Tuesday, December 13, 2011

what's in a name

[DBLastName] doesn’t feel like my name, and it’s hard to remember when it did. I don’t remember that person very well.

My maiden name also doesn’t feel like my name, but I do remember what it feels like to have it. It felt like my name at the time. Before the world started meeting me as myself and I changed to realize what the world saw.

It is a very strange feeling to meet yourself for the first time in your late 20’s. You’d think I wouldn’t have waited so long. What was I doing before now, you ask? The truth is, I don’t know. I think I was trying. In fact I’m still trying, but it feels less in vain. I’m arriving at places that are a little scary but feel right.

When I see DB now at various social events, he still feels like an excellent family member, but not my partner. I’ve wondered why I ever thought he could be. I spent the whole relationship trying to push him to be something he was not, and for reasons that are both his fault and mine, I didn’t (don’t?) respect the person he actually was. After seven years of trying, there was nothing to be done. It is still a relief to have let go, to not feel responsible for him, and to know that his doings do not reflect on me.

What we did have in common was my family. More than anything, I saw my family in him. He fit in perfectly, and I scored an A+ in finding a good addition to our numbers. Gma approved. MotherDearest thought he’d be a good father for her grandchildren. And for me – I used to think the same, but just as importantly, I appreciated that he served as a buffer at larger gatherings when I wasn’t feeling social. The problem is that I am not looking for items that already exist in my family. That is where I have come from, but not where I am going. If I am looking for balance, I will seek out someone who understands the parts of me that my family cannot. And even if he cannot understand parts of me that my family can, I will still have avoided creating a situation where I am marginalized even among my own people.

I have, by necessity, multiple parts. I wish I would have known this about myself much earlier. I would have spared one Minnesotan boy much grief, and my family just as much. (Eventually, DB is going to have to visit Gma and Gmpa to break up with them, and ask them not to include him in their weekly grandchild email.) It is an unfortunate bit of conventional wisdom that holds that you don't really know someone until you've met their family. While it may be true that knowing someone's family helps you get to know that someone better, it is not true that meeting someone's family is sufficient for knowing them completely. And so, there are parts of me that do not belong to my family. I didn't realize how important this was until it was too late.

When we weren’t with my family I wanted to kill him 3 times out of 4. Or disassociate from him. We’d be great family-members, but life-partners? No way. Some things you can handle from a family member, but not from your "other half." Too close of an association, both internally and externally.

So what was I thinking when I asked him to join my family? In reality, I was trying to live as if I had been born to my parents. In fact when I was 19 I told my mother that I would probably marry a Norwegian, and from then on it lodged in my brain. While living this way may be possible for some people who were also not born to their parents, it is not possible for me. My history fundamentally affects my self today, and I must carve out my own way of belonging to my family.

I cannot give the things to my family that I grew up thinking I wanted to give. I can’t be a near perfect granddaughter, or daughter, because I am not wired to do traditionally perfect mainstream granddaughter/daughter things. I can participate once in awhile because it feels good to make my family members happy, but engaging in traditionally perfect things as a life-work (see: getting married to a nice Norwegian-Minnesotan boy) feels wrong. I don’t identify with the perfect, and I probably never will. I feel more perfect being imperfect in certain ways. I am not like that nice Norwegian-Minnesotan boy. I could fool him for just long enough, just like I could fool anyone, but in the end I couldn’t convince him I was happy. If you ask any of our mutual friends, they will tell you that part of me shut off when we were together. I couldn't peacefully exist in such a close association as marriage with the person that he couldn't help being, on the inside. The people we were could be friends, but in a marriage I felt trapped. I couldn't feel proud of him most of the time, even though he brought me his biggest accomplishments to praise, because our value systems were so different. I felt most proud of him when the external world praised him instead. Pretty much I felt like I was living someone else's life and mostly pulling it off, but the dissonance wore me down.

But it's hard to explain, and people don't think you should get divorced unless you can provide a clear one-sentence reason. So I know I sound like a spoiled impractical too-modern girl. But let's be honest here. The situation as it stood wasn't fair to him either, and I think this decision gives both of us the opportunity for living real lives.

Did I want a friendly, stable, hardworking young man? Of course I did. He was all of those things, and yet I was wrong in thinking that those qualities were sufficient to make a relationship work. Those might be necessary things (maybe not "friendly") but are not the whole ballgame. I didn't know myself. I was wrong.

That is not my apron. 

No comments: