Monday, May 16, 2011

gay. marriage.

Le gasp.

I heard this guy on MPR... and I can't remember his name, but he's a lobbyist against same sex marriage in Minnesota. He wasn't yelling, which made him seem more sane, but his calm tone was a sharp contrast with the things he was saying. I hope people didn't feel inclined to agree with him just because he was using his pastor voice.

He made religious arguments against gay marriage. Which are useless if you think that church and state should be kept separate. While our founding fathers were not as free from religiosity as they would have liked to think, they still promoted the principles that we tout today. Even if it's not entirely possible to separate religion from government, I think it's important to try. So if you're against gay marriage because Jesus said so, that's not good enough for this country and this state.

He argued that "the definition of marriage is 'one man and one woman.'" Well that's nice. Where do definitions come from? Do they never change? It's a chicken-or-egg argument that, when thrown on the debate floor, sounds like it has more oomph than it really does. We are not powerless to change a mere definition.

The only thing he got right is that MN has the power to regulate marriages. The federal government should not, I believe. The conservative Right always runs back and points at the national constitution like God wrote it, word for word, and to even think of challenging it is immoral. They're all fundamentalist about the constitution like they are about the bible; they just can't help themselves. Once they start attaching to old documents it's like no human ever wrote them. Anyway, off my soapbox. Under the constitution of our federalist system of government, the big national government should basically just make sure A) we have freedoms, and B) no one hits each other. Then there's a clause about how it can do whatever's necessary to support itself. Anyway. The constitution isn't so much a holy script telling us how to live, as it is a recipe for government (add three branches, don't mix) and prescription for regulating ourselves. There are a lot of random odds and ends because our founding fathers were human and they couldn't agree on anything either - hence the pork. But I digress. Under our federalist form of government, it is up to the states to decide if they want to regulate social things like marriage, and how. So banning gay marriage via constitutional amendment does not belong in the national conversation, but making sure no one's liberties are being taken away (ahem right to marriage) does belong in the national conversation. The wrong side is taking this to the legislature.

Now that we have our proper venue (the state of Minnesota), we can debate whether a ban on gay marriage belongs in our constitution. And if you read paragraphs 2 and 3 above, you must agree that the whole idea is stupid.

And that's the way Sue "C's" it.

No comments: