I never thought this would be a question I'd end up asking myself, but would you rather hate your ex-romantic interest because of something they've done to you, or because you find out they're actually a bad person? Which is worse?
I don't actually hate ex-DB, but I'm anguished and sad that he didn't end up being the person I wanted him to be. And it's not because of anything he's done to me in anger, but rather because he has shown himself to be objectively corrupt. I understand that I am more concerned than most other people with the content of his character, but when he is a trustee of our shared frisbee team's best interests and commits a sickening breach of faith (and then paints me as stirring up drama), it affects everyone. It is public knowledge.
I've mostly kept our interpersonal issues off my blog because some of you know him. It's just easier for you if you can keep on calmly liking him until you forget about him. It takes a lot of energy to love and hate, and it's not anything I'd force you to go through on my behalf. Also, it's just been easier for me to mentally rationalize having been in a relationship with him for 7 years if I can treat him like he was worth it. Like he was friend material, at the very least.
Something that I just could never handle, in all the time I knew him, was his inability to face himself. He could not admit wrongdoing, and he'd take all steps to evade capture. He used omissions and partial truths. Capture, meaning me asking him point blank what was up. I couldn't handle it. I internalized a lot of our issues, thinking that I was somehow flawed because I wasn't happy, and repeating to myself that I was lucky to have a responsible, handsome, friendly, and employed husband. And I was lucky to have those things. But there are just some things I cannot live with (where others could), and the inability to face yourself is one of them. I like getting chocolates, but I don't need them. What I do need, always, is someone who can look me in the eye and say exactly what happened, even if it means admitting wrongdoing. Especially unsolicited admissions of wrongdoing. I need someone who will look out for not just my best interests, but who will demonstrate the strength of character necessary to care for the interests of anyone depending on him.
In some circles, people who do this are called "adults."
But I didn't know it. I didn't know that there were adults out there. Later, after ex-DB and I were separated and was visiting a therapist (Hal2000), Hal2000 commented that I seemed to treat ex-DB like he was my child. I was stunned, but then agreed. Looking back I realize that it was because I had to chase him around his evasive answers in order to protect myself, because I couldn't depend on him to protect me from himself. (Try to build a relationship of trust around that, and then try to feel good about it.)
I'd gotten used to it and I expected it. I just never thought he'd do it to an entire group of friends and teammates.
Ultimate frisbee (now called "Ultimate" because of patent issues) may seem like a casual recreational activity (see: kickball) to those who aren't involved. What do we do, just play fetch with ourselves? It might look like that. We don't have referees. We wear costumes sometimes. But we take ourselves seriously, and we have our share of fanatics and lifers. At any rate, Ultimate culture is a very specific, defined, and committed thing, as is evidenced by the fact that I have played on the same team for seven years. The only other thing I've done the same for seven years was be married, and my Ultimate team outlasted that. My teammates are former classmates from undergrad and new friends we've picked up along the way. We've seen three internal marriages, one internal divorce, three children, and multiple other marriages and breakups together. We're as close as it gets to being a TeamFamily.
Ultimate is also divided into two realms - competitive and recreational. "Recreational" is a misnomer in the Twin Cities, because it implies a light emotional commitment and a lot of beer. There is a lot of beer, but it happens after the games. People break themselves. They get surgery, they still attend games to cheer, and then they come back and play. Competitive Ultimate is called "club," and means that teams travel to various tournaments all around the country for glory, honor, and good times. My team is recreational and doesn't travel - we play in the one and only Twin Cities league (which houses 48 full teams, last time I checked).
I invited ex-DB to join my team back in 2006, and since then he has become a captain. Our team runs pretty democratically, however, and we consider ourselves group-owned. New players are invited based on personal relationships with current players and when our roster is limited, playing time is generally decided by who gets their money to the captain first. Right now we have two official captains and one informal prior captain who just doesn't want to handle logistics anymore.
We usually play fall league and winter league together. Because the league has to purchase fieldhouse time, the winter season is limited to 16 teams. Each year, the returning teams are given the option of re-signing up before the league opens to new teams. Obviously, new teams don't get to register very frequently because everyone wants to sign up again. The local Ultimate community is very close-knit, so people often move from team to team based on who needs players in a given year. Our team doesn't though. We've always stuck together, and we've always signed up.
This year, though, after the fall season ended we got an email from ex-DB saying that our bid for winter league failed and that while it was a "disappointment for all of us," we could use the time to heal, practice, and get ready for next fall. We figured that he'd done his best.
Last week I found out that he IS playing winter league. He is actually captaining a team, and it consists of people who play for his competitive club team.
I emailed him: "Did you try bidding for [our team] or did you decide you couldn't since you wouldn't be playing on it? I don't like that you made it sound like you wouldn't be playing winter league either. I hope it's the first, because if you didn't bid for us someone else could have."
I got an email back right away: "No other teams were allowed in this year. There wasn't even one open spot."
Pause for assessment.
This curt answer was uncharacteristic of him, except for when he's hiding something. Technically the words were true but I could tell he was being slippery. I asked: "Other teams?
No response.
The next day, I emailed the league administrator to see if anyone had tried to bid for us: "I have a question about the winter league registration process. Do returning teams get an automatic slot or seniority? Did anyone place a bid for [our team]?"
He replied: "[Your team] re-signed up and renamed themselves [other team]. All teams from last year get an automatic bid if they want it. All teams returned this year."
In other words, ex-DB took our reserved spot and gave it to his other team. But he tried to hide it.
This was confirmed by a few phone calls, where I found out that he'd been plotting this since October. He had so many opportunities to tell us the truth - any point during fall league games, at the team Christmas party when someone asked him point-blank, in November when a fellow teammate emailed him, and when I emailed him last week. Technically "no other teams were allowed in this year," as he said, but he evaded the real issue in his answer. He knew what I was asking.
I sent out an email to our team explaining what had happened, and seeking an apology from him and our other captains. If he'd just responded to me honestly (or at all... I waited until the next day), I would have told him that what he did was wrong and I would have let him tell the entire team. But he did nothing.
In response to my email, he sent out a brief message saying that he was sorry if anyone was confused and that he loved all of us dearly. But that was it. No apology.
Four days later, still no apology. In fact, he is spinning the events to appear that he had every right to "evolve" our team into a better one for winter league, and that such changes were the result of natural turnover among Ultimate teams. He hasn't addressed this to our team, however, because he knows we'd call bullshit on him. We had no say in this "natural turnover." We've never done things this way, and we've never changed our name for winter league. The team that is playing right now is not us although he maintains that it is because the roster includes some members who play for both. He lied, and now he is lying about lying. The new name he gave this "evolved" version of our team? After a Google search, we realized it's a character from the same video game as the name of his club team. How conceited do you have to be to so openly "hide" your intent?
A few individuals who play for both our recreational team and his club team emailed me to say that they are not playing winter league because they felt that it was wrong, but their names were left on the roster to make it appear that our recreational team was still there. Other, differently-minded individuals have unfriended me on FB. Undoubtedly they've been swayed by ex-DB's charisma and ability to paint himself as the victim, which I've too easily let him do. In our marriage I assumed my unhappiness was my fault. In retrospect, it was really the result of our conflict between different ways to live.
While I am upset about not getting to play this winter, I am mainly horrified by the lies. And by his selfish behavior in the first place.
I honestly never thought he could screw over an entire team full of people he's known for years and then easily brush off our hurt. I knew he was capable of doing the same type of thing to me on a smaller level, but this is an objectively corrupt thing to do.
Because it's Minnesota, and because we're all worried about staying together, I doubt anything major will come of it. I think it will be business as usual next fall, and he'll still be captain. But I hope that my email will let him know that now we're all aware of what he's capable of, and maybe he'll watch his step. Or maybe not. He's pretty full of himself, and he's afraid to consider the idea that he might not be worth the size of his ego. So he's probably succeeded in convincing himself that his selfishness was actually legitimate decision-making on behalf of our team.
I was livid all of Friday. Just shaking with rage. Then I came down with major headaches over the weekend. And now I am sad. Sad, and confused by what a poor judge of character I am. I never knew, until I began dating someone else, what it was like to have your partner truly take care of you. Not with grand gestures but through real consideration of your best interests. And not just in emergencies but on an ongoing basis, and for everyone else in his life. Real selflessness, and without thanks or recognition. I'd give you examples but I'd sound ridiculous. Also, those are not my stories to tell.
It's embarrassing to take your partner out in public, introduce him to people you admire, and be associated with him when you don't respect him on a very basic level. When ex-DB and I were together I always felt like I was teaching him things, and I was, but maybe they were things he wasn't supposed to learn. He is happiest when he is blindly following his happy-go-lucky desires, most of which are not compatible with my lifestyle.
Ex-DB never understood what I needed. Even when it came to gifts, he didn't get it. I wanted him to be someone with a spine. Instead, I got A) a dead/dried flower, B) a replica of a pope necklace from the Vatican, and C) a new cat 1 month after Bjorn died. I learned how to appreciate the intent behind the gifts, but I knew he didn't really see me. He supported me when it suited him and I know it wasn't all fun and games, and I'm grateful for the things he did right. But. I could never predict when I could rely on him, when it didn't benefit him as well.
I give him credit for trying to see me, and he did try, but he just could not be the person I thought was in there. He never learned how to look at the world without the naive lens of his privilege and entitlement clouding his judgment. He couldn't see what I saw, and thus couldn't understand what I wanted - whether it was more than a token gift or something within himself. I tried to teach him, but eventually realized I didn't want to. Too heartbreaking and futile.
So now I have been slammed in the face with the blatant realization that not only are we as different as I suspected, but that but that the person I was married to (for god's sake) is capable of calculated deviousness and betrayal. He definitely went downhill fast since he had me dragging my heels behind him. I'm not perfect, but I'm also not stupid, and this is even more reckless than the time he sank thousands of dollars into a Central American "mine" without asking me. He threw away so many relationships when he lied. Years and years. He probably assumes they'll forgive him because he is so charismatic. And they might. But he doesn't care.
It's all symptomatic of his selfishness and paranoia - he can't see himself clearly, and so he can't get better.
For those of you who were wondering how long we could last playing on the same team - we were doing just fine on the field. The arguments we used to have when I tried to reign in his unprofessional attitude no longer occurred after our divorce because I no longer felt burdened by my association with him. We could have shared joint custody of the team indefinitely. This time ex-DB's betrayal was not within our relationship, and was not specifically targeted at me. It was cold, calculated, and affected everyone.
Suffice it to say, on both counts,
Peace out, homies.