Hooray! The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld California District Judge Walker's opinion that revoking lesbian and gay individuals' right to marry violates the Equal Protection clause in our national constitution. They held that the people of CA may not add a provision to their state constitution that, for all practical purposes, accomplishes nothing further than stripping gays and lesbians of a preexisting right to use an official designation that the state grants all other individuals.
The ruling, expressed more succinctly, is this: "Tsk tsk, California, you can't go back on your word."
Which sounds great, but unfortunately that particular reasoning does not create same-sex marriage in states that did not initially offer same-sex marriage (and then retract it). So, only California is affected entirely by this ruling, and even then it'll be awhile before it can take effect.
If the court had ruled that marriage belongs to everyone, the whole wedding industry west of the rockies would be gunning for the extra business. But it's just California.
Luckily, District Judge Walker made 80 findings of fact in his decision that include the immutability of sexual orientation, etc. and the 9th Circuit left them alone, so everyone under their jurisdiction, not just Californians, can rely on those facts as legally valid in lawsuits regarding LGBT rights in general.
If the 9th Circuit had ruled more broadly and substantively regarding same-sex marriage itself, all the conservatives would be up in arms about activist benches. As it stands, the ruling is very specific, even if it was also very fair. If it goes to the Supreme Court and they approve it "as is," it would still only affect Californians.
This is a great step, but it is not the earthshattering case we are looking for. One win at a time.
Congrats, Californians!
No comments:
Post a Comment