Edited by: Jane Jeong Trenka, Julia Chinyere Oparah, and Sun Yung Shin
2006 South End Press
This
book is a must-read for anyone considering raising a child of another race. It's not really a how-to manual, but is rather a compilation of articles about the phenomenon of transracial adoption. It covers the personal experiences of transracial adoptees and their family members in the context of the origins of transracial adoption, laws and politics regarding it, mental health schemas, and societal trends.
Whether or not you think the personal perspectives of the authors are valid, the truth of the matter is that they are real perspectives, and your children will potentially share them, so get ready. If you're already a parent you're probably aware that you can't control how your children will feel (about anything) as adults, but you can give them healthy life-coping skills. And you, as a potential white parent, are not yet capable of teaching brown children all of the necessary skills. If you want give your transracially-adopted family-members the best chance at understanding and loving themselves, you should first be prepared to consider some very hard questions about yourself and your place in the world.
Reading this book was also very useful for me personally. It put things that I feel into the contexts of others' journeys and broader political and social movements. I felt like less of a loose-end and more of something comprehensible. Also, articles in the book moved beyond pathologizing adult adoptees' interest in examining their own social histories and in connecting with other adoptees. Our desire to hang out with other adoptees, or visit Korea, or even our feelings of loss do not necessarily arise out of mental illness or "maladjustment," but may be valid expressions of our healthy sense of self. In other words, maybe having healthy selves includes acknowledging that we have wounds indefinitely and accepting their presence.
We have such fractured identities from living in this world. We have too many selves, and in rejecting the stress of trying to meld them, some of us unbalance too far in one direction or another - trying to be white, trying to be Asian (or other race). Articles in this book discuss living with our many selves. Is that the solution? I don't know. Maybe it's not possible to merge our identities into one cohesive being. Regardless, living with multiple selves has given me an insta-detach response to stressful stimuli in my life.
I went to a friend's soccer game last weekend. He plays on a team of Korean-Korean-Americans. In other words, the older players mostly only speak Korean. The guys our age are bilingual - so the team generally communicates in Korean. My friend is one of two adoptees. On this particular day (and probably on every other day), his team was playing a team of white men. The white men had some fans on the sidelines, and I and another Korean-adoptee were on the sidelines for the Korean team. Races split accordingly.
The game got a little heated. The white fans, who looked like my aunts and grandparents, glared at the Korean team and included me in their glares. They muttered things under their breath that I could understand. And in moments like that, my Self floats away and I detach from the scene. It's automatic.
I watch myself from a distance.
I see myself in the eyes of the white team. I have white brain because I don't know how to have any other brain. I am, even to myself, an Other.
I see myself in the eyes of the Korean team. As I watch the game I stand assertively with my shoulders strong, unlike Korean-raised girls. I yell things in my strong American voice. I am competitive. I am alien.
Who is this person on the sidelines? I don't know. It's hard to openly be a cohesive strangething, all the time, when everyone else living the identities you hold clearly believes that you are not like them. It's easier to let yourself slip into a more comprehensible category - and for all purposes, my easiest category is "Asian." Without speaking, no matter what I wear, I am Asian. So I fall silent and watch the rest of the game inside my own head, belonging on both teams and neither, letting the white team dismiss me as Asian and letting the Korean team forget that I am there.
When you have children of a different race than you, who do you imagine they will be friends with as adults? What sort of person do you imagine will want to be friends with them? Who will they marry? Who will want to marry them? You cannot create the world to be as you hope it will be. You can position your children to enter utopia, but you must also equip them to survive in the chaos that will precede it, because change is slow.
Sidenote: you should also not expect them to feel enlightened for being inter-cultural ambassadors. They're really not, at least until they're adults, and then they might be bitter about it. When parents say they want to adopt brown kids because the kids will bring cultural enrichment to their lives, that's like the most racist thing ever. The kids will be totally American, because the parents are totally American and that's all they'll know how to be. Assuming that someone's going to have certain exotic personality characteristics just because of how they look is ridiculous, especially if you plan on raising them on Sponge Bob and Cheerios. What your kids
will bring to your family is experiences of direct and indirect racism as they age out of childhood. If you wanted cultural enrichment, you'll have to get it from outside your family. And if you were going to get it outside your family anyway, why use children as an excuse, as forced inter-cultural ambassadors?
Parents should also make note and distinguish between three different issue sets: Adoption, Racial prejudice and hatred, and Absence of belonging as adults. I deal with racism directed at groups I don't actually belong to. It's weird. It's confusing. It usually takes me awhile to figure out what, exactly, bothers me about each exchange like that. When I was younger I was angry that people threw their anti-Asian prejudices at me. I wanted to say, "I'm just like you! I have white parents! I'm a whole wheat bun with the nutritional value of bleached flour!" (I actually said that.) After I stopped trying to board the white privilege boat, I got angry because people were being racist at all. Damn white people... stop hating on us Asians. And now I'm just lost. I'm a well-adjusted mal-adjusted floater. I'm grateful that I had a family that supported me through many levels of education so that now I can articulate these things, because if I couldn't then I'd just be angry and unproductive. The downside is that now my family has to actually listen to my ruminations instead of having me go away and be self-destructive in isolation.
Adoption is a lifelong process. It's always discussed in terms of parenting, but it should be discussed in terms of family-forming. Your children will be adults, and then
you will all be adults together for longer than they were children. I've heard people talking about how they have, or want to, adopt "a little [gender] from [brown country]." They should think about adoption in terms of bringing an actual Korean, or Guatemalan, or Indian into their family. That's how everyone else is going to see them when they're grown up, and that's what you'll all have to deal with. Can you walk down the street with your arm around a black lady? Can you tolerate the pain your daughter will feel when she hears others telling her white boyfriend that he has "yellow fever?"
Will you still be a family then? My answer is yes, but a different sort of family. Not better, not worse. Different. Hopefully able to acknowledge fractures and multiple, sometimes conflicting, feelings.
Korean adoptees are like a family. I don't mean that in a cliche way, like we have potlucks and hold hands and sing "Kumbaya" together (though I'm sure it's happened). Korean adoptees have an affinity for one another. This affinity makes many adoptees uncomfortable, and so they reject the companionship of other adoptees. That's their decision. But they cannot deny that this affinity exists. It exists in even stronger forms than I'd previously acknowledged. I've always known that I wanted to hang out with other adoptees because I don't have to explain myself when I'm with them, but I've only recently realized how deep an actual duty to them goes.
Someone once asked, "Isn't there just a giant elephant in the room when you all hang out, because you know you're all sitting there because you're adopted?"
When we're together, it's like all of our personal elephants go away, and we are free to be ourselves. We like each other for our kindness, jokes, and taste in food, just like any other group of friends. But we also have an ease of being that comes from resting the most prevalent wall of self-defense in our lives. And we probably create other walls for each other, just like any other group of friends.
While I knew I liked having Korean adopted friends, I've neglected to notice that I feel indebted to all of the ones who are following me in their journeys. I allow them mistakes I wouldn't tolerate from other acquaintances. I maintain friendships with people I would normally forget because I know I might be their only Korean-adoptee friend, and they might need that connection. I listen extra-carefully to stories of woe from Korean-adoptee friends. I feel overly-protective of the teenagers I counsel at camp. It's like a family loyalty that transcends biology, again, because we know how to do that. I'll probably always feel like I have a duty to fellow Korean-adoptees.
I'll probably also always feel like I have a family loyalty to my adoptive family. I, and probably many other adoptees, have struggled with exactly how to rationalize our love for our adoptive families with our feelings of unrest and frustration. Articles in "Outsiders Within" acknowledge that both types of feelings are acceptable and often occur simultaneously. You are not necessarily a fractured person if you spend your day frustrated with racial injustices and white privilege, and then go home for dinner with your white family. Your family is your family, and the world your parents created for you within your nuclear family can feel very different from the world you encounter when you step outside. They
are different worlds. Here is a situation where strong belief in a legal fiction can create a reality. It's uncomfortable to make the leap back and forth until you realize that they really are just two different worlds. I'm still coming to terms with that fact. My childhood in my nuclear family was so nurturing that it's taken me a long time to step back from my love-induced complacency and really consider how the different parts of myself interact - sometimes to my benefit, sometimes not.
I didn't even realize I might have Korean grandparents until I was 3/4 through this book. I'm slightly stunned. I wish I would have dealt with this earlier, but I was too busy being loved in my cocoon.
Some adoptees who did not grow up with love or who were never taught emotional coping skills in their adoptive families never learned to make the leap between worlds. They had to find those parts of themselves elsewhere, and their journeys were much harder than mine. Many parents and professionals in the adoption community dismiss them as "messed up" or angry individuals. Inherently bad apples. But dismissing them as flaws in the process means missing a bigger picture.
"Adult adoptees who question this notion [that they are blessed] are often portrayed as being maladjusted or having personal problems, meaning that the real concerns with adoption are taken out of the larger context and are reduced to individual, personal issues." - Sunny Jo, pg. 286.
Don't assign pathology to the angry voices as a whole. Read this book, learn the history, and consider our stories in the context of our existence. Don't reduce these important themes to personal issues. Your future family members' health is at stake.