I am terribly, horribly nervous about the MN marriage amendment on the ballot next November.
It will read, "Shall the Minnesota Constitution be amended to provide that only a union of one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in Minnesota?"
On its face it sounds only mildly discriminatory, as if the amendment is merely asking voters to affirm that marriage between a man and woman is, in fact, a marriage, and any incidental exclusion that occurs is unfortunate but a minor issue.
NO!
How is my grandmother supposed to know to vote "no" on this? If you sat her down and asked point blank, "Should we change our state constitution to say that your grandson should never ever be able to marry his partner? This is nearly impossible to revoke, and there are already Minnesotan laws against same-sex marriage," she'd say no.
If you asked her, "Is real marriage between men and women?" she'd say yes. Because those marriages are real. Also.
Why the hell is this on our ballot?
Issue 1: One should never legislate by subjecting the human rights of a minority to the passions of the majority. This is where famous civil rights court cases come from. There is a reason why we put smart people in the judicial branch - so they can hold onto their heads when the rest of us are on fire. Stupid, unconstitutional laws exist. Judges are there to say so, and the rest of the reasonable people understand after a few decades of justice. Loving v. Virginia. Brown v. Board of Education. And for a current example, see the University of North Dakota's return to using "fighting sioux" as its mascot. In a 2007 study, 21 Native American related UND programs opposed the use of this image and name, and none supported it. But it was put to a state-wide vote, which statistically means that the tribes were subject to the whim of the 94.6% North Dakotans who are non-Native. If that wasn't a foregone conclusion, I dont know what would be.
Issue 2: This. Is. Permanent. There is already a MN law that exists stating that marriage is only between a man and a woman. This constitutional amendment would only serve to kick people that are already down. And it is nearly impossible to "un-do" constitutional amendments. This is an extreme measure that only accomplishes one thing - discrimination. There's no economic benefit. There's no social benefit.
Issue 3: Governing via constitutional amendment lacks serious foresight. Look what happened to California after they decided to amend their constitution to limit property taxes. All of a sudden, no money! (And they were surprised?) Years later, after they studied economics, they realized that all the variables they'd depended on had changed and they'd made a poor decision. If we want our constitution to last for all time, then we have to stop enshrining partisanally-motivated trendy taglines in it. Bigger picture, people.
So why is this amendment on our ballot? Pure hate? Ignorance? I think it's a combination of the two, plus ego - local republicans want to leave a permanent mark, so they're trying to pee all over our constitution like it's their personal fire hydrant. Also, they have to appease the crazies if they want enough votes to win republican seats in future elections.
And one final thing. Catholic Archbishop Nienstedt. Buddy needs to chill out. A far cry from the much-loved, incredibly wise Archbishop Harry Flynn, whose shoes were too big for Nienstedt to fill. This current archbishop has made it is very personal, very specific goal to crush same-sex-marriage. If it's the last thing he does, he's going to make sure the whole state lives his way. He's deliberately inciting his sheep to believe that same-sex marriage will encroach on religious liberty, as if the government was planning to somehow force priests to perform religious ceremonies.
Whenever LGBT rights come up, somehow the discussion veers into the weird terrain of whether homosexuality, in general, is ok. Really, that's what we're talking about? But yes. So when kids in Michele Bachmann's school district begin to commit suicide in double digits because their district lives under a "neutrality" policy that bars teachers from interfering with sexuality-based bullying, the school board stands by its policy because otherwise "the kids will think homosexuality is normal." No you idiots, what your children are learning is that it's ok to bully the weaker kids until they die. And the weaker kids are experiencing that even their teachers think they don't deserve to live. Bullying is bullying, no matter the underlying reason (which is a terrible one to begin with).
When LGBT employment rights like wrongful termination come up, or when any other normal human issue arises for this particular group, all of a sudden the conversation grows to include a debate on the morality of an identity. Seriously, seriously hijacked.
Under federalist principles (which republicans purport to be big fans of), the national government is the bottom line when it comes to rights, and the states may add to the list of enumerated rights, but they may not subtract them. Now whether the rights exist somewhere in the Constitution in the first place has always been a struggle throughout history (women's suffrage, brown people's rights, etc.), but something is definitely out of whack when certain people go to a lot of effort to limit a specific group of other people's rights. This is never ok, unless your membership in those groups can evolve (for instance adults changing teenagers' rights to drink or smoke) or unless the members of the affected group can't think for themselves.
And that's not what the republicans are saying, is it? That LGBT people are lesser human beings who can't make their own decisions or think for themselves? Are they, by definition, doing anything dangerous that needs limiting (like drugs)? No. So it must be that republicans don't think LGBT people do laundry, or pay taxes, or have families. Because everyone knows that the gays are contagious, and if they were doing those things then everyone in the state would be doing laundry and paying taxes, and god knows that doesn't happen. Laundry especially, if you look at some of my coworkers.
When the discussion suddenly becomes about "whether gayness is ok," people like my grandma lose sight of what is actually going on with the amendment business and get drawn into irrelevant discussions. The issue is: Should Minnesotans ban all same-sex marriages forever via a redundant and permanent constitutional amendment?
The answer, if you didn't catch my drift, is no.
figuring out what's real at the intersection of race, gender, and transnational adoption in america... this involves some serious discussions about food and my cat, roger.
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
another optometrist visit (do these ever go well?)
I had the most thorough eye exam ever today. It took two hours. My optometrist put three different drops in my eyes to do 3 different tests. I definitely felt like I had goldfish eyes. They were dyed yellow, numb, and dilated.
I started going to a new optometrist because, let's face it, when you work downtown Minneapolis you don't want to drive to West St. Paul midday just so you can renew your yearly contact lens prescription. Unfortunately, whenever I start going to any new doctor I forget about everything that comes with it and I feel like they're pouncing on me.
She'd never treated anyone with my chronic illness before. Whenever medical staff ask which medications I'm taking, they inevitably want to know what everything is for. Makes sense. But once I explain they get creeped out.
""What's that?"
This optometrist had never treated anyone with my illness before. She didn't know what to do. She got really awkward and then started washing her hands every 5 minutes (excessive, even for flu season). For a 2-hour appointment, that's a lot. I felt like a leper.
She paused to go look up the effects of my illness on my eyesight. I don't think she found anything. There's not much out there.
Then she asked how I got it.
"I was born with it."
"Oh, were you born here, or...?"
"Korea."
"Oh, are your parents... I mean... did your parents come here or..."
"I'm adopted."
"So that explains why you don't have any medical history."
Yes. Yes, it does.
She took lots of pictures and discovered that I have four opacities in my right eye. Blind spots. Which are new. I was trying not to freak out about going blind when she asked, "Does your freckled skin feel any different?"
"What?"
"I'm wondering why you only have opacities in one eye. Have you had trauma in that eye? Infection?"
"Nope."
"Maybe there's something different about that side of your body."
Kind of like the time U of M researchers thought my freckles meant I would develop Proteus syndrome. Now that was a conversation my parents didn't want to have.
Listen lady, no one knows why my freckles are weird. The most coherent explanation I've heard sounds like "neurological disorder" and I never want to hear that again. So unless you have a cogent reason for tying my freckles to my blind spots, don't freak me out!
"No idea," I muttered.
After my appointment her assistant reviewed my benefits plan, which included greatly-discounted frames and lenses every other year. I was excited. Was it time, perhaps, to finally get new glasses?
If you were wondering, it was not that time. My day hadn't been going great so far. This morning I found out that my project, which was slated to go through March, was ending on Thursday. No future money in immediate sight. So obviously to keep the trend going there was no way I was going to find glasses that fit.
Let me emphasize that there was no way I was going to find glasses that fit. Not just "looked nice," but that actually fit.
Because I have an Asian face.
If I didn't want to wear dorky wire frames (they work on some white people but they make American Asians look fresh off the boat), I was out of luck. Because I can't wear the cute plastic frames I see on people all the time. They don't sit high enough on my face, and they slip off easily. I've tried to pull this style off before but it doesn't work - the bridge on white people glasses is so high and wide that I need nose pads to keep them on.
And while I appreciate the effort, I am not about to sport a pair of these. Maybe if it was 1995 and I had a thing for orange tans and water-skiing.
The eyeglasses assistant didn't want to admit failure but after awhile even she had to admit that it was futile. I give her props for actually saying, "You have a lower bridge and need to look for something that fits it," instead of either A) not knowing my face works differently, or B) awkwardly pushing wire frames at me but not explaining why, like other salespeople I've spent time with.
I walked out, dejected, and texted two of my Asian friends who have cute thick glasses.
One said, "Got my glasses in Korea! Lots of Asian noses there, haha."
"Damn. There's nothing here for me," I said. "Also, I got the adoption schpiel from her."
"Fucking eye doctors. Sorry, friend. Mine told me the reason I was having issues with contact lenses is because my eyes were too narrow. Wtf?" she responded.
The second friend I asked said, "You're not going to like this but I got them in Korea."
"I figured."
Inter-country adoption strikes again. When I go back to Korea don't let me leave without bras, eyeglasses, makeup, and hair products. Apparently my body doesn't belong in America.
I started going to a new optometrist because, let's face it, when you work downtown Minneapolis you don't want to drive to West St. Paul midday just so you can renew your yearly contact lens prescription. Unfortunately, whenever I start going to any new doctor I forget about everything that comes with it and I feel like they're pouncing on me.
She'd never treated anyone with my chronic illness before. Whenever medical staff ask which medications I'm taking, they inevitably want to know what everything is for. Makes sense. But once I explain they get creeped out.
""What's that?"
This optometrist had never treated anyone with my illness before. She didn't know what to do. She got really awkward and then started washing her hands every 5 minutes (excessive, even for flu season). For a 2-hour appointment, that's a lot. I felt like a leper.
She paused to go look up the effects of my illness on my eyesight. I don't think she found anything. There's not much out there.
Then she asked how I got it.
"I was born with it."
"Oh, were you born here, or...?"
"Korea."
"Oh, are your parents... I mean... did your parents come here or..."
"I'm adopted."
"So that explains why you don't have any medical history."
Yes. Yes, it does.
She took lots of pictures and discovered that I have four opacities in my right eye. Blind spots. Which are new. I was trying not to freak out about going blind when she asked, "Does your freckled skin feel any different?"
"What?"
"I'm wondering why you only have opacities in one eye. Have you had trauma in that eye? Infection?"
"Nope."
"Maybe there's something different about that side of your body."
Kind of like the time U of M researchers thought my freckles meant I would develop Proteus syndrome. Now that was a conversation my parents didn't want to have.
Listen lady, no one knows why my freckles are weird. The most coherent explanation I've heard sounds like "neurological disorder" and I never want to hear that again. So unless you have a cogent reason for tying my freckles to my blind spots, don't freak me out!
"No idea," I muttered.
After my appointment her assistant reviewed my benefits plan, which included greatly-discounted frames and lenses every other year. I was excited. Was it time, perhaps, to finally get new glasses?
If you were wondering, it was not that time. My day hadn't been going great so far. This morning I found out that my project, which was slated to go through March, was ending on Thursday. No future money in immediate sight. So obviously to keep the trend going there was no way I was going to find glasses that fit.
Let me emphasize that there was no way I was going to find glasses that fit. Not just "looked nice," but that actually fit.
Because I have an Asian face.
If I didn't want to wear dorky wire frames (they work on some white people but they make American Asians look fresh off the boat), I was out of luck. Because I can't wear the cute plastic frames I see on people all the time. They don't sit high enough on my face, and they slip off easily. I've tried to pull this style off before but it doesn't work - the bridge on white people glasses is so high and wide that I need nose pads to keep them on.
And while I appreciate the effort, I am not about to sport a pair of these. Maybe if it was 1995 and I had a thing for orange tans and water-skiing.
The eyeglasses assistant didn't want to admit failure but after awhile even she had to admit that it was futile. I give her props for actually saying, "You have a lower bridge and need to look for something that fits it," instead of either A) not knowing my face works differently, or B) awkwardly pushing wire frames at me but not explaining why, like other salespeople I've spent time with.
I walked out, dejected, and texted two of my Asian friends who have cute thick glasses.
One said, "Got my glasses in Korea! Lots of Asian noses there, haha."
"Damn. There's nothing here for me," I said. "Also, I got the adoption schpiel from her."
"Fucking eye doctors. Sorry, friend. Mine told me the reason I was having issues with contact lenses is because my eyes were too narrow. Wtf?" she responded.
The second friend I asked said, "You're not going to like this but I got them in Korea."
"I figured."
Inter-country adoption strikes again. When I go back to Korea don't let me leave without bras, eyeglasses, makeup, and hair products. Apparently my body doesn't belong in America.
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
proposition 8 is still unconstitutional!
Hooray! The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld California District Judge Walker's opinion that revoking lesbian and gay individuals' right to marry violates the Equal Protection clause in our national constitution. They held that the people of CA may not add a provision to their state constitution that, for all practical purposes, accomplishes nothing further than stripping gays and lesbians of a preexisting right to use an official designation that the state grants all other individuals.
The ruling, expressed more succinctly, is this: "Tsk tsk, California, you can't go back on your word."
Which sounds great, but unfortunately that particular reasoning does not create same-sex marriage in states that did not initially offer same-sex marriage (and then retract it). So, only California is affected entirely by this ruling, and even then it'll be awhile before it can take effect.
If the court had ruled that marriage belongs to everyone, the whole wedding industry west of the rockies would be gunning for the extra business. But it's just California.
Luckily, District Judge Walker made 80 findings of fact in his decision that include the immutability of sexual orientation, etc. and the 9th Circuit left them alone, so everyone under their jurisdiction, not just Californians, can rely on those facts as legally valid in lawsuits regarding LGBT rights in general.
If the 9th Circuit had ruled more broadly and substantively regarding same-sex marriage itself, all the conservatives would be up in arms about activist benches. As it stands, the ruling is very specific, even if it was also very fair. If it goes to the Supreme Court and they approve it "as is," it would still only affect Californians.
This is a great step, but it is not the earthshattering case we are looking for. One win at a time.
Congrats, Californians!
The ruling, expressed more succinctly, is this: "Tsk tsk, California, you can't go back on your word."
Which sounds great, but unfortunately that particular reasoning does not create same-sex marriage in states that did not initially offer same-sex marriage (and then retract it). So, only California is affected entirely by this ruling, and even then it'll be awhile before it can take effect.
If the court had ruled that marriage belongs to everyone, the whole wedding industry west of the rockies would be gunning for the extra business. But it's just California.
Luckily, District Judge Walker made 80 findings of fact in his decision that include the immutability of sexual orientation, etc. and the 9th Circuit left them alone, so everyone under their jurisdiction, not just Californians, can rely on those facts as legally valid in lawsuits regarding LGBT rights in general.
If the 9th Circuit had ruled more broadly and substantively regarding same-sex marriage itself, all the conservatives would be up in arms about activist benches. As it stands, the ruling is very specific, even if it was also very fair. If it goes to the Supreme Court and they approve it "as is," it would still only affect Californians.
This is a great step, but it is not the earthshattering case we are looking for. One win at a time.
Congrats, Californians!
Monday, February 6, 2012
the nerd conference
I am going to LA in a few weeks! There are a bunch of meetings to discuss reunification on the Korean peninsula, the implications of Kim Jong-il's death, etc. and two groups are sponsoring my trip. I won't have that much to contribute, but I'm really excited to get to tag along.
I'll only be there Friday night through Sunday afternoon so I won't have time to do anything touristy, but that doesn't bother me. I'm there for the nerd discussions. Whenever people ask what I've "been up to" or what I do for fun, it's hard to know which non sequitur is least worst: talking about my cat, repeating the frisbee monologue, complaining about the weather, complaining about the job market, or attempting to explain that I mostly participate in civic organizations and advocacy study groups. Sometimes I go to fringe theater. But in the last week, for instance, all my free time was spent researching facts and laws for an adoptee immigration justice campaign, writing bylaws for a new pan-Asian organization, and learning about U.S. militarism and foreign policy. I saw some friends for late-night drinks. But we talked about issues surrounding the governance of our adoptee summer camp. I saw some other friends for happy hour, but we talked about how to stop a North-Korean-adoption bill. And another day I had dinner with the steering committee for the pan-Asian organization.
I like doing all of these things. It's just hard to explain to someone looking for an answer like, "I just transferred to a different company," or, "I make my own wine." Plus my head is so far into my own world that I lose the ability to remember who knows and doesn't know what. And most people don't want to know that adoption is more than just a personal interest story. So if I want to leave them alone I have to come up with something better than, "My cat snores," so I don't sound like a total loser.
P.S. He DOES snore. He'd be a complete failure in the wild.
I'll only be there Friday night through Sunday afternoon so I won't have time to do anything touristy, but that doesn't bother me. I'm there for the nerd discussions. Whenever people ask what I've "been up to" or what I do for fun, it's hard to know which non sequitur is least worst: talking about my cat, repeating the frisbee monologue, complaining about the weather, complaining about the job market, or attempting to explain that I mostly participate in civic organizations and advocacy study groups. Sometimes I go to fringe theater. But in the last week, for instance, all my free time was spent researching facts and laws for an adoptee immigration justice campaign, writing bylaws for a new pan-Asian organization, and learning about U.S. militarism and foreign policy. I saw some friends for late-night drinks. But we talked about issues surrounding the governance of our adoptee summer camp. I saw some other friends for happy hour, but we talked about how to stop a North-Korean-adoption bill. And another day I had dinner with the steering committee for the pan-Asian organization.
I like doing all of these things. It's just hard to explain to someone looking for an answer like, "I just transferred to a different company," or, "I make my own wine." Plus my head is so far into my own world that I lose the ability to remember who knows and doesn't know what. And most people don't want to know that adoption is more than just a personal interest story. So if I want to leave them alone I have to come up with something better than, "My cat snores," so I don't sound like a total loser.
P.S. He DOES snore. He'd be a complete failure in the wild.
Sunday, February 5, 2012
south korea's national security law
That paranoid national security law (or group of laws) that I mentioned in a previous post, that South Korea uses to stifle any opposition, has made its way into American news. The NY Times picked it up because a political artist was arrested under it for re-posting [edited, satirical] North Korean tweets.
We level all sorts of propaganda accusations at North Korea, but South Korea does the same thing. They both stifle free speech. South Koreans are often afraid to talk about the North at all. My friend's family found her research books on North Korea and freaked out.
If I got caught studying North Korea or working on reunification activities, I could be arrested and/or any visa I had could be revoked.
"During the first 10 months of 2011, the police deleted 67,300 Web posts they believed threatened national security by 'praising North Korea and denouncing the U.S. and the government...'"
President Lee Myung-bak continues to send South Korea backwards.
We level all sorts of propaganda accusations at North Korea, but South Korea does the same thing. They both stifle free speech. South Koreans are often afraid to talk about the North at all. My friend's family found her research books on North Korea and freaked out.
If I got caught studying North Korea or working on reunification activities, I could be arrested and/or any visa I had could be revoked.
"During the first 10 months of 2011, the police deleted 67,300 Web posts they believed threatened national security by 'praising North Korea and denouncing the U.S. and the government...'"
President Lee Myung-bak continues to send South Korea backwards.
Thursday, February 2, 2012
komen vs. planned parenthood
A fellow law school alum posted this link as her Facebook status:
Live Action Applauds Komen Defunding Of Planned Parenthood.
She said: "FANTASTIC!! Goooood job, Komen, well done! PLEASE stop what you are doing right now and write to news@komen.org and say (in English please): 'Thanks for defunding Planned Parenthood!' That's all you have to say! And it will make a huge difference :)"
I almost barfed.
ArtsyChef, one of my coworkers (also a fellow alum) turned beet red and started shaking. I watched it happen.
Texts from other women we graduated with started pouring in. Apparently our classmate managed to aggravate all of us.
Comments on her Facebook post, in order:
ArtsyChef: "Yeah, cancer screenings and education are the worst!"
Me: "But I only speak Spanish."
EarthMadre: "For the record, I personally have received breast cancer screenings from Planned Parenthood, during a time when I certainly couldn't have afforded other care. If that was Komen fundraising - thanks! Sorry you're stopping. And the notion that two organizations can't work together on one goal just because they also have individual goals is absurd. That kind of attitude is why Republicans and Democrats can't get anything done in Congress!"
And then our classmate's conservative friends jumped in with a bunch of arguments about how terrible abortion is. "Planned Parenthood, with a sucking tube, purposefully dismembers and decapitates thousands of unborn babies every day. Think I am lying? Think I am extreme? Watch an ultrasound of an abortion procedure and then tell me I am extreme. I dare you."
They kept going. In their eagerness to sensationalize their pet project, they missed our point (well, the other alumni's point... I was responding to the inanely racist ownership of the message). Our point was not "abortion is awesome." Do you know what Planned Parenthood does? I just want to tell them listen. Idiots. This is not a "win" for the pro-life movement. The number of abortions it will stop, if any, is probably under 5. And if Komen wanted to stop funding Planned Parenthood for logistical reasons (one of its arguments) then so be it, but it's still a travesty for the women who relied on that funding for their health. There are probably lots of other places you can get mammograms, but Planned Parenthood is such a well-established organization that reaches so many women. Why not help their already-existing population?
Even if you're adamantly pro-life and are celebrating the detrriment to an organization that 2% of the time does things you think are evil, I think a baby and bathwater analogy would be appropriate here. Our point, which the crazies missed, was that:
More breast cancer checks for the poor = good
Less breast cancer checks for the poor = bad
EarthMadre kept trying to reason with them. She noted that Planned Parenthood served as a good safety net for women who weren't thinking of other aspects of their health. Women walk in to get contraceptives and then realize they should get a whole medical workover, thus catching their breast cancer early.
Texts:
EarthMadre: My god I'm annoyed.
Me: Your logic is impeccable. The only problem is that it's directed at idiots.
EM: Yes. Yes it is. I should stop. Last Word Syndrome ends in pain.
Me: They make me want to scream and throw things. At the very least, any sane readers will pick up on the fact that you make better points than the other commenters. And any insane readers were lost causes to begin with.
EM: "But they are MURDERERS!!!"
Me: Genociders.
EM: I bet Planned Parenthood slaughters puppies at the employee Christmas party.
Me: Of course they do. They worship Satan, and Satan eats puppies.
EM: Let's eat Scarlett for dinner.
Well played, dear roommate. Well played.
Live Action Applauds Komen Defunding Of Planned Parenthood.
She said: "FANTASTIC!! Goooood job, Komen, well done! PLEASE stop what you are doing right now and write to news@komen.org and say (in English please): 'Thanks for defunding Planned Parenthood!' That's all you have to say! And it will make a huge difference :)"
I almost barfed.
ArtsyChef, one of my coworkers (also a fellow alum) turned beet red and started shaking. I watched it happen.
Texts from other women we graduated with started pouring in. Apparently our classmate managed to aggravate all of us.
Comments on her Facebook post, in order:
ArtsyChef: "Yeah, cancer screenings and education are the worst!"
Me: "But I only speak Spanish."
EarthMadre: "For the record, I personally have received breast cancer screenings from Planned Parenthood, during a time when I certainly couldn't have afforded other care. If that was Komen fundraising - thanks! Sorry you're stopping. And the notion that two organizations can't work together on one goal just because they also have individual goals is absurd. That kind of attitude is why Republicans and Democrats can't get anything done in Congress!"
And then our classmate's conservative friends jumped in with a bunch of arguments about how terrible abortion is. "Planned Parenthood, with a sucking tube, purposefully dismembers and decapitates thousands of unborn babies every day. Think I am lying? Think I am extreme? Watch an ultrasound of an abortion procedure and then tell me I am extreme. I dare you."
They kept going. In their eagerness to sensationalize their pet project, they missed our point (well, the other alumni's point... I was responding to the inanely racist ownership of the message). Our point was not "abortion is awesome." Do you know what Planned Parenthood does? I just want to tell them listen. Idiots. This is not a "win" for the pro-life movement. The number of abortions it will stop, if any, is probably under 5. And if Komen wanted to stop funding Planned Parenthood for logistical reasons (one of its arguments) then so be it, but it's still a travesty for the women who relied on that funding for their health. There are probably lots of other places you can get mammograms, but Planned Parenthood is such a well-established organization that reaches so many women. Why not help their already-existing population?
Even if you're adamantly pro-life and are celebrating the detrriment to an organization that 2% of the time does things you think are evil, I think a baby and bathwater analogy would be appropriate here. Our point, which the crazies missed, was that:
More breast cancer checks for the poor = good
Less breast cancer checks for the poor = bad
Texts:
EarthMadre: My god I'm annoyed.
Me: Your logic is impeccable. The only problem is that it's directed at idiots.
EM: Yes. Yes it is. I should stop. Last Word Syndrome ends in pain.
Me: They make me want to scream and throw things. At the very least, any sane readers will pick up on the fact that you make better points than the other commenters. And any insane readers were lost causes to begin with.
EM: "But they are MURDERERS!!!"
Me: Genociders.
EM: I bet Planned Parenthood slaughters puppies at the employee Christmas party.
Me: Of course they do. They worship Satan, and Satan eats puppies.
EM: Let's eat Scarlett for dinner.
Well played, dear roommate. Well played.
Wednesday, February 1, 2012
ny times article: it's not me, it's you
In other words: how to end a friendship. And whether you should.
I've complained about this before. People don't end friendships in small towns, and this possibility befuddles transplants to the city (see: my college friends). In small towns there's no one else to be friends with so you can either grow with your friends and deal with the annoying bits of their lives, or move somewhere else. Everyone just expects to have to put up with their friends, because what other option is there? It's like having a family. Whether you love them or hate them, it's really hard to make them go away so you just make it work. Luckily for small town folk, there aren't that many varied experiences you can do separately in a population of a few thousand, so you and your friends will probably grow through similar experiences anyway.
Also, brown communities end friendships less frequently. Any smaller or marginalized community feels tied together for life, through good and bad, and rarely questions it. The idea of choosing not to know someone seems unrealistic once you realize that there aren't that many of you and everyone knows everyone else. You're going to run into them again, so you might as well just admit that you are friends. Forever.
The Korean adoptee community is like this. No one's friendship just fades away forever... either it is violently ended, or you have it forever. It may change in nature, but they're never going away.
I've complained about this before. People don't end friendships in small towns, and this possibility befuddles transplants to the city (see: my college friends). In small towns there's no one else to be friends with so you can either grow with your friends and deal with the annoying bits of their lives, or move somewhere else. Everyone just expects to have to put up with their friends, because what other option is there? It's like having a family. Whether you love them or hate them, it's really hard to make them go away so you just make it work. Luckily for small town folk, there aren't that many varied experiences you can do separately in a population of a few thousand, so you and your friends will probably grow through similar experiences anyway.
Also, brown communities end friendships less frequently. Any smaller or marginalized community feels tied together for life, through good and bad, and rarely questions it. The idea of choosing not to know someone seems unrealistic once you realize that there aren't that many of you and everyone knows everyone else. You're going to run into them again, so you might as well just admit that you are friends. Forever.
The Korean adoptee community is like this. No one's friendship just fades away forever... either it is violently ended, or you have it forever. It may change in nature, but they're never going away.
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
new team
So... randomly... the day after I decided I couldn't play on a team with ex-DB any more, I got a Facebook message from a Korean American (panda) and a Korean adoptee. One whom I have never met, and the other whom I have met only once.
"We were wondering if you'd be interested in joining our fall league team. We need a few more experienced women," they said.
Um, yes?
I'm pretty sure their whole team isn't Asians (or I would have noticed), but it's strange how my worlds collided. At exactly the right time.
"We were wondering if you'd be interested in joining our fall league team. We need a few more experienced women," they said.
Um, yes?
I'm pretty sure their whole team isn't Asians (or I would have noticed), but it's strange how my worlds collided. At exactly the right time.
Monday, January 30, 2012
meowsic
I recently made DadCat and MumDear CDs of songs they might like. I put them on iTunes for them.
I included some old music with the modern stuff for some contrast because I think you can really see direct paths music has taken. There is some overlap between the mixes and they'll probably borrow each other's, but here are the lists:
Dad's Party Mixx!!
1. Hotel Song (Regina Spektor)
2. Pumped Up Kicks (Foster The People)
3. Don't Gotta Work It Out (Fitz & The Tantrums)
4. Tightrope (Janelle Monae)
5. Dance To The Music (Sly & The Family Stone)
6. Kiss (Gwyneth Paltrow on Glee covering Prince)
7. Somebody That I Used To Know (Gotye)
8. Wouldn't It Be Nice (Beach Boys)
9. Mushabooom (Feist)
10. Mercy (Duffy)
11. Big Girls Don't Cry (Frankie Vallie & The Four Seasons)
12. Thieves (She & Him)
13. If I Wanted Someone (Dawes)
14. Cry To Me (Solomon Burke)
15. Rehab (Amy Winehouse)
16. Hooked (Mayer Hawthorne)
17. Blood Buzz Ohio (The National)
18. Landslide (Gwyneth Paltrow on Glee covering Fleetwood Mac)
19. Taken Up (The Limestones of St. Olaf College)
20. Kia Hora Te Marino (Christopher Tin)
Mom's Modern Mix
1. The Cave (Mumford & Sons)
2. ? (Some Brazilian group...)
3. Pennies On The Floor (The Little Willies)
4. Born To Die (Lana Del Rey)
5. Star In My Eyes (Gowe feat. Erin Kim)
6. I Feel Pretty/Unpretty (Glee West Side Story & TLC mashup)
7. The Gambler (Fun.)
8. Wait So Long (Trampled By Turtles)
9. Baba Yetu (Christopher Tin)
10. Dan Zai Fan Ye (Christopher Tin)
11. Fidelity (Regina Spektor)
12. Somebody That I Used To Know (Gotye)
13. Poison & Wine (The Civil Wars)
14. We Are Young (Glee cover of Fun. & Janelle Monae)
15. Sleeping Sickness (City & Colour)
16. Lost In My Mind (The Head & The Heart)
17. The Walk (Mayer Hawthorne)
I also made MumDear a Glee album of traditional showtunes, and a Diva's Mix so she can hear the contrast between Janelle Monae and J.Lo when she listens to them together.
I included some old music with the modern stuff for some contrast because I think you can really see direct paths music has taken. There is some overlap between the mixes and they'll probably borrow each other's, but here are the lists:
Dad's Party Mixx!!
1. Hotel Song (Regina Spektor)
2. Pumped Up Kicks (Foster The People)
3. Don't Gotta Work It Out (Fitz & The Tantrums)
4. Tightrope (Janelle Monae)
5. Dance To The Music (Sly & The Family Stone)
6. Kiss (Gwyneth Paltrow on Glee covering Prince)
7. Somebody That I Used To Know (Gotye)
8. Wouldn't It Be Nice (Beach Boys)
9. Mushabooom (Feist)
10. Mercy (Duffy)
11. Big Girls Don't Cry (Frankie Vallie & The Four Seasons)
12. Thieves (She & Him)
13. If I Wanted Someone (Dawes)
14. Cry To Me (Solomon Burke)
15. Rehab (Amy Winehouse)
16. Hooked (Mayer Hawthorne)
17. Blood Buzz Ohio (The National)
18. Landslide (Gwyneth Paltrow on Glee covering Fleetwood Mac)
19. Taken Up (The Limestones of St. Olaf College)
20. Kia Hora Te Marino (Christopher Tin)
Mom's Modern Mix
1. The Cave (Mumford & Sons)
2. ? (Some Brazilian group...)
3. Pennies On The Floor (The Little Willies)
4. Born To Die (Lana Del Rey)
5. Star In My Eyes (Gowe feat. Erin Kim)
6. I Feel Pretty/Unpretty (Glee West Side Story & TLC mashup)
7. The Gambler (Fun.)
8. Wait So Long (Trampled By Turtles)
9. Baba Yetu (Christopher Tin)
10. Dan Zai Fan Ye (Christopher Tin)
11. Fidelity (Regina Spektor)
12. Somebody That I Used To Know (Gotye)
13. Poison & Wine (The Civil Wars)
14. We Are Young (Glee cover of Fun. & Janelle Monae)
15. Sleeping Sickness (City & Colour)
16. Lost In My Mind (The Head & The Heart)
17. The Walk (Mayer Hawthorne)
I also made MumDear a Glee album of traditional showtunes, and a Diva's Mix so she can hear the contrast between Janelle Monae and J.Lo when she listens to them together.
Sunday, January 29, 2012
i got offered a job
...but I don't think I'm going to take it.
According to Mr. BearCat, people take jobs for three reasons:
1) They like the money
2) They like the work itself
3) They like the identity
Sometimes, if you are very lucky, you can get all three.
This job is none of the above for me.
1) It's paid on commission until I make partner
2) It's criminal defense, which I know nothing about
3) It's a small rural firm with no connections to anything I care about
The good things about the job are that the two partners are very nice, calm people and they have brand new office space with sunny windows. All the infrastructure that was a barrier to setting up my own firm is in place - office space, computers, filing system, business cards, retainer agreements, client bank accounts, paralegals. And when one of the current partners retires, I would inherit her estate planning practice.
But other than being able to say, "I got a job," there is nothing in it for me. The experience isn't useful for someone who doesn't want to practice. Where do I want to be in 5 years? Not in a law office. And I can only survive for 3 months without my doc review paycheck. Nothing about this job is going to make me get out of bed in the morning.
On the other hand, no one else is offering. Should I just keep doing doc review?
I've been toying with the idea of going to Korea again.
According to Mr. BearCat, people take jobs for three reasons:
1) They like the money
2) They like the work itself
3) They like the identity
Sometimes, if you are very lucky, you can get all three.
This job is none of the above for me.
1) It's paid on commission until I make partner
2) It's criminal defense, which I know nothing about
3) It's a small rural firm with no connections to anything I care about
The good things about the job are that the two partners are very nice, calm people and they have brand new office space with sunny windows. All the infrastructure that was a barrier to setting up my own firm is in place - office space, computers, filing system, business cards, retainer agreements, client bank accounts, paralegals. And when one of the current partners retires, I would inherit her estate planning practice.
But other than being able to say, "I got a job," there is nothing in it for me. The experience isn't useful for someone who doesn't want to practice. Where do I want to be in 5 years? Not in a law office. And I can only survive for 3 months without my doc review paycheck. Nothing about this job is going to make me get out of bed in the morning.
On the other hand, no one else is offering. Should I just keep doing doc review?
I've been toying with the idea of going to Korea again.
Thursday, January 26, 2012
not for you
When was the first time you knew something was not for you? I don't mean birthday presents when it's your brother's birthday (that one took me longer than it should have). I'm talking about things other people do or have that would feel wrong if you did them.
The first adult moment I can really think of is WE Fest. My high school friends started going to this in college. I remember looking at photos and thinking there's no way I'd survive there as an Asian. And at that point I was listening to country music because my roommate was obsessed with the GAC channel - Great American Country. But I knew, deep down, that it was not for me. It took me a lot longer to actually say this aloud to anyone (and then I received a lot of miffed responses).
I'm pretty sure my first real "not for me" moment came to me really late in life. I drank the Kool-Aid your teachers give you when they tell you you can be or do anything you want if you try hard enough. I knew I could never be president of the United States because I wasn't born here, but that's because someone told me when I was 8. I'm pretty sure it was my parents when I was sitting at a picnic table in a San Diego campground telling them all the things I wanted to be (astronaut, veterinarian, Clara Barton, etc.). But I could be imagining that.
White people have a hard time accepting "not for me" realizations. They think anything is possible, and that it will feel good if you want it enough when you get it. This explains a lot of skinny white boys in do-rags and baggy pants. This is also why my college roommates were offended when I told them that I really didn't think country music was for Asians.
"You could be the first Asian country music star," they encouraged. Yes, and I could also get eyelid fold surgery. Technically possible, but essentially useless. I'd be denying something true about myself if I did it. Even if the country music audience accepted me, I'd still feel weird.
My point was that country music actually is not for Asians. Neither the melodies nor the messages (nor the images) resonate with Asian culture. Whether or not you think that is ok, that is the truth. If you are Asian and you want to be the first Asian country music star, go for it, but it's weird when white people tell you it's worth trying, if only for the anomaly factor. "The first."
Since then I've accumulated a long list of "not for me" items and experiences, and while you might see that as a limiting feature, I don't. I've just made choices to be me, many of which I should have made earlier in life when I wasn't paying attention to the fact that I am a 5'10 Asian female with white parents.
Travel alone (male)? Not for me. Too dangerous.
Dreadlocks (black)? Not for me.
Breast implants (rich, shallow)? Not for me.
Live in Idaho? Not for me.
White girl hair (white, female)? Sometimes.
Theology degree (Christian, academic)? Too late.
September wedding at age 23 (pick one)? Too late.
Hippie? Too late. I didn't know that only white people can be real hippies. Asian hippies are just called failures.
You probably have your own list.
I see former classmates running off to Holden Village to find peace and Jesus, and they have their own progressive peaceful Jesus language they use when they talk to each other. They all like nature a lot too and wear bandanas on their heads when they hike in their North Face fleeces. Many of them ski. I'd say all of them are Lutheran. I used to think I was Lutheran, but then I discovered that I was not. Being Lutheran is nice, but it is not for me. So it is partially entertaining, and partially just plain weird to see people I used to know living in my former life stages and belonging there when I didn't.
Obviously, if you don't know what IS for you, you have to try a few things out. And you might be surprised. But you should have some idea of what is and is not for you, unlike me. It took me a loooooong time to accept this.
There is nothing wrong with not taking, "You can do anything!" literally if it is not your passion. Don't waste your time. You'll just confuse yourself and miss out on what you should really be doing.
The first adult moment I can really think of is WE Fest. My high school friends started going to this in college. I remember looking at photos and thinking there's no way I'd survive there as an Asian. And at that point I was listening to country music because my roommate was obsessed with the GAC channel - Great American Country. But I knew, deep down, that it was not for me. It took me a lot longer to actually say this aloud to anyone (and then I received a lot of miffed responses).
I'm pretty sure my first real "not for me" moment came to me really late in life. I drank the Kool-Aid your teachers give you when they tell you you can be or do anything you want if you try hard enough. I knew I could never be president of the United States because I wasn't born here, but that's because someone told me when I was 8. I'm pretty sure it was my parents when I was sitting at a picnic table in a San Diego campground telling them all the things I wanted to be (astronaut, veterinarian, Clara Barton, etc.). But I could be imagining that.
White people have a hard time accepting "not for me" realizations. They think anything is possible, and that it will feel good if you want it enough when you get it. This explains a lot of skinny white boys in do-rags and baggy pants. This is also why my college roommates were offended when I told them that I really didn't think country music was for Asians.
"You could be the first Asian country music star," they encouraged. Yes, and I could also get eyelid fold surgery. Technically possible, but essentially useless. I'd be denying something true about myself if I did it. Even if the country music audience accepted me, I'd still feel weird.
My point was that country music actually is not for Asians. Neither the melodies nor the messages (nor the images) resonate with Asian culture. Whether or not you think that is ok, that is the truth. If you are Asian and you want to be the first Asian country music star, go for it, but it's weird when white people tell you it's worth trying, if only for the anomaly factor. "The first."
Since then I've accumulated a long list of "not for me" items and experiences, and while you might see that as a limiting feature, I don't. I've just made choices to be me, many of which I should have made earlier in life when I wasn't paying attention to the fact that I am a 5'10 Asian female with white parents.
Travel alone (male)? Not for me. Too dangerous.
Dreadlocks (black)? Not for me.
Breast implants (rich, shallow)? Not for me.
Live in Idaho? Not for me.
White girl hair (white, female)? Sometimes.
Theology degree (Christian, academic)? Too late.
September wedding at age 23 (pick one)? Too late.
Hippie? Too late. I didn't know that only white people can be real hippies. Asian hippies are just called failures.
You probably have your own list.
I see former classmates running off to Holden Village to find peace and Jesus, and they have their own progressive peaceful Jesus language they use when they talk to each other. They all like nature a lot too and wear bandanas on their heads when they hike in their North Face fleeces. Many of them ski. I'd say all of them are Lutheran. I used to think I was Lutheran, but then I discovered that I was not. Being Lutheran is nice, but it is not for me. So it is partially entertaining, and partially just plain weird to see people I used to know living in my former life stages and belonging there when I didn't.
Obviously, if you don't know what IS for you, you have to try a few things out. And you might be surprised. But you should have some idea of what is and is not for you, unlike me. It took me a loooooong time to accept this.
There is nothing wrong with not taking, "You can do anything!" literally if it is not your passion. Don't waste your time. You'll just confuse yourself and miss out on what you should really be doing.
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
ex-DB
I never thought this would be a question I'd end up asking myself, but would you rather hate your ex-romantic interest because of something they've done to you, or because you find out they're actually a bad person? Which is worse?
I don't actually hate ex-DB, but I'm anguished and sad that he didn't end up being the person I wanted him to be. And it's not because of anything he's done to me in anger, but rather because he has shown himself to be objectively corrupt. I understand that I am more concerned than most other people with the content of his character, but when he is a trustee of our shared frisbee team's best interests and commits a sickening breach of faith (and then paints me as stirring up drama), it affects everyone. It is public knowledge.
I've mostly kept our interpersonal issues off my blog because some of you know him. It's just easier for you if you can keep on calmly liking him until you forget about him. It takes a lot of energy to love and hate, and it's not anything I'd force you to go through on my behalf. Also, it's just been easier for me to mentally rationalize having been in a relationship with him for 7 years if I can treat him like he was worth it. Like he was friend material, at the very least.
Something that I just could never handle, in all the time I knew him, was his inability to face himself. He could not admit wrongdoing, and he'd take all steps to evade capture. He used omissions and partial truths. Capture, meaning me asking him point blank what was up. I couldn't handle it. I internalized a lot of our issues, thinking that I was somehow flawed because I wasn't happy, and repeating to myself that I was lucky to have a responsible, handsome, friendly, and employed husband. And I was lucky to have those things. But there are just some things I cannot live with (where others could), and the inability to face yourself is one of them. I like getting chocolates, but I don't need them. What I do need, always, is someone who can look me in the eye and say exactly what happened, even if it means admitting wrongdoing. Especially unsolicited admissions of wrongdoing. I need someone who will look out for not just my best interests, but who will demonstrate the strength of character necessary to care for the interests of anyone depending on him.
In some circles, people who do this are called "adults."
But I didn't know it. I didn't know that there were adults out there. Later, after ex-DB and I were separated and was visiting a therapist (Hal2000), Hal2000 commented that I seemed to treat ex-DB like he was my child. I was stunned, but then agreed. Looking back I realize that it was because I had to chase him around his evasive answers in order to protect myself, because I couldn't depend on him to protect me from himself. (Try to build a relationship of trust around that, and then try to feel good about it.)
I'd gotten used to it and I expected it. I just never thought he'd do it to an entire group of friends and teammates.
Ultimate frisbee (now called "Ultimate" because of patent issues) may seem like a casual recreational activity (see: kickball) to those who aren't involved. What do we do, just play fetch with ourselves? It might look like that. We don't have referees. We wear costumes sometimes. But we take ourselves seriously, and we have our share of fanatics and lifers. At any rate, Ultimate culture is a very specific, defined, and committed thing, as is evidenced by the fact that I have played on the same team for seven years. The only other thing I've done the same for seven years was be married, and my Ultimate team outlasted that. My teammates are former classmates from undergrad and new friends we've picked up along the way. We've seen three internal marriages, one internal divorce, three children, and multiple other marriages and breakups together. We're as close as it gets to being a TeamFamily.
Ultimate is also divided into two realms - competitive and recreational. "Recreational" is a misnomer in the Twin Cities, because it implies a light emotional commitment and a lot of beer. There is a lot of beer, but it happens after the games. People break themselves. They get surgery, they still attend games to cheer, and then they come back and play. Competitive Ultimate is called "club," and means that teams travel to various tournaments all around the country for glory, honor, and good times. My team is recreational and doesn't travel - we play in the one and only Twin Cities league (which houses 48 full teams, last time I checked).
I invited ex-DB to join my team back in 2006, and since then he has become a captain. Our team runs pretty democratically, however, and we consider ourselves group-owned. New players are invited based on personal relationships with current players and when our roster is limited, playing time is generally decided by who gets their money to the captain first. Right now we have two official captains and one informal prior captain who just doesn't want to handle logistics anymore.
We usually play fall league and winter league together. Because the league has to purchase fieldhouse time, the winter season is limited to 16 teams. Each year, the returning teams are given the option of re-signing up before the league opens to new teams. Obviously, new teams don't get to register very frequently because everyone wants to sign up again. The local Ultimate community is very close-knit, so people often move from team to team based on who needs players in a given year. Our team doesn't though. We've always stuck together, and we've always signed up.
This year, though, after the fall season ended we got an email from ex-DB saying that our bid for winter league failed and that while it was a "disappointment for all of us," we could use the time to heal, practice, and get ready for next fall. We figured that he'd done his best.
Last week I found out that he IS playing winter league. He is actually captaining a team, and it consists of people who play for his competitive club team.
I emailed him: "Did you try bidding for [our team] or did you decide you couldn't since you wouldn't be playing on it? I don't like that you made it sound like you wouldn't be playing winter league either. I hope it's the first, because if you didn't bid for us someone else could have."
I got an email back right away: "No other teams were allowed in this year. There wasn't even one open spot."
Pause for assessment.
This curt answer was uncharacteristic of him, except for when he's hiding something. Technically the words were true but I could tell he was being slippery. I asked: "Other teams?
No response.
The next day, I emailed the league administrator to see if anyone had tried to bid for us: "I have a question about the winter league registration process. Do returning teams get an automatic slot or seniority? Did anyone place a bid for [our team]?"
He replied: "[Your team] re-signed up and renamed themselves [other team]. All teams from last year get an automatic bid if they want it. All teams returned this year."
In other words, ex-DB took our reserved spot and gave it to his other team. But he tried to hide it.
This was confirmed by a few phone calls, where I found out that he'd been plotting this since October. He had so many opportunities to tell us the truth - any point during fall league games, at the team Christmas party when someone asked him point-blank, in November when a fellow teammate emailed him, and when I emailed him last week. Technically "no other teams were allowed in this year," as he said, but he evaded the real issue in his answer. He knew what I was asking.
I sent out an email to our team explaining what had happened, and seeking an apology from him and our other captains. If he'd just responded to me honestly (or at all... I waited until the next day), I would have told him that what he did was wrong and I would have let him tell the entire team. But he did nothing.
In response to my email, he sent out a brief message saying that he was sorry if anyone was confused and that he loved all of us dearly. But that was it. No apology.
Four days later, still no apology. In fact, he is spinning the events to appear that he had every right to "evolve" our team into a better one for winter league, and that such changes were the result of natural turnover among Ultimate teams. He hasn't addressed this to our team, however, because he knows we'd call bullshit on him. We had no say in this "natural turnover." We've never done things this way, and we've never changed our name for winter league. The team that is playing right now is not us although he maintains that it is because the roster includes some members who play for both. He lied, and now he is lying about lying. The new name he gave this "evolved" version of our team? After a Google search, we realized it's a character from the same video game as the name of his club team. How conceited do you have to be to so openly "hide" your intent?
A few individuals who play for both our recreational team and his club team emailed me to say that they are not playing winter league because they felt that it was wrong, but their names were left on the roster to make it appear that our recreational team was still there. Other, differently-minded individuals have unfriended me on FB. Undoubtedly they've been swayed by ex-DB's charisma and ability to paint himself as the victim, which I've too easily let him do. In our marriage I assumed my unhappiness was my fault. In retrospect, it was really the result of our conflict between different ways to live.
While I am upset about not getting to play this winter, I am mainly horrified by the lies. And by his selfish behavior in the first place.
I honestly never thought he could screw over an entire team full of people he's known for years and then easily brush off our hurt. I knew he was capable of doing the same type of thing to me on a smaller level, but this is an objectively corrupt thing to do.
Because it's Minnesota, and because we're all worried about staying together, I doubt anything major will come of it. I think it will be business as usual next fall, and he'll still be captain. But I hope that my email will let him know that now we're all aware of what he's capable of, and maybe he'll watch his step. Or maybe not. He's pretty full of himself, and he's afraid to consider the idea that he might not be worth the size of his ego. So he's probably succeeded in convincing himself that his selfishness was actually legitimate decision-making on behalf of our team.
I was livid all of Friday. Just shaking with rage. Then I came down with major headaches over the weekend. And now I am sad. Sad, and confused by what a poor judge of character I am. I never knew, until I began dating someone else, what it was like to have your partner truly take care of you. Not with grand gestures but through real consideration of your best interests. And not just in emergencies but on an ongoing basis, and for everyone else in his life. Real selflessness, and without thanks or recognition. I'd give you examples but I'd sound ridiculous. Also, those are not my stories to tell.
It's embarrassing to take your partner out in public, introduce him to people you admire, and be associated with him when you don't respect him on a very basic level. When ex-DB and I were together I always felt like I was teaching him things, and I was, but maybe they were things he wasn't supposed to learn. He is happiest when he is blindly following his happy-go-lucky desires, most of which are not compatible with my lifestyle.
Ex-DB never understood what I needed. Even when it came to gifts, he didn't get it. I wanted him to be someone with a spine. Instead, I got A) a dead/dried flower, B) a replica of a pope necklace from the Vatican, and C) a new cat 1 month after Bjorn died. I learned how to appreciate the intent behind the gifts, but I knew he didn't really see me. He supported me when it suited him and I know it wasn't all fun and games, and I'm grateful for the things he did right. But. I could never predict when I could rely on him, when it didn't benefit him as well.
I give him credit for trying to see me, and he did try, but he just could not be the person I thought was in there. He never learned how to look at the world without the naive lens of his privilege and entitlement clouding his judgment. He couldn't see what I saw, and thus couldn't understand what I wanted - whether it was more than a token gift or something within himself. I tried to teach him, but eventually realized I didn't want to. Too heartbreaking and futile.
So now I have been slammed in the face with the blatant realization that not only are we as different as I suspected, but that but that the person I was married to (for god's sake) is capable of calculated deviousness and betrayal. He definitely went downhill fast since he had me dragging my heels behind him. I'm not perfect, but I'm also not stupid, and this is even more reckless than the time he sank thousands of dollars into a Central American "mine" without asking me. He threw away so many relationships when he lied. Years and years. He probably assumes they'll forgive him because he is so charismatic. And they might. But he doesn't care.
It's all symptomatic of his selfishness and paranoia - he can't see himself clearly, and so he can't get better.
For those of you who were wondering how long we could last playing on the same team - we were doing just fine on the field. The arguments we used to have when I tried to reign in his unprofessional attitude no longer occurred after our divorce because I no longer felt burdened by my association with him. We could have shared joint custody of the team indefinitely. This time ex-DB's betrayal was not within our relationship, and was not specifically targeted at me. It was cold, calculated, and affected everyone.
Suffice it to say, on both counts,
Peace out, homies.
I don't actually hate ex-DB, but I'm anguished and sad that he didn't end up being the person I wanted him to be. And it's not because of anything he's done to me in anger, but rather because he has shown himself to be objectively corrupt. I understand that I am more concerned than most other people with the content of his character, but when he is a trustee of our shared frisbee team's best interests and commits a sickening breach of faith (and then paints me as stirring up drama), it affects everyone. It is public knowledge.
I've mostly kept our interpersonal issues off my blog because some of you know him. It's just easier for you if you can keep on calmly liking him until you forget about him. It takes a lot of energy to love and hate, and it's not anything I'd force you to go through on my behalf. Also, it's just been easier for me to mentally rationalize having been in a relationship with him for 7 years if I can treat him like he was worth it. Like he was friend material, at the very least.
Something that I just could never handle, in all the time I knew him, was his inability to face himself. He could not admit wrongdoing, and he'd take all steps to evade capture. He used omissions and partial truths. Capture, meaning me asking him point blank what was up. I couldn't handle it. I internalized a lot of our issues, thinking that I was somehow flawed because I wasn't happy, and repeating to myself that I was lucky to have a responsible, handsome, friendly, and employed husband. And I was lucky to have those things. But there are just some things I cannot live with (where others could), and the inability to face yourself is one of them. I like getting chocolates, but I don't need them. What I do need, always, is someone who can look me in the eye and say exactly what happened, even if it means admitting wrongdoing. Especially unsolicited admissions of wrongdoing. I need someone who will look out for not just my best interests, but who will demonstrate the strength of character necessary to care for the interests of anyone depending on him.
In some circles, people who do this are called "adults."
But I didn't know it. I didn't know that there were adults out there. Later, after ex-DB and I were separated and was visiting a therapist (Hal2000), Hal2000 commented that I seemed to treat ex-DB like he was my child. I was stunned, but then agreed. Looking back I realize that it was because I had to chase him around his evasive answers in order to protect myself, because I couldn't depend on him to protect me from himself. (Try to build a relationship of trust around that, and then try to feel good about it.)
I'd gotten used to it and I expected it. I just never thought he'd do it to an entire group of friends and teammates.
Ultimate frisbee (now called "Ultimate" because of patent issues) may seem like a casual recreational activity (see: kickball) to those who aren't involved. What do we do, just play fetch with ourselves? It might look like that. We don't have referees. We wear costumes sometimes. But we take ourselves seriously, and we have our share of fanatics and lifers. At any rate, Ultimate culture is a very specific, defined, and committed thing, as is evidenced by the fact that I have played on the same team for seven years. The only other thing I've done the same for seven years was be married, and my Ultimate team outlasted that. My teammates are former classmates from undergrad and new friends we've picked up along the way. We've seen three internal marriages, one internal divorce, three children, and multiple other marriages and breakups together. We're as close as it gets to being a TeamFamily.
Ultimate is also divided into two realms - competitive and recreational. "Recreational" is a misnomer in the Twin Cities, because it implies a light emotional commitment and a lot of beer. There is a lot of beer, but it happens after the games. People break themselves. They get surgery, they still attend games to cheer, and then they come back and play. Competitive Ultimate is called "club," and means that teams travel to various tournaments all around the country for glory, honor, and good times. My team is recreational and doesn't travel - we play in the one and only Twin Cities league (which houses 48 full teams, last time I checked).
I invited ex-DB to join my team back in 2006, and since then he has become a captain. Our team runs pretty democratically, however, and we consider ourselves group-owned. New players are invited based on personal relationships with current players and when our roster is limited, playing time is generally decided by who gets their money to the captain first. Right now we have two official captains and one informal prior captain who just doesn't want to handle logistics anymore.
We usually play fall league and winter league together. Because the league has to purchase fieldhouse time, the winter season is limited to 16 teams. Each year, the returning teams are given the option of re-signing up before the league opens to new teams. Obviously, new teams don't get to register very frequently because everyone wants to sign up again. The local Ultimate community is very close-knit, so people often move from team to team based on who needs players in a given year. Our team doesn't though. We've always stuck together, and we've always signed up.
This year, though, after the fall season ended we got an email from ex-DB saying that our bid for winter league failed and that while it was a "disappointment for all of us," we could use the time to heal, practice, and get ready for next fall. We figured that he'd done his best.
Last week I found out that he IS playing winter league. He is actually captaining a team, and it consists of people who play for his competitive club team.
I emailed him: "Did you try bidding for [our team] or did you decide you couldn't since you wouldn't be playing on it? I don't like that you made it sound like you wouldn't be playing winter league either. I hope it's the first, because if you didn't bid for us someone else could have."
I got an email back right away: "No other teams were allowed in this year. There wasn't even one open spot."
Pause for assessment.
This curt answer was uncharacteristic of him, except for when he's hiding something. Technically the words were true but I could tell he was being slippery. I asked: "Other teams?
No response.
The next day, I emailed the league administrator to see if anyone had tried to bid for us: "I have a question about the winter league registration process. Do returning teams get an automatic slot or seniority? Did anyone place a bid for [our team]?"
He replied: "[Your team] re-signed up and renamed themselves [other team]. All teams from last year get an automatic bid if they want it. All teams returned this year."
In other words, ex-DB took our reserved spot and gave it to his other team. But he tried to hide it.
This was confirmed by a few phone calls, where I found out that he'd been plotting this since October. He had so many opportunities to tell us the truth - any point during fall league games, at the team Christmas party when someone asked him point-blank, in November when a fellow teammate emailed him, and when I emailed him last week. Technically "no other teams were allowed in this year," as he said, but he evaded the real issue in his answer. He knew what I was asking.
I sent out an email to our team explaining what had happened, and seeking an apology from him and our other captains. If he'd just responded to me honestly (or at all... I waited until the next day), I would have told him that what he did was wrong and I would have let him tell the entire team. But he did nothing.
In response to my email, he sent out a brief message saying that he was sorry if anyone was confused and that he loved all of us dearly. But that was it. No apology.
Four days later, still no apology. In fact, he is spinning the events to appear that he had every right to "evolve" our team into a better one for winter league, and that such changes were the result of natural turnover among Ultimate teams. He hasn't addressed this to our team, however, because he knows we'd call bullshit on him. We had no say in this "natural turnover." We've never done things this way, and we've never changed our name for winter league. The team that is playing right now is not us although he maintains that it is because the roster includes some members who play for both. He lied, and now he is lying about lying. The new name he gave this "evolved" version of our team? After a Google search, we realized it's a character from the same video game as the name of his club team. How conceited do you have to be to so openly "hide" your intent?
A few individuals who play for both our recreational team and his club team emailed me to say that they are not playing winter league because they felt that it was wrong, but their names were left on the roster to make it appear that our recreational team was still there. Other, differently-minded individuals have unfriended me on FB. Undoubtedly they've been swayed by ex-DB's charisma and ability to paint himself as the victim, which I've too easily let him do. In our marriage I assumed my unhappiness was my fault. In retrospect, it was really the result of our conflict between different ways to live.
While I am upset about not getting to play this winter, I am mainly horrified by the lies. And by his selfish behavior in the first place.
I honestly never thought he could screw over an entire team full of people he's known for years and then easily brush off our hurt. I knew he was capable of doing the same type of thing to me on a smaller level, but this is an objectively corrupt thing to do.
Because it's Minnesota, and because we're all worried about staying together, I doubt anything major will come of it. I think it will be business as usual next fall, and he'll still be captain. But I hope that my email will let him know that now we're all aware of what he's capable of, and maybe he'll watch his step. Or maybe not. He's pretty full of himself, and he's afraid to consider the idea that he might not be worth the size of his ego. So he's probably succeeded in convincing himself that his selfishness was actually legitimate decision-making on behalf of our team.
I was livid all of Friday. Just shaking with rage. Then I came down with major headaches over the weekend. And now I am sad. Sad, and confused by what a poor judge of character I am. I never knew, until I began dating someone else, what it was like to have your partner truly take care of you. Not with grand gestures but through real consideration of your best interests. And not just in emergencies but on an ongoing basis, and for everyone else in his life. Real selflessness, and without thanks or recognition. I'd give you examples but I'd sound ridiculous. Also, those are not my stories to tell.
It's embarrassing to take your partner out in public, introduce him to people you admire, and be associated with him when you don't respect him on a very basic level. When ex-DB and I were together I always felt like I was teaching him things, and I was, but maybe they were things he wasn't supposed to learn. He is happiest when he is blindly following his happy-go-lucky desires, most of which are not compatible with my lifestyle.
Ex-DB never understood what I needed. Even when it came to gifts, he didn't get it. I wanted him to be someone with a spine. Instead, I got A) a dead/dried flower, B) a replica of a pope necklace from the Vatican, and C) a new cat 1 month after Bjorn died. I learned how to appreciate the intent behind the gifts, but I knew he didn't really see me. He supported me when it suited him and I know it wasn't all fun and games, and I'm grateful for the things he did right. But. I could never predict when I could rely on him, when it didn't benefit him as well.
I give him credit for trying to see me, and he did try, but he just could not be the person I thought was in there. He never learned how to look at the world without the naive lens of his privilege and entitlement clouding his judgment. He couldn't see what I saw, and thus couldn't understand what I wanted - whether it was more than a token gift or something within himself. I tried to teach him, but eventually realized I didn't want to. Too heartbreaking and futile.
So now I have been slammed in the face with the blatant realization that not only are we as different as I suspected, but that but that the person I was married to (for god's sake) is capable of calculated deviousness and betrayal. He definitely went downhill fast since he had me dragging my heels behind him. I'm not perfect, but I'm also not stupid, and this is even more reckless than the time he sank thousands of dollars into a Central American "mine" without asking me. He threw away so many relationships when he lied. Years and years. He probably assumes they'll forgive him because he is so charismatic. And they might. But he doesn't care.
It's all symptomatic of his selfishness and paranoia - he can't see himself clearly, and so he can't get better.
For those of you who were wondering how long we could last playing on the same team - we were doing just fine on the field. The arguments we used to have when I tried to reign in his unprofessional attitude no longer occurred after our divorce because I no longer felt burdened by my association with him. We could have shared joint custody of the team indefinitely. This time ex-DB's betrayal was not within our relationship, and was not specifically targeted at me. It was cold, calculated, and affected everyone.
Suffice it to say, on both counts,
Peace out, homies.
Monday, January 23, 2012
happy new year!
It's the lunar new year. Dragon year. Time to eat rice cake soup - ddukgeok.
I was invited to march in a festival parade next weekend in some suburb. If I wore "my outfit." Obviously, the organizers are not Asian.
This weekend I helped out at a friend's fundraiser for her dance and drum studio. Normally I avoid events with a large crowd of adoptive parents, but I was going to be in the kitchen for most of it and I thought I should support my friend. Also, I really do like watching traditional Korean arts.
I spent the morning chopping and stirring things in an industrial kitchen with other adult adoptee women and some Korean American ajummas who were running the show. I like hanging out with American ajummas - they're no-nonsense earthy women who will tell you exactly what they think, and they know they're right. In Korea they're scary because if they've never talked to an adoptee before it can be shocking and appalling for them (and terrible for you), but in the U.S. at this type of event they know exactly what they're getting into.
There's one who was adopted to the U.S. at age 14 and is now a grandma. She retained all her Korean language and cooking skills but has a full command of English, so watch out. I was eating my bibimbahp with a fork (the only utensil I could find) and as she ran by she yelled, "Spoon!" at me, because she thinks it's her business to make sure I live the right way among Korean things. For that moment, anyway.
I surfaced to say hello to MumDear and DadCat, who had come to have lunch and see the show, but I mainly steered clear of the adoptive parents weaving in and out of the tables and looking at the craft sales. It's just too much to handle. Inevitably, one of them will say something inappropriate and I'll recoil in horror, and then go home and mull about it. The Korean adoption community (parents, kids, agencies) just does not learn from its past. Parents of adults do not pass on their wisdom to new adoptive parents, and it's like re-creating the wheel every time you meet one.
This is a community of people who are so happy to know each other that they run full throttle into each others' arms until their collective situation is normalized, and everyone feels ownership. Over each other. Over the "kids," who are often not kids anymore but 28-year-old attorneys.
This summer an adoptive parent reprimanded a male camp counselor for not "letting the ladies go first," meaning my female co-counselor and I, when all of us approached her soup station. We just looked at her in horror, too shocked to say anything, and then meekly took our soup and left. It's hard to get rid of the parent-child dynamic that's so blatantly obvious because of our varying skin tones, even when it's wrong. She didn't know enough to realize that that power dynamic was unjust, because past adoptive parents didn't explain to her that we don't stay children forever. And she didn't know that because of the way the world works - things she cannot change - she can't establish the immediate rapport that old Korean women can with younger Korean women. It's a very different kitchen. If she said that to us and we were white, we wouldn't walk away feeling the invalidity of our adulthood. We would just think that she was bossy, like the ajummas. But she doesn't realize that she's an adult white woman with Korean children, and that we used to be Korean children with adult white woman mothers, but that we are now real adults. She has convinced herself that none of that exists. (Probably because adult Asians are intimidating, and she doesn't know any, so the only way to interact with us is to remember that we have "child-adoptee" as part of our identity.)
This mindless ownership of the community, of the situation, and of each other's life experiences leads to other offensive interactions between adoptive parents and adult adoptees. It has become normal to inquire into others' origin stories, as if the information somehow belongs in the public forum like discussions of high school football and good recipes.
"Have you found your birth family? Have you tried searching for them?"
It's like asking someone, "Why did you adopt? Was it because you couldn't have children?"
Totally inappropriate. It is totally inappropriate to inquire into someone's very personal life story when you haven't exchanged more than 50 words with them. But for some reason very few people realize that adoption is still personal. Just because you have adopted children (or know some) does not mean that it is your privilege to feel like we are "in this together." You are in it with your family. I am in it with mine. That is very different. But again, parents of adults haven't passed this on, and often it's because adoptees get swept up in this collective ownership culture too and don't stop to tell their parents - don't discuss my story with the ladies at Herbergers.
Also, we live in Minnesota and no one wants to say, "That's personal and none of your business."
So it's tricky to go to an event like this fundraiser. It's tricky to participate. The parents are also participating whether they're aware of it or not, as a crowd of white people watching their Korean children who, after shedding their jeans and sweaters to put on traditional costumes for a few hours, dance and drum on a stage. They clap, they're happy for their kids, and they are very supportive, but they don't question the oddness of such a situation. They don't consider that perhaps, such an oddness might require more intention and care in passing on the experience and knowledge from one generation of parents to the next.
The adoption agencies don't care to learn, since it would upset their cash flow and mojo.
I was invited to march in a festival parade next weekend in some suburb. If I wore "my outfit." Obviously, the organizers are not Asian.
This weekend I helped out at a friend's fundraiser for her dance and drum studio. Normally I avoid events with a large crowd of adoptive parents, but I was going to be in the kitchen for most of it and I thought I should support my friend. Also, I really do like watching traditional Korean arts.
I spent the morning chopping and stirring things in an industrial kitchen with other adult adoptee women and some Korean American ajummas who were running the show. I like hanging out with American ajummas - they're no-nonsense earthy women who will tell you exactly what they think, and they know they're right. In Korea they're scary because if they've never talked to an adoptee before it can be shocking and appalling for them (and terrible for you), but in the U.S. at this type of event they know exactly what they're getting into.
There's one who was adopted to the U.S. at age 14 and is now a grandma. She retained all her Korean language and cooking skills but has a full command of English, so watch out. I was eating my bibimbahp with a fork (the only utensil I could find) and as she ran by she yelled, "Spoon!" at me, because she thinks it's her business to make sure I live the right way among Korean things. For that moment, anyway.
I surfaced to say hello to MumDear and DadCat, who had come to have lunch and see the show, but I mainly steered clear of the adoptive parents weaving in and out of the tables and looking at the craft sales. It's just too much to handle. Inevitably, one of them will say something inappropriate and I'll recoil in horror, and then go home and mull about it. The Korean adoption community (parents, kids, agencies) just does not learn from its past. Parents of adults do not pass on their wisdom to new adoptive parents, and it's like re-creating the wheel every time you meet one.
This is a community of people who are so happy to know each other that they run full throttle into each others' arms until their collective situation is normalized, and everyone feels ownership. Over each other. Over the "kids," who are often not kids anymore but 28-year-old attorneys.
This summer an adoptive parent reprimanded a male camp counselor for not "letting the ladies go first," meaning my female co-counselor and I, when all of us approached her soup station. We just looked at her in horror, too shocked to say anything, and then meekly took our soup and left. It's hard to get rid of the parent-child dynamic that's so blatantly obvious because of our varying skin tones, even when it's wrong. She didn't know enough to realize that that power dynamic was unjust, because past adoptive parents didn't explain to her that we don't stay children forever. And she didn't know that because of the way the world works - things she cannot change - she can't establish the immediate rapport that old Korean women can with younger Korean women. It's a very different kitchen. If she said that to us and we were white, we wouldn't walk away feeling the invalidity of our adulthood. We would just think that she was bossy, like the ajummas. But she doesn't realize that she's an adult white woman with Korean children, and that we used to be Korean children with adult white woman mothers, but that we are now real adults. She has convinced herself that none of that exists. (Probably because adult Asians are intimidating, and she doesn't know any, so the only way to interact with us is to remember that we have "child-adoptee" as part of our identity.)
This mindless ownership of the community, of the situation, and of each other's life experiences leads to other offensive interactions between adoptive parents and adult adoptees. It has become normal to inquire into others' origin stories, as if the information somehow belongs in the public forum like discussions of high school football and good recipes.
"Have you found your birth family? Have you tried searching for them?"
It's like asking someone, "Why did you adopt? Was it because you couldn't have children?"
Totally inappropriate. It is totally inappropriate to inquire into someone's very personal life story when you haven't exchanged more than 50 words with them. But for some reason very few people realize that adoption is still personal. Just because you have adopted children (or know some) does not mean that it is your privilege to feel like we are "in this together." You are in it with your family. I am in it with mine. That is very different. But again, parents of adults haven't passed this on, and often it's because adoptees get swept up in this collective ownership culture too and don't stop to tell their parents - don't discuss my story with the ladies at Herbergers.
Also, we live in Minnesota and no one wants to say, "That's personal and none of your business."
So it's tricky to go to an event like this fundraiser. It's tricky to participate. The parents are also participating whether they're aware of it or not, as a crowd of white people watching their Korean children who, after shedding their jeans and sweaters to put on traditional costumes for a few hours, dance and drum on a stage. They clap, they're happy for their kids, and they are very supportive, but they don't question the oddness of such a situation. They don't consider that perhaps, such an oddness might require more intention and care in passing on the experience and knowledge from one generation of parents to the next.
The adoption agencies don't care to learn, since it would upset their cash flow and mojo.
Sunday, January 22, 2012
the disappearing cat trick
Part of my brain shuts down when I'm stressed out. Maybe it's the result of emotional trauma. I go on auto-pilot and don't retain any information gained during stressful moments. I think this is common among adoptees. I see it when I play sports, when I try to learn Korean, and when people tell me things in interviews. I have one next Thursday.
Pretty much I've learned how to compensate for the fact that I actually disappear inside myself. I make a list of things about myself, things I want my interviewers to know about me when I walk away, and then I memorize them. Except for the very rare question, anything can usually be answered with a prepared schpiel. People have told me I'm a very good interviewer because I'm friendly and articulate ideas well. But honestly, I'm not even there. I've just prepped my robot so well that it knows what to do when prompted.
This also explains why I can never retain any information that's in my adoption file.
Pretty much I've learned how to compensate for the fact that I actually disappear inside myself. I make a list of things about myself, things I want my interviewers to know about me when I walk away, and then I memorize them. Except for the very rare question, anything can usually be answered with a prepared schpiel. People have told me I'm a very good interviewer because I'm friendly and articulate ideas well. But honestly, I'm not even there. I've just prepped my robot so well that it knows what to do when prompted.
This also explains why I can never retain any information that's in my adoption file.
Thursday, January 19, 2012
selfish seeds
I hate targeted advertising.
For starters, it creeps me out. When Facebook advertises "clothes for Korean girls!" in my sidebar it makes me wonder just how much info the interwebs have caught about me, and who is reading it. It also makes me wonder if Korean girls have an extra arm that makes clothes shopping difficult and grounds for targeted advertising.
But most importantly, I think targeted advertising kills the potential for sharing a common culture and spreading tolerance in our American society. While I don't really care to see commercials for Depends adult diapers or the next Ke$ha concert, having to sit through them if I want to see my show tunes me in to others' wants and needs. I might be more sympathetic to old people's frequent need to make restroom stops. I might have a better chance of understanding what's going through my teenage campers' minds when they start wearing holey glitter tights and raccoon eyes.
Already though, most of the time I only have to think about me because everything I see is specifically aimed at my desires, or what others want me to desire.
Mid-twentieth century, everyone had to listen to the same radio station if they wanted modern music. Everyone had the same TV shows. It created a common experience, and while that media silenced certain voices [usually communities of color], everyone knew what everyone else knew. Now while I feel like I have a good grasp on what everyone thinks, it's very possible that I don't have any idea what's going on out there. Old friends' Facebook statuses are key clues to that situation. When I see things like, "Let us be saints together! Pray for us Mother Mary!" in my mini-feed, I know that my friendship with the writer is probably unique among friendships, and they've most likely forgotten that I can see their status. A majority of their friends are in the Catholic club and think a Facebook status like that is normal, if the responses can be believed.
In a previous post I wrote about making a personal effort to tune in to the conflicting voices at the periphery of my life so that I wouldn't lose touch with everyone else. I think targeted advertising is that battle on a wider, more organized scale.
For starters, it creeps me out. When Facebook advertises "clothes for Korean girls!" in my sidebar it makes me wonder just how much info the interwebs have caught about me, and who is reading it. It also makes me wonder if Korean girls have an extra arm that makes clothes shopping difficult and grounds for targeted advertising.
But most importantly, I think targeted advertising kills the potential for sharing a common culture and spreading tolerance in our American society. While I don't really care to see commercials for Depends adult diapers or the next Ke$ha concert, having to sit through them if I want to see my show tunes me in to others' wants and needs. I might be more sympathetic to old people's frequent need to make restroom stops. I might have a better chance of understanding what's going through my teenage campers' minds when they start wearing holey glitter tights and raccoon eyes.
Already though, most of the time I only have to think about me because everything I see is specifically aimed at my desires, or what others want me to desire.
Mid-twentieth century, everyone had to listen to the same radio station if they wanted modern music. Everyone had the same TV shows. It created a common experience, and while that media silenced certain voices [usually communities of color], everyone knew what everyone else knew. Now while I feel like I have a good grasp on what everyone thinks, it's very possible that I don't have any idea what's going on out there. Old friends' Facebook statuses are key clues to that situation. When I see things like, "Let us be saints together! Pray for us Mother Mary!" in my mini-feed, I know that my friendship with the writer is probably unique among friendships, and they've most likely forgotten that I can see their status. A majority of their friends are in the Catholic club and think a Facebook status like that is normal, if the responses can be believed.
In a previous post I wrote about making a personal effort to tune in to the conflicting voices at the periphery of my life so that I wouldn't lose touch with everyone else. I think targeted advertising is that battle on a wider, more organized scale.
Wednesday, January 18, 2012
global warming
What a great title for a blog post, huh? Makes you really want to read it.
97% of scientists agree that global warming is occurring. Studies have been peer-reviewed and peer-reviewed.
Global warming is real. It's science.
For some, "science" is a dirty word. In their religion, it means "anti-religion." But it shouldn't. Science is just the best agreed-upon process for arriving at conclusions to questions people have about the world around us.
Someone on MPR said this: If 97% of doctors said that you had cancer, you'd probably believe them and seek treatment.
Why, then is there even a debate? Why did someone in the lawsuit I'm working on refer to "the global warming hoax" in an email? (True story. This lawsuit makes me feel dirty.)
There is a debate (in the U.S.) because global warming is related to [U.S.] economic policy. The things that are frying our earth are the same things that are making certain people rich, and others slightly better off. So there is an incentive to make arguments to the contrary, to push against any limits to this economic "improvement." And the venue for pushing and pulling these economic policies is the government, which is made up of two political parties. And one political party has decided to make itself a vehicle for this agenda. Thus what should just be a bare bones fact has somehow become politicized. Why is there a debate? How have we even allowed this to be framed as a choice between equal versions of reality?
Policy should be formed around facts; facts should not be formed around pre-existing policy. The real fact is that the earth is dying. You can quibble about how quickly this is occurring, but it is still dying. And that knowledge should be the constant around which we form our policies. We will never escape the fact that we need the earth to live on and to sustain us. The whole circus around the "debate" is ridiculous. An almost bulletproof majority of scientists have agreed on a fact. Reality: we have to work with that fact. The sooner everyone is on board with reality, the better. I mean you, Mitt Romney.
97% of scientists agree that global warming is occurring. Studies have been peer-reviewed and peer-reviewed.
Global warming is real. It's science.
For some, "science" is a dirty word. In their religion, it means "anti-religion." But it shouldn't. Science is just the best agreed-upon process for arriving at conclusions to questions people have about the world around us.
Someone on MPR said this: If 97% of doctors said that you had cancer, you'd probably believe them and seek treatment.
Why, then is there even a debate? Why did someone in the lawsuit I'm working on refer to "the global warming hoax" in an email? (True story. This lawsuit makes me feel dirty.)
There is a debate (in the U.S.) because global warming is related to [U.S.] economic policy. The things that are frying our earth are the same things that are making certain people rich, and others slightly better off. So there is an incentive to make arguments to the contrary, to push against any limits to this economic "improvement." And the venue for pushing and pulling these economic policies is the government, which is made up of two political parties. And one political party has decided to make itself a vehicle for this agenda. Thus what should just be a bare bones fact has somehow become politicized. Why is there a debate? How have we even allowed this to be framed as a choice between equal versions of reality?
Policy should be formed around facts; facts should not be formed around pre-existing policy. The real fact is that the earth is dying. You can quibble about how quickly this is occurring, but it is still dying. And that knowledge should be the constant around which we form our policies. We will never escape the fact that we need the earth to live on and to sustain us. The whole circus around the "debate" is ridiculous. An almost bulletproof majority of scientists have agreed on a fact. Reality: we have to work with that fact. The sooner everyone is on board with reality, the better. I mean you, Mitt Romney.
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
my friend made this
You probably won't like it. But, it's true. Walk around with my face for awhile.
Monday, January 16, 2012
the pyramid scheme continues
I found out last week that the client whose case I'm working on is being billed $208,000 a year for my work. That breaks down to $100/hr, which in the context of legal fees is not that much, but considering that I'm sitting at a computer clicking a mouse all day is still a lot. Especially since I don't take home even a quarter of that. In fact, I take home far less than a quarter because it's logistically impossible to be hired for all 52 weeks out of the year.
The temp agency takes a cut, the review center takes a cut, and the law firm takes a cut. I think we could cut out all of these middlemen. The law firm could hire more attorneys directly (even if just for a short-term contract) and charge for the efforts in locating us, setting up payroll, etc. but not for our labor which they do not in any real sense of the word "supervise."
The temp agency takes a cut, the review center takes a cut, and the law firm takes a cut. I think we could cut out all of these middlemen. The law firm could hire more attorneys directly (even if just for a short-term contract) and charge for the efforts in locating us, setting up payroll, etc. but not for our labor which they do not in any real sense of the word "supervise."
Sunday, January 15, 2012
one is the loneliest number...
Meow: Wow. I need a new dentist.
EarthMadre: Or that one black guy... What's his name?
Meow: Denzel Washington? Which movie?
EarthMadre: Yes, Denzel. Thank goodness he went dental... would have made a terrible ObGYN.
It's a sad, sad world when we know there is only one black guy. It couldn't be Will Smith because society never casts him as black. He is just "Will Smith," like he is benign and race-less.
Hollywood, you can do better.
Thursday, January 12, 2012
welcome to maricopa county
Mr. BearCat is home in Arizona at the moment. He sent me this picture of his county sheriff's van driving through Phoenix:
I thought the writing was a joke. I mean, if someone's going to be obnoxious enough to paint a street sign on the back of a government van, I can't blame whoever writes "illegally" on it. They are in Arizona.
But it's not graffiti. The image is really designed to say "do not illegally enter." To enter, in immigration terms, means to physically set foot on U.S. soil.
The way it's painted on the van doors though, it looks like the sheriff is opposed to any unapproved van occupants.
Jerks. But at least someone's giving Minnesota a run for its money in the "crazy public officials" department. What a waste of resources.
I thought the writing was a joke. I mean, if someone's going to be obnoxious enough to paint a street sign on the back of a government van, I can't blame whoever writes "illegally" on it. They are in Arizona.
But it's not graffiti. The image is really designed to say "do not illegally enter." To enter, in immigration terms, means to physically set foot on U.S. soil.
The way it's painted on the van doors though, it looks like the sheriff is opposed to any unapproved van occupants.
Jerks. But at least someone's giving Minnesota a run for its money in the "crazy public officials" department. What a waste of resources.
Wednesday, January 11, 2012
politician-press rules
Should candidates' personal lives be available for the public to chew on? A few ground rules:
If you broadcast your personal life (see: Santorum's book involving bringing his dead baby home for an evening) in a public forum, then others are free to comment on it. If they do it rudely you can be angry at their tone, but you can't blame them for bringing it up. Caveat: It is bad form to sell out your living family members by telling their very personal stories for your own advantage, without their adult permission. While the press may then comment on this material, those with any decency at all should refrain.
If you bring up an issue (see: marriage) but not certain facts from your own life, if those facts become available through legal means (someone sees you snuggling with your also-married legislative staff member) then they are also up for public consumption. If they become available through illegal means, then it's debatable. It depends on what the facts are and which illegal means were used.
If you claim the moral high ground on pretty much everything, then you have brought the issue of "my character" to the table, and others are then free to bring forth evidence on your character. But if your character is not relevant to the discussion (see: debate on education funding) and you did not raise it as an argument, then it is bad form for others to raise it.
I've said this before, but I swear, all the normal Republicans must be tied up in a barn somewhere.
If you broadcast your personal life (see: Santorum's book involving bringing his dead baby home for an evening) in a public forum, then others are free to comment on it. If they do it rudely you can be angry at their tone, but you can't blame them for bringing it up. Caveat: It is bad form to sell out your living family members by telling their very personal stories for your own advantage, without their adult permission. While the press may then comment on this material, those with any decency at all should refrain.
If you bring up an issue (see: marriage) but not certain facts from your own life, if those facts become available through legal means (someone sees you snuggling with your also-married legislative staff member) then they are also up for public consumption. If they become available through illegal means, then it's debatable. It depends on what the facts are and which illegal means were used.
If you claim the moral high ground on pretty much everything, then you have brought the issue of "my character" to the table, and others are then free to bring forth evidence on your character. But if your character is not relevant to the discussion (see: debate on education funding) and you did not raise it as an argument, then it is bad form for others to raise it.
I've said this before, but I swear, all the normal Republicans must be tied up in a barn somewhere.
Tuesday, January 10, 2012
chusing
I'm having a personal-professional identity crisis. My interests lie in doing policy analysis and advocacy around Korean adoption issues, and I have built these professional skills working on issues in this area. The skills transfer to available paid positions, but the subject matter does not. In fact, the subject matter runs counter to all the paid positions out there in this area. It's hard to have an intelligent conversation about what it is that I do without inevitably offending someone's basic beliefs about how the world works.I interviewed for a position at a family law firm. "Oh, you're adopted!" they asked. "Would you be interested in doing adoptions?"
Hell no.
Further, to those unfamiliar with the realm of international adoption (and let's face it, that's almost everyone), my work with adoptee advocacy organizations could be construed as a conflict of interest with any clients I'm representing. Grounds for disbarment.
Would I want to be a legislative aide? Of course. But working for the government (especially the legislative branch) and lobbying the government (the legislative branch) at the same time is, again, a conflict of interest.
But this is what I care about. In fact, the only reason why I'd want to be a legislative aide (or a family law attorney) is so I can become more useful in the Korean adoptee advocacy world.
I've been asking myself for awhile whether it's a career or a hobby, and I haven't had to arrive at a firm answer because I have no career and everything then is by default a hobby - even developing career skills. But I'm beginning to see that I'll probably have to choose one or the other.
Monday, January 9, 2012
This video was supposedly created by supporters of Republican primary candidate Ron Paul and claims that fellow candidate Jon Huntsman is “un-American.” It obviously reeks of racist and nationalist sentiment. Not surprisingly, there was a lot of backlash and the Paul campaign disavowed it immediately.
There’s also discussion about whether Huntsman is actually responsible for creating it – his campaign was the first to link to the video even when there were under 10 views (so how did they even find it?), and there were a few other suspicious things.
Jon Huntsman’s public response to the video is also nauseating. He completely sells out his Chinese and Indian daughters and shares their origin stories like poverty porn, casting himself as their savior. I’m pretty sure they’re going to bitch him out when they get old enough to realize how he used them. Or at least I hope they do. The origin stories belong to the daughters, and only the daughters. They are not his to share. Now when people meet them they'll try to remember if they're talking to the one who was left in the market or the one who was left for dead.
Why couldn't he have just said, "Leave my family alone," and left it at that? Too convenient.
Once again, international adoption enters national campaign politics. See: Bridget McCain.
Everything about this situation is horrifying.
Sunday, January 8, 2012
Thursday, January 5, 2012
survival analysis for the suburban jungle
Welp. I'm going to a baby shower on Saturday. I've been dreading it ever since my college roommate announced she was pregnant, grabbed both my arms and said, "Will you come? Please? It would mean so much to me," and I nodded and said, "Yeah, sure."
I got the invitation in the mail and let it sit on my dresser until last week, when I realized I should probably see where she was registered so I could get her a baby gift. Target. Manageable.
At Target I printed out the registry list and then stood in the baby section staring into space. Too overwhelming. I didn't have enough stamina to see if I could hunt down matching crib sheets. A cursory glance only showed blue polka dots; no pink ones were in sight.
I got her a gift card. Not so much fun to open, but she'll like it later when she runs out of butt paste or breaks a bottle.
Next, I figured out how I would get there. She lives 45 minutes away from me so a car pool would be preferable, but my options were pretty slim. After ruling out:
1. Ex-roommate who recently gave birth and who hates me for getting divorced
2. Second ex-roommate who recently gave birth and who hates me for getting divorced
3. Third ex-roommate who is pregnant with the child of a man who can only be described as neurotic, at best
4. Fourth ex-roommate with demon child (who lives too far away anyway)
5. Fifth ex-roommate who lives too far away
6. Acquaintance who I don't know well enough to spend 45 minutes in the car with (and who recently gave birth)
7. Shower hostess who consistently snubbed me when we lived on the same dorm floor as sophomores, and who I suspect is pregnant
8. One of DB's newly-minted ex-girlfriends
I decided to ride with BallerinaChica. Not only is she the obvious best ride-share choice, but she is consistently 45 minutes late, so I can count on less face-time there. When we arrive they will be well into their mimosas. Or at least the non-pregnant or breast-feeding ones will be. Which turns out to be only two of them, because BallerinaChica just called and told me that DB's ex is also riding with us and will enjoy her first mimosa when I do.
I'm very happy for my roommate. I think she'll be terrifying but will mother with the best of intentions. I am glad to help set her up with parenting supplies. I just don't want to do it in a room full of frenemies. (Also, I think diaper games are disgusting.) All week I've been trying not to attach myself to the plan in the back of my mind, which is to call in sick and mail in the gift card (oh, such an easy thing to send! Did I do that on purpose?).
"Just don't go," said Mr. BearCat. "You'd obviously have a much better day if you slept in, watched 'Glee,' applied for jobs, and ate a nice relaxing breakfast."
I am a good person... I am a good person... I am a good person...
*rocks back and forth in fetal position*
I got the invitation in the mail and let it sit on my dresser until last week, when I realized I should probably see where she was registered so I could get her a baby gift. Target. Manageable.
At Target I printed out the registry list and then stood in the baby section staring into space. Too overwhelming. I didn't have enough stamina to see if I could hunt down matching crib sheets. A cursory glance only showed blue polka dots; no pink ones were in sight.
I got her a gift card. Not so much fun to open, but she'll like it later when she runs out of butt paste or breaks a bottle.
Next, I figured out how I would get there. She lives 45 minutes away from me so a car pool would be preferable, but my options were pretty slim. After ruling out:
1. Ex-roommate who recently gave birth and who hates me for getting divorced
2. Second ex-roommate who recently gave birth and who hates me for getting divorced
3. Third ex-roommate who is pregnant with the child of a man who can only be described as neurotic, at best
4. Fourth ex-roommate with demon child (who lives too far away anyway)
5. Fifth ex-roommate who lives too far away
6. Acquaintance who I don't know well enough to spend 45 minutes in the car with (and who recently gave birth)
7. Shower hostess who consistently snubbed me when we lived on the same dorm floor as sophomores, and who I suspect is pregnant
8. One of DB's newly-minted ex-girlfriends
I decided to ride with BallerinaChica. Not only is she the obvious best ride-share choice, but she is consistently 45 minutes late, so I can count on less face-time there. When we arrive they will be well into their mimosas. Or at least the non-pregnant or breast-feeding ones will be. Which turns out to be only two of them, because BallerinaChica just called and told me that DB's ex is also riding with us and will enjoy her first mimosa when I do.
I'm very happy for my roommate. I think she'll be terrifying but will mother with the best of intentions. I am glad to help set her up with parenting supplies. I just don't want to do it in a room full of frenemies. (Also, I think diaper games are disgusting.) All week I've been trying not to attach myself to the plan in the back of my mind, which is to call in sick and mail in the gift card (oh, such an easy thing to send! Did I do that on purpose?).
"Just don't go," said Mr. BearCat. "You'd obviously have a much better day if you slept in, watched 'Glee,' applied for jobs, and ate a nice relaxing breakfast."
I am a good person... I am a good person... I am a good person...
*rocks back and forth in fetal position*
Wednesday, January 4, 2012
adoption file
Thinking about my adoption file always does funny things to my brain. Usually I'm great at remembering numbers and facts, but I've had to read and re-read it to remember even basic items, and then I can't even piece them together to form information. My sieve-like brain can't process the data.
So of course, it is not until I am 28 years of age that someone points out the inconsistency of the story in my file with the facts presented.
I am listed as being born at 9:30 am. My file shows my birth mother's name, my name, and my birth date. It says that she brought me in to a maternity home (in the countryside) when I was 6 months old, wrote my name and birth date in pencil on a piece of notebook paper, and left (refusing intake procedures). The piece of paper is still in my file (I saw it when I visited my agency in Seoul).
So. If her name and that piece of paper is all there is, then how do they know I was born at 9:30 am? Why did they bother to transfer that info to my file in Seoul when I left the maternity home? Obviously, there was more in my original file that never made it to Seoul.
My guess is that I actually was born in the town where I was relinquished, at that maternity home, and that my birth mother went home with me, kept me for 6 months, and then took me back to the same place. She wrote my name and birth date on the piece of paper so that they'd know which baby I was, and they had all my birth/medical files already (and her name).
The adoption agency told me that that maternity home doesn't exist any more, and it probably doesn't, but I'm not sure whether to believe that the files were all destroyed. It's plausible, but on the other hand after hearing all my friends' stories of false files and fake names (and kidnappings, actually), there's a good chance that the information is out there still. Anything is possible, and I can't trust the agency to tell me if it is.
I wish I didn't have such an emotional mental block on this whole thing. It takes me months to make each small step toward figuring it out, because I can't think clearly and practically. It's like I'm a little kid again and I don't even know how to tie my shoes.
So of course, it is not until I am 28 years of age that someone points out the inconsistency of the story in my file with the facts presented.
I am listed as being born at 9:30 am. My file shows my birth mother's name, my name, and my birth date. It says that she brought me in to a maternity home (in the countryside) when I was 6 months old, wrote my name and birth date in pencil on a piece of notebook paper, and left (refusing intake procedures). The piece of paper is still in my file (I saw it when I visited my agency in Seoul).
So. If her name and that piece of paper is all there is, then how do they know I was born at 9:30 am? Why did they bother to transfer that info to my file in Seoul when I left the maternity home? Obviously, there was more in my original file that never made it to Seoul.
My guess is that I actually was born in the town where I was relinquished, at that maternity home, and that my birth mother went home with me, kept me for 6 months, and then took me back to the same place. She wrote my name and birth date on the piece of paper so that they'd know which baby I was, and they had all my birth/medical files already (and her name).
The adoption agency told me that that maternity home doesn't exist any more, and it probably doesn't, but I'm not sure whether to believe that the files were all destroyed. It's plausible, but on the other hand after hearing all my friends' stories of false files and fake names (and kidnappings, actually), there's a good chance that the information is out there still. Anything is possible, and I can't trust the agency to tell me if it is.
I wish I didn't have such an emotional mental block on this whole thing. It takes me months to make each small step toward figuring it out, because I can't think clearly and practically. It's like I'm a little kid again and I don't even know how to tie my shoes.
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
white names
One thing I am doing at work is figuring out if any of the documents I see are legally privileged - that is, I check to see if any are a communication to/from an attorney seeking/reflecting legal advice. If they are, then we would not "produce" them to the opposing side in the discovery process of this lawsuit.
So I have a list of 700 attorney names that would cause a document to be privileged, and at first this task seemed daunting and overly time-consuming. Each email address and each name had to be checked on the list. After awhile though, I noticed some trends.
While the emails may have had "ethnic" sounding employee or client names in them, none of the names on the attorney list was ethnic. In fact, I'd have to say that all the names came from only 3 regions: Scandinavia, the United Kingdom, and Germany. I didn't even see any French or Italian names. And take note - these 700 names were a compilation of many different law firms from all over the U.S.
So the privilege review process became easier once I realized that I didn't have to check the attorney list for any Khans or Tanakas. Depressing.
So I have a list of 700 attorney names that would cause a document to be privileged, and at first this task seemed daunting and overly time-consuming. Each email address and each name had to be checked on the list. After awhile though, I noticed some trends.
While the emails may have had "ethnic" sounding employee or client names in them, none of the names on the attorney list was ethnic. In fact, I'd have to say that all the names came from only 3 regions: Scandinavia, the United Kingdom, and Germany. I didn't even see any French or Italian names. And take note - these 700 names were a compilation of many different law firms from all over the U.S.
So the privilege review process became easier once I realized that I didn't have to check the attorney list for any Khans or Tanakas. Depressing.
Monday, January 2, 2012
window garden
EarthMadre and I (ok her boyfriend) are constructing a window garden in our sun room. I haven't really helped at all except for that time I drove them to Menard's and stared blankly at a wall of tubes while they found stuff. But I am planning to help maintain it.
EarthMadre has ordered packets of heirloom seeds for herbs and small vegetables we are planning to grow. There's an online community of people who have devised different systems for watering the plants, and most of them involve pumps of some sort, but EarthMadre designed a wicking system that will (cross our fingers) work.
The animals are very interested in the preparations.
EarthMadre has ordered packets of heirloom seeds for herbs and small vegetables we are planning to grow. There's an online community of people who have devised different systems for watering the plants, and most of them involve pumps of some sort, but EarthMadre designed a wicking system that will (cross our fingers) work.
The animals are very interested in the preparations.
Sunday, January 1, 2012
Thursday, December 29, 2011
office thief!
Someone in the office stole my string cheese!
I told my friend TommyCloset, who works with me. "Yeah, someone stole a whole Subway sandwich from me the other week. It was only in the 'fridge for an hour," he said.
Dum dum dum...!!
I was very angry about my missing cheese. In fact, I was surprised by how angry I was. I knew enough to write my name on my frozen dinners, but now I had to sign my cheese too? The nerve!
"Maybe I should write them a note," I said. "In fact, I will write passive-aggressive messages on my cheese, like 'This cheese has herpes' and 'nacho cheese.'"
I can't believe it. Who just eats other people's food??
I told my friend TommyCloset, who works with me. "Yeah, someone stole a whole Subway sandwich from me the other week. It was only in the 'fridge for an hour," he said.
Dum dum dum...!!
I was very angry about my missing cheese. In fact, I was surprised by how angry I was. I knew enough to write my name on my frozen dinners, but now I had to sign my cheese too? The nerve!
"Maybe I should write them a note," I said. "In fact, I will write passive-aggressive messages on my cheese, like 'This cheese has herpes' and 'nacho cheese.'"
I can't believe it. Who just eats other people's food??
Wednesday, December 28, 2011
silos
Real Facebook status of an acquaintance from high school: "[Son] told me today that 'girls are pretty and boys are awesome!'"
Real Facebook comment from another user: "That about sums it up ;)"
Real Meow reaction: Oh barf.
I know it's possible to hide the doings of certain Facebook friends from my news feed, but sometimes I keep them around to remind myself that the real world is full of people who don't agree with me, and probably never will. If I didn't do that, I'd happily pad around in my own silo and forget they existed.
Note to self: stay grounded. People who watch Fox News know less about current events than people who watch no news at all, and over 100 million households watch Fox. Now is not the time to escape into your happy world of people who care about the same things you do.
P.S. I bet you 50 bucks my high school acquaintance watches Fox News.
Tuesday, December 27, 2011
red
I think red-baiting is one of the stupidest scare-tactics out there.
"He's a communist!"
Do you realize how ridiculous that sounds? Let's all go around frantically labeling each other by economic systems.
"He's a capitalist!"
That sounds really stupid. Absurd. You're not sure whether you would answer, "Why do you think so?" or "Yes, but why does it matter?" Because we all live under the same economic system, capitalist or not, in a democracy where one person's ideology won't trump everyone else's.
And if your problem with communism is that it has de facto been associated with atheism, well, so goes capitalism with Christianity in the modern era (even though the Biblical new testament community "shared all things in common").
"He's a Christian!" God forbid! Ironically.
I realize I didn't grow up in a time when the communist label was akin to "child rapist" so I don't have the same ingrained emotional reaction to it. But really. Get a hold of yourselves.
"He's a communist!"
Do you realize how ridiculous that sounds? Let's all go around frantically labeling each other by economic systems.
"He's a capitalist!"
That sounds really stupid. Absurd. You're not sure whether you would answer, "Why do you think so?" or "Yes, but why does it matter?" Because we all live under the same economic system, capitalist or not, in a democracy where one person's ideology won't trump everyone else's.
And if your problem with communism is that it has de facto been associated with atheism, well, so goes capitalism with Christianity in the modern era (even though the Biblical new testament community "shared all things in common").
"He's a Christian!" God forbid! Ironically.
I realize I didn't grow up in a time when the communist label was akin to "child rapist" so I don't have the same ingrained emotional reaction to it. But really. Get a hold of yourselves.
Monday, December 26, 2011
boxing day
Christmas card to DB:
DB text: Hahaha... Got your X-mas card today. You certainly are my favorite ex-wife. :)
Success!
Merry Christmas!
Safe travels down [hwy], and say hello to your family.
<3, your favorite ex-wife
DB text: Hahaha... Got your X-mas card today. You certainly are my favorite ex-wife. :)
Success!
Sunday, December 25, 2011
mrow
This is a totally inane exercise in... fluency. Pretend that you are an American cat learning to speak other cat languages. Yes, I know that the proper way to spell “Meow” in French is “Mieu.” But this cat does not read French. This cat is practicing accents.
Mrow (American cat)
Meow?! (English cat)
Miaux (French cat)
Mlow (Korean cat)
Mvao (German cat)
Mao (Chinese cat)
Anyway, Meowy Christmas.
Anyway, Meowy Christmas.
Friday, December 23, 2011
worn
Yeah, pretty sure I'm carrying some psychic trauma this year from learning about the U.S.' relationship with the Korean peninsula. It didn't go away like I thought it would after I posted about it. It's like I tapped into a collective grief, but I wasn't prepared and haven't developed the muscles to bear it so it's weighing me down. This phenomena, when coupled with my ambivalence about being both the oppressed and oppressor, is hard for me to handle at the moment.
Part of me wants to scream, "But when did you think I would find out!?" at everyone I know, even though they probably weren't aware either. But that's also part of the problem.
Part of me wants to scream, "But when did you think I would find out!?" at everyone I know, even though they probably weren't aware either. But that's also part of the problem.
Thursday, December 22, 2011
pandas vs. lamberts
As I have said before, there is a huge gap between how Asian-Americans and progressive white [Midwestern-specific] Americans (like me!) think. Let's call Asian-Americans with Asian/Asian-American parents "pandas." Let's call transracial adoptees with white parents "lamberts" after Lambert the Sheepish Lion, a cartoon I used to watch as a kid.
Illustration #1004 of how we are different inside - a real text message conversation:
Lambert: I'm going to WCCO today to inspect their public record.
Panda: For work?
Lambert: No, as an accountability thing. So they remember to check their facts, not sensationalize Asian stereotypes, and respond to public letters.
Panda: So what are you looking for?
Lambert: Nothing. The act of going is the reminder. We already know what's in their records. Public media are required to hold onto letters received for 3 years, etc.
Panda: Ok...
Lambert: The FCC can't monitor every station so these rules exist to enable the public to hold broadcasting stations accountable. They have to show them to me.
Panda: So you personally feel the need to hold a TV station accountable for its reporting. To stop them from... throwing away letters? So if you go and they're like, "Yeah we threw them away," ... what happens then?
Lambert: They get fined and/or lose their license. We're also looking to see which other complaints they've received. But it's mainly important to remind them to report responsibly.
Panda: They won't lose their license silly. At most they'll get a small fine. And aren't there already tons of crazies that already do this?
Lambert: This is the dog meat issue, where a market was actually invaded and shut down because WCCO ran a sensationalist story. They'd be fined for not complying once, but continuing to do so would be worse. Anyway, I'm sure they don't want to splotch up their public record.
Panda: Well they shouldn't have been selling dog meat.
Lambert: They weren't. It was duck.
Panda: Shouldn't it be up to the restaurant to pursue action against WCCO?
Lambert: They're a small non-English speaking business in NY. Pretty sure that would be beyond overwhelming for them. WCCO didn't even offer a real apology even after they were called out on it. They said, "Our facts were wrong, but the situation lent itself to that conclusion that it was dog."
Panda: I feel like this is one of those situations where you just end up increasing the resentment of the people at account against Asians. Like, they probably already hate us more due to all the shit they got. And now you and your friend are going to go poke at them more. You can be sure that if an Asian person screws up, WCCO will drop the hammer on them.
Lambert: And that is an example of you being a panda and me not.
Panda: You mean me seeing the bigger picture and how getting up in their face needs to be done by whites?
Lambert: Laws exist to protect us from this. And whites don't see it as their problem.
Panda: I'm sure some do.
Lambert: If the Asian American Journalist Association in MN is brave enough to demand an apology when WCCO has all the leverage in their world, then they deserve to have someone actually support them and do the dirty work. And no white group has organized around this. CAAR is supposed to be multiracial but it's mostly Asians.
Panda: This is like when black people got civil rights and started washing their genitals in the white drinking fountain. It just made white people hate them more.
Lambert: Har har. I'm not breaking any laws. In fact, I'm supporting their functions. The FCC wants members of the public to do this.
Panda: WCCO didn't break any laws either.
Lambert: Right. This is an entirely civil conversation occurring for the public good.
Panda: But you have bad intentions. You would just love it so much if you found something bad and smeared WCCO with it.
Lambert: No, I don't. I like WCCO. I want them to do a good job, and represent me, and sometimes reminding them who they should be is useful for them.
Panda: Hrmph.
Lambert: I was on WCCO - they filmed me skating on their roof for a story. They recorded me arriving from Korea and meeting my parents. I identify with them.
Panda: Ok. So what you're saying is that they need more fake news.
Lambert: Whatever.... obviously, nothing ever happens in Minnesota.
Illustration #1004 of how we are different inside - a real text message conversation:
Lambert: I'm going to WCCO today to inspect their public record.
Panda: For work?
Lambert: No, as an accountability thing. So they remember to check their facts, not sensationalize Asian stereotypes, and respond to public letters.
Panda: So what are you looking for?
Lambert: Nothing. The act of going is the reminder. We already know what's in their records. Public media are required to hold onto letters received for 3 years, etc.
Panda: Ok...
Lambert: The FCC can't monitor every station so these rules exist to enable the public to hold broadcasting stations accountable. They have to show them to me.
Panda: So you personally feel the need to hold a TV station accountable for its reporting. To stop them from... throwing away letters? So if you go and they're like, "Yeah we threw them away," ... what happens then?
Lambert: They get fined and/or lose their license. We're also looking to see which other complaints they've received. But it's mainly important to remind them to report responsibly.
Panda: They won't lose their license silly. At most they'll get a small fine. And aren't there already tons of crazies that already do this?
Lambert: This is the dog meat issue, where a market was actually invaded and shut down because WCCO ran a sensationalist story. They'd be fined for not complying once, but continuing to do so would be worse. Anyway, I'm sure they don't want to splotch up their public record.
Panda: Well they shouldn't have been selling dog meat.
Lambert: They weren't. It was duck.
Panda: Shouldn't it be up to the restaurant to pursue action against WCCO?
Lambert: They're a small non-English speaking business in NY. Pretty sure that would be beyond overwhelming for them. WCCO didn't even offer a real apology even after they were called out on it. They said, "Our facts were wrong, but the situation lent itself to that conclusion that it was dog."
Panda: I feel like this is one of those situations where you just end up increasing the resentment of the people at account against Asians. Like, they probably already hate us more due to all the shit they got. And now you and your friend are going to go poke at them more. You can be sure that if an Asian person screws up, WCCO will drop the hammer on them.
Lambert: And that is an example of you being a panda and me not.
Panda: You mean me seeing the bigger picture and how getting up in their face needs to be done by whites?
Lambert: Laws exist to protect us from this. And whites don't see it as their problem.
Panda: I'm sure some do.
Lambert: If the Asian American Journalist Association in MN is brave enough to demand an apology when WCCO has all the leverage in their world, then they deserve to have someone actually support them and do the dirty work. And no white group has organized around this. CAAR is supposed to be multiracial but it's mostly Asians.
Panda: This is like when black people got civil rights and started washing their genitals in the white drinking fountain. It just made white people hate them more.
Lambert: Har har. I'm not breaking any laws. In fact, I'm supporting their functions. The FCC wants members of the public to do this.
Panda: WCCO didn't break any laws either.
Lambert: Right. This is an entirely civil conversation occurring for the public good.
Panda: But you have bad intentions. You would just love it so much if you found something bad and smeared WCCO with it.
Lambert: No, I don't. I like WCCO. I want them to do a good job, and represent me, and sometimes reminding them who they should be is useful for them.
Panda: Hrmph.
Lambert: I was on WCCO - they filmed me skating on their roof for a story. They recorded me arriving from Korea and meeting my parents. I identify with them.
Panda: Ok. So what you're saying is that they need more fake news.
Lambert: Whatever.... obviously, nothing ever happens in Minnesota.
Wednesday, December 21, 2011
forbes peers down and says "hey you there"
I don't know if any of you read Forbes Magazine (I don't make a habit of it), but if you do, you'll have read an article titled, "If I Were A Poor Black Kid" written by Gene Marks lately. Gene Marks is, if you take a gander, obviously not a poor black kid but as you read the article it will become more and more apparent how far he is from it. As I continued to read I wasn't sure whether it was more hilarious or sad - his whole endeavor is terribly misguided and insulting to generations of people who have worked with poor black kids and their communities.
Here are some of the best responses:
Kelly Virella - "If I Were The Middle Class White Guy Gene Marks"
Jeff Yang - "If I Were A Rich White Dude"
The Urban Scientist - "If I Were A Wealthy White Suburbanite"
Here are some of the best responses:
Kelly Virella - "If I Were The Middle Class White Guy Gene Marks"
Jeff Yang - "If I Were A Rich White Dude"
The Urban Scientist - "If I Were A Wealthy White Suburbanite"
Tuesday, December 20, 2011
when a dictator dies
I cannot be curious or excited
when it feels like tourism from someone born on the privileged end
of a TV remote flipping through the news channels
when it feels like tourism from someone born on the privileged end
of a TV remote flipping through the news channels
I cannot pray for or on behalf of a people
when the sentences keep ending with “new markets for capitalism”
when the sentences keep ending with “new markets for capitalism”
I cannot ask if one is from the north or south
or east or west
when a border does not define a human being
or east or west
when a border does not define a human being
I cannot use the term dictator
When dictator is a term we only use to label our enemies
who were sometimes our friends before they were our enemies
When dictator is a term we only use to label our enemies
who were sometimes our friends before they were our enemies
I cannot wave justice like a flag
when I believe I can find it in the full of a body bag
when I believe I can find it in the full of a body bag
I cannot act in a peoples’ best interests
when my best interests sound like too many screaming in silence
when my best interests sound like too many screaming in silence
I cannot muse about what this event means for my life
When I do not know the desperate alchemy of trying to feed a family
When I do not know the desperate alchemy of trying to feed a family
I cannot be one drum, one pair of clapping hands, or one jeering mouth,
I cannot celebrate death
ever
I cannot celebrate death
ever
I cannot be afraid of what the next man will do, or what country will rise
when I have questioned into the hallow of that logic time and time again
And love is the only thing
that has ever answered back
“stay whole”
when I have questioned into the hallow of that logic time and time again
And love is the only thing
that has ever answered back
“stay whole”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
