Did you hear about the federal judge in Montana who sent an email with a racist joke involving bestiality and Obama's mother to six "old buddies?" If you didn't, now you have.
Of course there's the expected post-event battle between supporters of the judge and offended groups, but neither seems to be communicating the real problem very well. Sure, Judge Cebull is probably a very personable, collegial man, and he probably has enough sense not to make racist jokes in public, and one mistake should not define a person's entire life.
But Judge Cebull stated that he "didn't send it as racist, although that's what it is. I sent it out because it's anti-Obama." Later, he said, "If anything, it's political." He argued that his conduct over the years has shown that he is not "a racist."
And that, my friends, is exactly what is wrong.
In the minds of the general public, racism consists of individual outward acts. Behavior. People believe that if you can manage to overcome your initial behavioral urges (like clutching your purse when a black man walks by), you have "overcome racism." This task is now considered one of many things the modern individual must do to be considered morally right. "Racist" has somehow ended up in the same category as "wife beater" and "communist." It has been too easy to relegate real evaluations of this issue to a black and white moral dichotomy with a simple test: Am I mean to brown people and not white people?
And in fact, I'd go so far as to say that some people do not even keep this test in mind, but rather expect that "racism" would physically manifest itself somewhere on their body like a health issue. If you don't ever "come down with it," or if you don't see a malignant growth on your foot, you don't have it. So you don't have to think about it. It's something that troubles other, less fortunate people, and since you don't hang out with any racists you couldn't possibly have contracted it.
Another form of the test is: Do I have any brown friends or family members? Yes? Then I couldn't possibly have racism. Whew. I can use this as proof when other people ask.
This seems to be the depth of the discussion surrounding Cebull's behavior. People are searching for examples of his prior behavior, scanning for indicia of racism. Since he is a federal judge, his potential bias as the decider of people's lives is relevant. But the discussion has an obvious outcome, and that is this: Cebull is racist. Does that mean he has been a bad judge? Not necessarily. It appears on the surface that he has successfully managed his own tendencies in the decisions he's written on the federal bench. But the mere fact that he sent that email without considering that comparing a black man to an animal who mated with a white woman (resulting in the President of the United States) is a horribly offensive, racially-charged scenario... means that he's racist. If you don't have any second thoughts about something so obvious, then your view of the world is skewed. And that particular brand of "skewing" is known as - you guessed it - racism. Will he be a good judge in the future? All this incident has shown us is that, like 90% of other judges, he has realized that it is personally beneficial to avoid any outward signs of racism. And in his caseload as a judge, he will try not to take any actions that clearly demonstrate his racism. Is that safety net good enough?
For this conversation to be productive and for his apology to mean anything, needs to own his racism and stop telling everyone that he is not "a racist." What do racists look like? Not all of them have swastika tattoos. We all need to own our racism. It's not the end of the world. Very few people get disowned for being racist. It's a very serious issue, but somehow the seriousness of it has created a culture of avoidance - we give it such a wide berth that no one knows what it looks like any more. We only recognize it in its extremity, and that is a travesty. It's like deciding that only cancer deserves our attention, when the flu affects more people, is still awful, and also has the potential to kill you.
There's not an easy fix like some seem to believe (ex: the behavior test above), but it is clear that choosing not to see it only harms people. And that is the real moral test. Are you willing to work further on yourself instead of merely changing some outward behavior and calling it a day?
If everyone got to the point and just agreed that yes, Cebull exhibited racist behavior (and thus is racist), then they could move on to the more pressing issue: what should be done?
1 comment:
I was a victim of an act of racism about 3 weeks ago, during rehearsal with the community choir I've been singing in....and it's been affecting my life. and I've been struggling with how to articulate it.
Post a Comment