Sunday, March 15, 2009

can't

To my subsequent dismay, I tried again this year. And failed, miserably. I truly own a naive element that refuses to learn the hard way. Note to self: I am not Irish. And not only am I not Irish, I don't look Irish. Worse, my presence reminds white people who are not Irish that they are not Irish, on a local day (weekend) of white people celebration. They look at me in my green beads and suddenly remember that "Kiss me I'm Irish" doesn't belong on their shirts or their babies' jumpers. With our non-Irish heritages, I have as much a right to wear my beads as they do, and that unsettles them.

I'm sure St. Patrick's day happens all over the world, but whether or not entire countries or other states celebrate, where I live it feels like a national holiday. It's a local national holiday. And I love holidays - especially ones that involve costumes and food. Unfortunately, this one is tied to physical appearance (specifically: not ethnic heritage). Why can't I participate in this holiday? I want to get together with friends and feel involved in the celebration. I love Ireland the country. I love Irish food and Irish music, and while I haven't developed a similar appreciation for Irish literature, the whole thing makes me feel excited and festive. (Anyway, who reads Joyce on St. Patrick's day? No one. It's not an important element of Irish appreciation on March 17th.)

This is my holiday; I'm not a transplant from another country who can sit back, watch the strange Americans drink Guinness, and enjoy the cultural exchange. I am wholly Minnesotan-American, and that encompasses both Korean adoption and soda bread, dammit.

I am forced to face the sad truth that on this particular holiday I'm an outsider. And if I don't want to interact with people who can't help but make me feel that way, I should just stay home.

Only I can't. My friends are Irish and have St. Patrick's day gatherings. I want to support anyone who is Irish-American in celebrating their identities. And anyway, not only would knowing I'm hiding at home and ignoring the date make other people sad, it would make me sad. (Note: I have, however, learned the hard way not to interact with members of the public on St. Patrick's day. There is no way in hell I'd follow my friends to the bars.)

At the moment I'm surprised that every year I forget how sad I am on this holiday. It's like being dunked in a tank of cold water for the first time, every time it rolls around. You'd think I'd develop either a thicker skin or the resolve to stay home. But I don't. I keep naively trying to participate in my holiday.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Reading this disturbed me.

Think about, yes, disturbing me takes some doing.

*Everyone* is Irish on St. Patrick's Day. This shouldn't make you sad. Anyone who feels uncomfortable with your celebration should seriously piss off.

I, as a nationalist, don't associate the holiday with physical appearances. In all my travels, everyone "becomes" Irish on this day and it is a welcomed cultural experience that we share. Now it is true that I find some Irish-Americans to be a bit plastic in the 'ritual', but I don't take offense to it. It's fun, good spirit, and imitation is a high form of flattery (or insanity...)

I wish I'd of been out and about with you when any of these idjits made you learn the "hard way" - I'd of bloodied their nose and blackened their eye.

SF

1234 said...

you know, i don't think most people do it on purpose. it's just one of those situations that many white people haven't processed, so they aren't prepared to hide whatever reaction they have at the moment it occurs.

there are, however, many freaks at the bar. you're welcome to them if you come back and visit!

Anonymous said...

I went out this year and saw people of 'obviously not Irish ancestry' painted green and wearing green and so forth. They seemed to be treated like the rest of us (badly haha)

Perhaps it's just a yanquee thing.

I even go to use the grand line:
My son, can you *imagine* the pain of picking up your own teeth with broken fingers?

...I hate it when people snap my braces.

SF

B said...

St. Patrick's day is interesting to me. I understand that Irish people have been through a lot historically, but I don't really understand what that has to do with binge drinking on one specific day every year. I feel weird on St. Patrick's day because 1) I am not Irish and don't like being told that "everyone is Irish" and 2) I can't handle the people who are drunk from 9 AM to midnight. Seriously. It also sucks that Cinco de Mayo has that sort of vibe too, at least in St. Paul. It's so much about drinking. :-( Why??? Is that just the American spin?

Anonymous said...

It is an American spin. Though I can say there's a decent amount of drinking in Ireland too - it's only because that caught on. In the village of which I'm from, it's a go to mass, have a fry up, then go home sort of day.

The parades and all that started in the U.S. Of course, they happen in Ireland now, as it's good for the trade and tourism. Plus, all and all it's good craic anyway.

SF