Monday, March 21, 2011

never let me go

If you haven't read "Never Let Me Go," by Kazuo Ishiguro, it's a 2005 novel by a Japanese-British man written as a first-person narrative: but the voice is a 30-something British woman in the 1980's-1990's. When I first started reading I was weirded out by the fact that an Asian male could so realistically (to me, it seemed) voice the thoughts and impressions of a white Englishwoman. Sort of like the way I'm weirded out by the fact that "Memoirs of a Geisha" was written by Arthur Golden, a white man from Tennessee. Since Golden couldn't help but over-fetishize a lot of Asian things in his book, I was already suspicious when I started "Never Let Me Go." But Ishiguro's book is nothing like Golden's in the way of cultural voyeurism. Ishiguro's book isn't about being a British schoolgirl at all.

The thing that did end up annoying me about "Never Let Me Go" was that the narrative voice couldn't seem to tell a straight story. Every time she divulged a piece of information she digressed into two or three more stories about other seemingly-unrelated things. It almost always took her an entire chapter to make a point. This got on my nerves. Probably in the same way that I got on your nerves when I didn't end my first paragraph with a conclusion. But imagine doing that for an entire book.

After awhile I figured out that she kept telling stories about "insignificant" memories of life at her boarding school because her boarding school was her whole life. It framed the way she saw everything. It was her entire world. (And by extension, whoever ran her boarding school had immense power over her world. You have to read the book to figure out what that means). If you haven't gotten annoyed with me these first three paragraphs, you can probably handle the book. You learn that she is an organ donor clone in the first chapter, but she doesn't directly address this until the end.

My main point in writing about all of this is that the book asks the question, "What is the point of trying to live an authentic life?" Oh, I know that a lot of book clubs are probably wrestling over the immediate ethical issues inherent in cloning humans to be organ donors, but in their discussions they will eventually arrive at the question, "What is the best possible life that an organ-donor clone could have, and is it worth living?" We will ask this because we are humanists, and of course we have to think about the clones' feelings because we will assume that that they have souls. This will be easy for us because none of us have relatives who need (readily available!) organs yet.

The book is well-written, but I didn't like reading it. I thought the narrative was too ethereal, and the voice was wandering on codeine. The pages didn't grab my attention. But overall it captured an experience I have every day - the effort to live an authentic life even when you know that there is something inherently false about your existence, and the alienation that results from this struggle. The voice's detachment accurately reflects this feeling.

How did Ishiguro do this, I wondered? Then I remembered that he is a Japanese man living in the UK. I looked him up on Wikipedia and learned that he moved to England when he was six, back in 1960. He didn't become a British citizen until 1982, but he didn't return to Japan until 1989 - nearly thirty years after he arrived in the UK. He spent his entire formative life as an "other" in 20th century England, without a real adult experience in the country of his birth. He is both more and less alienated than me. He spoke Japanese at home and through his parents he gained a cultural inheritance that matches his face, but he grew up in a more xenophobic outside environment - and one that his parents couldn't navigate like mine do.

I'm sure book clubs are also revisiting themes of "loss of childhood innocence" and "coming of age," but the real story, for me at least, lies in the struggle to be authentic even when you don't know what that means for your life. The phenomenon of my existence, just like the narrator's existence as a scientifically-engineered human clone, is the product of nothing natural. Artificial transplants are rightly regarded by adoptive environments as foreign species. In nature, this is often dangerous for native species. I know that humans operate on a more social, less purely biological level than plants. Due to the great love and care of my parents I have had many success stories in my life, but if I want to live an authentic one I have to appraise mine honestly, and in doing so I acknowledge that I am unnatural. I am. Whether or not it is ok (all of you recoiled at that word) to be unnatural, that is what I am.

Both the narrator of "Never Let Me Go" and I were lucky to have had peaceful, well-fed childhoods greatly shaped by our caretakers. In fact, I would say that my parents were much more influential over my life than other children's parents because I grew up without TV, neighbors, or constant daycare. My parents spent more time with me than many other parents have the resources to do. Similarly, the narrator grew up in an idyllic boarding school that emphasized healthy living (of course), education, and creative art projects. When she learns, as an adult, that other organ donor clones grew up in horrible conditions, she is not sure whether to feel grateful for her childhood or to resent that the stark reality of her existence was glossed over for so long by her school guardians. In the end, she decides that her childhood memories at the boarding school are valuable and should be cherished, but that she would also have preferred hearing a more truthful account of her existence.

My life would be both easier and more difficult if everyone had openly acknowledged that I am a freak. This book clearly highlights issues that for me have been hard to pin down, because my situation is less freaky than cloning and it is customary to be polite about adoption. But the narrator is aware that she is a ghost when she leaves her boarding school for the adult world; normal people physically shrink back from her when they learn what she is. The narrator and I can both hide behind our natural-looking faces, but organic Asians mentally shrink back from me when they learn what I am. The narrator and I have both been created to be something that would not exist, had it not been for technological-legal interference.

I'm not sure that author Ishiguro is aware of how his time as a Japanese-English citizen has influenced his writing, and I haven't read anything else by him, but I am certain that his ability to write this novel from the perspective of an organ donor clone comes from this experience. He knows what it is to be alienated, and he has undoubtedly experienced a search for an authentic existence.

I haven't decided whether it is possible for Ishiguro's narrator to live an authentic life. I think it comes down to whether she can fall in love, as is posed in the book. I am not sure that she did fall in love. But then again, what do I know?

Perhaps my conclusion is that it is just much harder to live an authentic life when you have no original foothold from which to spring into motion. Everything means more when you don't naturally come by it, and you find yourself mimicking others in an effort to be real. You try on different ways of being, and it's easy for you because you don't know what your default is. You always have the sense that your actions are not as true as others' even if you don't intend to be false. You overcompensate. You over analyze. And in doing so, you forget to live.

So what is the point of trying to live an authentic life if you are an organ donor clone? Beats me. Maybe there is something inherent in us that makes us try.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I had to read Kazuo Ishiguro's "Remains of the Day", supposedly one of the best British post WWII novels, for the Cambridge Proficiency in English as a Foreign Language Oral Exam. Regarding your first three paragraphs, it seems that his writing style has actually improved! I don't think Ishiguro's main character (an English butler) managed to make a point in most chapters. I remember him droning on about his father's dignity (over 11 pages, no conclusion) or the "difficult" decision of whether or not to buy a new suit (8 pages, cannot remember if there was a conclusion to the butler's ramblings).
Have you considered that your intelligence, education and social values might also contribute to your feelings of not being "authentic" as your social environment should rightly be declared non-thinking (e.g. Obama is a Muslim Socialist Facist)? I would think it's more important to find out who you are and not how you are perceived by others...
Lots of love from your BigSis