Monday, June 11, 2012

from russia, with love

I just noticed this article. It's the story of a Russian girl adopted into a South Korean home. It gave me a lot to think about. I sent it to Mr.BearCat.

"It's a happie story," he said.

"Yes," I said.

"You don't think so?" he asked, suspicious. He knows I take issue with many things in the adoption world, but I don't think he's quite parsed out the reasoning underlying my views. I am not "pro" or "anti" adoption in the dichotomy most people use when they think of the issue. I don't operate with a foregone conclusion ("no adoptions ever!"), but rather with an understanding of the many pitfalls transnational, transracial adoption can fall into.

I did agree - this was a happy story. And the reasons why I believe it is shed light on what I take issue with concerning typical inter-country adoption trends. In this case,

The adoptee was old enough to make the decision for herself.

She still has a relationship with her birth family.

She still speaks fluent Russian.

There is no evidence that an adoption agency has promoted Russian-Korean adoptions on a wide scale for profit.

The adoptee's race will privilege her in her new country, instead of being a detriment, and even if her Korean parents aren't able to teach her how to be white, her first parents have already given her this identity.

This was done on an individual basis between the two families, so the birth parents' rights were maintained. It  was a real choice.

The situation doesn't promulgate the idea that white women are better mothers for brown children than brown mothers would be.

Obviously, learning Korean at age 12 and moving countries and families mid-childhood isn't easy. But it's a real choice that everyone got to make together. It's completely different than what's going on elsewhere.

No comments: