Wednesday, December 12, 2012

little war on the prairie

When I was in elementary school (probably 6th grade, which is when all Minnesotan kids have to do a year of Minnesota history) I remember going on a tour of my hometown to look at sites involved in various battles of the U.S. - Dakota War / Conflict. Formerly referred to as the Sioux Uprising.

We looked at arrowheads lodged in stone walls and heard about some little girl who was shot in the street. I remember that the tour guide did a reasonable job of presenting it as a nuanced conflict but still did not offer more context than one could garner from watching "Dances With Wolves." Which is what I always picture when I think about these issues.

This year is the 150th anniversary of the war, and southern Minnesota held commemorations and healing ceremonies and symbolically welcomed the Dakota back. If this sounds silly (weren't they already "back?" - no) check out this story at MPR (which I first heard on "This American Life"). I'd recommend listening to it, but the transcript is available as well.

We (well, some people) know that the largest mass execution in American history took place in Mankato, MN in 1862. We perceive that tensions were high on the prairie at the time and that as the winners, we took it upon ourselves to execute the losers. But questions of why and how still persist.

Also, if you listen to the story you'll develop a strong loathing for Minnesota's beloved Henry Sibley.

What the context brought to light for me this time around is that the Homestead Act... of 1862... was passed immediately after these events. The Act was designed to get settlers out west in great numbers, and it succeeded.

So all of you proud homesteaders who like to talk about how many years your families have owned land in southern Minnesota, stop and think about where that land came from. You know who you are.

The concept of "settling" has been problematic for me ever since I was struck by the negativity of the word when I learned more about the Israel-Palestine conflict during college (past a Leon Uris analysis). In the holy land, settlers are jerks. Nothing about what they're currently doing makes sense.

And if we (Am I owning this? I suppose it is my cultural legacy) did the same thing 150 years and more ago, we're just as bad. I'd just been in the habit of hearing "settler" and idealistically imagining someone in overalls stoically striking off to meet his destiny, battling hardships and ultimately succeeding in... farming.

Obviously, I grew up on the prairie.

But my point is that there must have been something we thought needed settling, and that thing was someone else's, and our means of doing it were horrible.

We need to incorporate this truth into our collective identity. While I understand how our little happy bubbles of manifest destiny came to be, they are bubbles nonetheless and we're lesser for living in them.

1 comment:

Mushroom Planet said...

Don't forget to put The Night Birds on your reading list.