tradition which holds that woman came from man; if we're going to be all about Genesis, let's remember that in the un-mistranslated text God created "earth creature" who didn't acquire gender until it was divided into two beings. Anyway. Women have a ways to go before we share equal power with males, but we're making long strides.
There's a tenuous analogy in my adoptee status, but I am still my parents' child. I would categorize this differently, especially since few legal benefits that affect me as an adult accrue from blood-relationships. My adoptee identity is less affected by outside opinion/treatment than it is by my own needs and inside experiences.
But my identity as an Asian-American is truly non-substantive. Without substance, or life really. This is maybe why I've been attracted to Korean-adoptee communities; we need to form our substantive identities in relation to something, and other AK's are our closest option. The only problem is that there are relatively so few of us and finding more than one person truly "like me" is near impossible.
Am I what happens when the proverbial fish and bird mate? Does being part fish and part bird mean that I have both gills and wings? Or does it mean that I have neither, and have to content myself with treading water on the surface?
The Muslim Pakistani woman cocked an eyebrow and waited.
"I have white parents."
"Then how did you develop your racial identity as an Asian-American woman?" she asked me.
Hmmm. Good question. I realized that mostly, it was from reading books and processing my experiences in light of the arguments inside. Kinda lame.
"I don't know," I said, which was even more lame.
Later I realized that since I have no substantive racial identity (I don't culturally identify with any Asian tradition), mine is almost purely a reaction to not being white in America. I am, if you will, wholly "not something." Which is really stupid and is nothing to build on. It just means that "I" am a product of individual racist experiences and racism in general (because we do not live in a post-racial world).
One could say similarly that women's identities used to be a reaction to not being men, but now I'd argue that we can choose to define ourselves if we wish, how we wish. I am as much myself because of DB as he is himself because of me. We are not "man and wife," but "husband and wife" (or "man and woman," but in that case we should spell it "womyn"). I reject the Christian tradition which holds that woman came from man; if we're going to be all about Genesis, let's remember that in the un-mistranslated text God created "earth creature" who didn't acquire gender until it was divided into two beings. Anyway. Women have a ways to go before we share equal power with males, but we're making long strides.
There's a tenuous analogy in my adoptee status, but I am still my parents' child. I would categorize this differently, especially since few legal benefits that affect me as an adult accrue from blood-relationships. My adoptee identity is less affected by outside opinion/treatment than it is by my own needs and inside experiences.
But my identity as an Asian-American is truly non-substantive. Without substance, or life really. This is maybe why I've been attracted to Korean-adoptee communities; we need to form our substantive identities in relation to something, and other AK's are our closest option. The only problem is that there are relatively so few of us and finding more than one person truly "like me" is near impossible.
Am I what happens when the proverbial fish and bird mate? Does being part fish and part bird mean that I have both gills and wings? Or does it mean that I have neither, and have to content myself with treading water on the surface?
Sunday, March 8, 2009
interesting non sequiturs of late
1. Woke up (multiple times) next to the scarf our apartment coordinator knit for Bjorn and realized that he's started bringing it to bed with him.
2. Ate a loaf of free sourdough bread meant for nuns.
3. Was asked to model items of business professional clothing at a future event.
4. Out of nowhere, have started receiving enough "new baby" magazines to start a bookshelf. DearlyBeloved is displeased.
5. Was startled to see two professors unselfconsciously nod or point at me upon mentioning China, twice.
6. Baked cornbread, served it to DB, and learned after 2.5 years of marriage that he does not like maple syrup.
7. Cannot stop making lists.
2. Ate a loaf of free sourdough bread meant for nuns.
3. Was asked to model items of business professional clothing at a future event.
4. Out of nowhere, have started receiving enough "new baby" magazines to start a bookshelf. DearlyBeloved is displeased.
5. Was startled to see two professors unselfconsciously nod or point at me upon mentioning China, twice.
6. Baked cornbread, served it to DB, and learned after 2.5 years of marriage that he does not like maple syrup.
7. Cannot stop making lists.
Thursday, March 5, 2009
zzzzzzzzzzz
This weekend I am going to a resort in the wilderness with other Asians from the city. *Jokes not included.
DearlyBeloved will spend a week in Iowa and a week in Ohio for his job. Did I tell you he got a new job? He did. It comes with a giant tank of a vehicle. This means that "MyCar" is now my car - I am driving the RedDevil.
Recipe for easy pumpkin muffcakes
Note: "Muffcakes" are when you can't tell whether it's a muffin or cupcake and frosting is optional.
Note: "Easy" is for when you're willing to eat a few preservatives in order to save time because you're falling apart.
Note: The pumpkin is real as far as I know.
15 oz can of pumpkin
box of yellow cake mix
Instructions: Mix, then bake. Bring up north to share with fellow urban Asians who are "roughing it" and nod humbly when you are compared to Betty Crocker. Hide the plastic tub of Betty's cream-cheese frosting that you bought at Target.
DearlyBeloved will spend a week in Iowa and a week in Ohio for his job. Did I tell you he got a new job? He did. It comes with a giant tank of a vehicle. This means that "MyCar" is now my car - I am driving the RedDevil.
Recipe for easy pumpkin muffcakes
Note: "Muffcakes" are when you can't tell whether it's a muffin or cupcake and frosting is optional.
Note: "Easy" is for when you're willing to eat a few preservatives in order to save time because you're falling apart.
Note: The pumpkin is real as far as I know.
15 oz can of pumpkin
box of yellow cake mix
Instructions: Mix, then bake. Bring up north to share with fellow urban Asians who are "roughing it" and nod humbly when you are compared to Betty Crocker. Hide the plastic tub of Betty's cream-cheese frosting that you bought at Target.
Wednesday, March 4, 2009
meowember
I think we should get rid of February. It has to be the worst month of the year. And I know it's only 28 days long (usually), but by day 15 I'm always screaming to get out. Or we could just break it in half and create "Meowember." This year I heaved an enormous sigh of relief when February passed, but then we got that giant snowfall so maybe March is worthless too.I wish I were going somewhere cool over spring break. I keep hearing people talk about Cancun and Mazatlan and New York and Jamaica and L.A. Unfortunately I will probably spend my week looking for jobs and cleaning the apartment in what is still an icy tundra.
Things that brighten my Meowember:
Student discounts (see $4 salad).
Movies like "Religulous" which you should not see if you are at all religious. It will make you cry. Or if you are not religious, it will make you angry. If you are agnostic, either you will fall asleep or you will be crangry, and that's something no one wants to see. Do I sound like you shouldn't watch it? You should; just don't send me hate mail when you can't fall asleep at night. Oh, and I should mention that it's hilarious. And Bill Maher looks like FatherDearest.
Bjorn. The cat who still thinks he is a puppy or a human. He ran off with my tank top this morning. Just picked it up in his mouth and scampered away.
Schadenfreude.
Tuesday, March 3, 2009
unappealing
Monday, March 2, 2009
SWAK?

So, what would you think if you received this card in the mail?
For starters I knew that MotherDearest had been hanging out with one of her employees who does this sort of scrapbook thing. It was cute.
I also knew that it was Valentine's Day.
But when I asked DearlyBeloved, he queried, "What is SWAK? Sweaty back?"
Not so, my dearest strange one.
I was reminded of the time we were at my parents' house for family dinner (was it Christmas, perhaps?) and the subject of codpieces came up. These things happen. Anyway, three generations of us were deeply involved in evaluating the merits of wearing them when DB piped up, "And they attract cats!"
I finished my lutefisk and tried to stifle the laugh that was bubbling up. I knew I married this one for a reason.
Sunday, March 1, 2009
meow plays hockey
So I didn't realize that I'd never played against all (or any) dudes before until I was on my way home from the arena. I started laughing. What was I thinking? It'd seemed like a good idea at the time, but faced with the reality of how huge they were the whole thing was really funny. No lie, one guy's arm was the size of my ribcage. Me trying to shove one away from the net was like a sparrow hitting a window. I had to content myself with keeping their sticks off the ice in the crease. They could try to kick the puck in if they wanted to.We won. We scored 4 goals in the last 10 minutes to win by 1, probably due to my team's anger at the meatheads just standing on the blue line taking slap shots, one of which hit me in the ankle bone. Who takes slap shots when people aren't wearing full equipment and face masks? Idiots who can't skate the puck in, that's who. When I got hit I felt like my skate shattered but I looked down and could see that it was still intact. More annoying at the moment was that the shot came so hard it knocked my feet out from under me. I limped to the bench, pissed off.
The next time I went out the dude took another one from the blue line. I cussed him out. He smirked.
The highlight of my game was a one on one when I took him out in front of the net. I wasn't heavy enough to knock him over but I think I threw him off balance enough to let him trip himself and slide into the boards. Meow - 1, Meathead - 1. I do play better when I'm angry.
During the game I struggled with brain-muscle disconnect as my muscle memory didn't accurately reflect what I thought myself capable of doing. That was frustrating. "No really, I'm better than this!" But I'm not, anymore. Luckily, the strategy of the game came back to me. I should call my high school coaches and thank them for teaching me a smart game; the rules were so ingrained that I didn't have to think about where I should be in any situation. My defensive partner and I played well together; we only got scored on once.
Casualties:
2 wooden slivers
1 cracked ankle
1 broken fingernail
1 high school era mouthguard formed to braces
pride
Overall, I'm pretty pleased. I just wish my ankle wasn't the size of a baseball. I need to get it in a sneaker for indoor frisbee!
Thursday, February 26, 2009
i'm not racist:: episode XXI
Coming soon to your local law school: "I'm not racist," featuring your fellow students and everyone they've ever met. Be sure to bring your own fried chicken, won-tons, and enchiladas.
We all took this test. Well, there are a bunch of the demonstration tests you can choose from. But it measures your implicit associations, and people sure weren't happy to learn that they held any biases at all. What did they expect?
Oh right, they all thought they were perfect little capsules of neutral.
I didn't say anything. I know you think I should have, but you also know that I'm sick of being the messenger. I'd rather they protest to someone else, or try their newfound thoughts on some other brown friend, or claim they're perfect to someone who cares.
What they forgot to consider is that while all of us carry some bias or another, A) not all biases are bad, B) in fact I'm sure they're a product of evolution, and C) we can override them if we're conscious about it. The test doesn't assess how we will always behave; it measures our unspoken assumptions.
But apparently that's too complex for most people. I heard way more about "reverse discrimination" that hour than I have ever wanted to hear. Children, children. Stop acting like someone pushed you into a corner; take a minute and just respond to the test itself.
My very presence during this conversation made them uncomfortable enough to jump right past "I might exhibit bias" to "I've been threatened by reverse discrimination!" Or another student: "I read this book that explained everything so clearly - if we would stop defining people by race and just see them as all God's children, we could stop being prejudiced." Yeah right, bucky. Which world do you live in? That sounds like a nice end result, but you don't get there by ignoring the problem. Note that our topic for the day was "implicit associations," i.e. unconscious items.
The really funny thing that I also didn't bring up (why add insult to injury?) was that I displayed no implicit racial bias. I have a moderate bias toward democracy over facism (which is nice to know, but still somewhat disconcerting because it's only moderate).
The test-makers would tell me that I haven't internalized negative things about people of color. I'm pretty sure I have, but I make such a point of being conscious of my biases in daily life that I think I've developed the ability to throw them off (quickly enough) to test well.
Either that or being a brown person raised by white people makes you love everyone.
We all took this test. Well, there are a bunch of the demonstration tests you can choose from. But it measures your implicit associations, and people sure weren't happy to learn that they held any biases at all. What did they expect?
Oh right, they all thought they were perfect little capsules of neutral.
I didn't say anything. I know you think I should have, but you also know that I'm sick of being the messenger. I'd rather they protest to someone else, or try their newfound thoughts on some other brown friend, or claim they're perfect to someone who cares.
What they forgot to consider is that while all of us carry some bias or another, A) not all biases are bad, B) in fact I'm sure they're a product of evolution, and C) we can override them if we're conscious about it. The test doesn't assess how we will always behave; it measures our unspoken assumptions.
But apparently that's too complex for most people. I heard way more about "reverse discrimination" that hour than I have ever wanted to hear. Children, children. Stop acting like someone pushed you into a corner; take a minute and just respond to the test itself.
My very presence during this conversation made them uncomfortable enough to jump right past "I might exhibit bias" to "I've been threatened by reverse discrimination!" Or another student: "I read this book that explained everything so clearly - if we would stop defining people by race and just see them as all God's children, we could stop being prejudiced." Yeah right, bucky. Which world do you live in? That sounds like a nice end result, but you don't get there by ignoring the problem. Note that our topic for the day was "implicit associations," i.e. unconscious items.
The really funny thing that I also didn't bring up (why add insult to injury?) was that I displayed no implicit racial bias. I have a moderate bias toward democracy over facism (which is nice to know, but still somewhat disconcerting because it's only moderate).
The test-makers would tell me that I haven't internalized negative things about people of color. I'm pretty sure I have, but I make such a point of being conscious of my biases in daily life that I think I've developed the ability to throw them off (quickly enough) to test well.
Either that or being a brown person raised by white people makes you love everyone.
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
studies in the "double whammy"
ON WOMEN:
I think an unacknowledged barrier to women’s advancement in the profession is older women who have “made it” and who clench tightly to their achievements so as not to lose sight of what they did accomplish in the even more unfriendly environment of past decades. I have had three women mentors. One is a judge, one is a partner at a local firm, and one is a recent graduate who works in a nonprofit. Both the judge and the partner were adamant that women these days have it too easy and we should essentially “suck it up” and work harder than the men to achieve what they have. Instead of mentoring us, they see our success in easier (but still, not perfect) territory as a threat to the prestige of their positions. If we will not be like them, we must not be good enough.
This reflects a phenomenon I’ve read about in the context of poverty, race, and violence – when oppressed or disadvantaged, a group will eventually try to rise up and throw off its oppressors, who react with even harsher oppression. The disadvantaged group eventually internalizes the presence of barriers to its power and operates/lives within the realm the more powerful group allows it to have. Problems arise when there is more than one disadvantaged group – these similarly situated factions begin to commit violence on one another; they see each other as rivals for the limited resources and opportunities inside the “realm.” So instead of providing mutual support in their struggle for power/space/opportunity equal to that of the dominant group, they waste energy dragging each other down. From my experience with older women mentors, they see themselves as a separate group from younger women… to the detriment of both, but mostly to the younger women.
ON BROWN PEOPLE:
I’m involved in multiple (they sometimes blend) minority / Asian / Korean / women / attorney groups. There are monthly lunches, dinners, occasional happy hours, and even an Oscars-watching party. Most are purely for the purpose of socializing, networking, and supporting each other – there’s no advocacy or official business on the agenda. And while I am grateful that firms occasionally sponsor our activities, I hope they don’t stop their diversity support efforts there. Because while these gatherings are useful for mental peace and sometimes for careers, the fact remains that women (and especially women of color) are not the major decision-makers in many client-organizations. So we may keep each other sane, but this type of acquaintance does not bring in business – a major factor in who makes partner. And women are still excluded from many minor interactions peripheral but oh-so-necessary to work (like golfing, running, discussions about sports teams, friendly competitions, etc.) where men might not even be consciously excluding us. When women rule the world we’ll have to evaluate the power of book clubs; until then everyone needs to be aware of the golf/sports/running club club club.
ON BROWN WOMEN:
Being a member of the “double whammy” group is a funny thing. Our high numbers of attrition from firms is counterintuitive – you’d think that some statistically-minded person at the top would realize that retaining us means the firm gets to count its diversity levels twice. At the very least, looking good ought to motivate some people, if rightness won’t.
NATIONAL & LOCAL STUDIES:
Women account for 30% of attorneys in the U.S. and 50% of all law students; women of color account for only 3% of the profession.
Minority women are the most likely to begin their careers in public interest jobs. (5.7%)
3.5 % White women
3.3 % Minority men
1.5% White men
Minority women leave law firms at an alarming rate. 12.1 % leave within their first year of practice, and 75% leave within the first five years.
Although most attorneys in the majority do not recognize bias as a major or moderate problem, most attorneys rate themselves as more sensitive than other people to the rights and needs of attorneys in diverse communities.
When firms employ diverse attorneys, they may feel overused to attend and present at diversity events, to serve on diversity committees, and to participate in other activities that do not accrue toward billable hour objectives. (The number of hours you bill per year determines your "rank" at the firm because it signifies how much money you earned for your firm. Bills go to clients; because there is no client at diversity initiatives, essentially it's a drain on your expensive time.)
Women of color state that they were allowed to meet with clients only when their race or gender would be advantageous to the firm; they frequently were not given a substantive role in those meetings.
Many complained that they received "soft evaluations" which denied them the opportunity to correct deficits and gain experiences that could lead to promotions and partnership.
"This study clearly evidences that if women of color are not viewed as separate from women in general or people of color in general, your ability to recruit, retain, and advance them is impaired." - Recommendations to firms by the Commission of Women In The Profession.
I think an unacknowledged barrier to women’s advancement in the profession is older women who have “made it” and who clench tightly to their achievements so as not to lose sight of what they did accomplish in the even more unfriendly environment of past decades. I have had three women mentors. One is a judge, one is a partner at a local firm, and one is a recent graduate who works in a nonprofit. Both the judge and the partner were adamant that women these days have it too easy and we should essentially “suck it up” and work harder than the men to achieve what they have. Instead of mentoring us, they see our success in easier (but still, not perfect) territory as a threat to the prestige of their positions. If we will not be like them, we must not be good enough.
This reflects a phenomenon I’ve read about in the context of poverty, race, and violence – when oppressed or disadvantaged, a group will eventually try to rise up and throw off its oppressors, who react with even harsher oppression. The disadvantaged group eventually internalizes the presence of barriers to its power and operates/lives within the realm the more powerful group allows it to have. Problems arise when there is more than one disadvantaged group – these similarly situated factions begin to commit violence on one another; they see each other as rivals for the limited resources and opportunities inside the “realm.” So instead of providing mutual support in their struggle for power/space/opportunity equal to that of the dominant group, they waste energy dragging each other down. From my experience with older women mentors, they see themselves as a separate group from younger women… to the detriment of both, but mostly to the younger women.
ON BROWN PEOPLE:
I’m involved in multiple (they sometimes blend) minority / Asian / Korean / women / attorney groups. There are monthly lunches, dinners, occasional happy hours, and even an Oscars-watching party. Most are purely for the purpose of socializing, networking, and supporting each other – there’s no advocacy or official business on the agenda. And while I am grateful that firms occasionally sponsor our activities, I hope they don’t stop their diversity support efforts there. Because while these gatherings are useful for mental peace and sometimes for careers, the fact remains that women (and especially women of color) are not the major decision-makers in many client-organizations. So we may keep each other sane, but this type of acquaintance does not bring in business – a major factor in who makes partner. And women are still excluded from many minor interactions peripheral but oh-so-necessary to work (like golfing, running, discussions about sports teams, friendly competitions, etc.) where men might not even be consciously excluding us. When women rule the world we’ll have to evaluate the power of book clubs; until then everyone needs to be aware of the golf/sports/running club club club.
ON BROWN WOMEN:
Being a member of the “double whammy” group is a funny thing. Our high numbers of attrition from firms is counterintuitive – you’d think that some statistically-minded person at the top would realize that retaining us means the firm gets to count its diversity levels twice. At the very least, looking good ought to motivate some people, if rightness won’t.
NATIONAL & LOCAL STUDIES:
Women account for 30% of attorneys in the U.S. and 50% of all law students; women of color account for only 3% of the profession.
Minority women are the most likely to begin their careers in public interest jobs. (5.7%)
3.5 % White women
3.3 % Minority men
1.5% White men
Minority women leave law firms at an alarming rate. 12.1 % leave within their first year of practice, and 75% leave within the first five years.
Although most attorneys in the majority do not recognize bias as a major or moderate problem, most attorneys rate themselves as more sensitive than other people to the rights and needs of attorneys in diverse communities.
When firms employ diverse attorneys, they may feel overused to attend and present at diversity events, to serve on diversity committees, and to participate in other activities that do not accrue toward billable hour objectives. (The number of hours you bill per year determines your "rank" at the firm because it signifies how much money you earned for your firm. Bills go to clients; because there is no client at diversity initiatives, essentially it's a drain on your expensive time.)
Women of color state that they were allowed to meet with clients only when their race or gender would be advantageous to the firm; they frequently were not given a substantive role in those meetings.
Many complained that they received "soft evaluations" which denied them the opportunity to correct deficits and gain experiences that could lead to promotions and partnership.
"This study clearly evidences that if women of color are not viewed as separate from women in general or people of color in general, your ability to recruit, retain, and advance them is impaired." - Recommendations to firms by the Commission of Women In The Profession.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

