It passed yesterday. I didn't even think it would make it out of committee.
It had wide bipartisan support. Because everyone sees the words "adoption" and "orphan" and "refugee" and the logical parts of their brains stop moving. "It must be good, then! Orphans, you know!"
The facts they are touting in post-vote interview are wrong, and poorly supported.
The reasoning behind passing this benign-sounding bill is an ulterior motive at best, malevolent at worst. Either way, it's going to create irreparable damage.
I'm trying to figure out what can be done. The analysis behind why this bill is so problematic is tricky, nuanced, and will fly over the heads of most legislators because they don't have time to actually sit down and consider what they voted on. After reading the articles, I honestly believe their thought process looked something like this:
- Helping orphans = Good!
- North Korea = Bad!
Even scholars on North Korea, foreign policy wonks, adoption professionals, immigration attorneys, and adoptees themselves aren't catching this. Probably because none of them are talking to each other. Or talking to war strategists.
I'd write some more articles, except this isn't my own research, and the people who did this research aren't currently speaking to one another.
The historical number of times that personal disputes have probably gotten in the way of progress blows my mind. It must be astronomical.
No comments:
Post a Comment