Friday, February 11, 2011

"why yes, let us acquire a whole person and keep it"

If you've been paying attention in the last few years (and I won't fault you if you haven't), Madonna has adopted two children from Malawi. Unfortunately, these two children, David and Mercy, both have living and involved families. Apparently when Madonna descended on Malawi and found her perfect children she promised these families that they would have regular access to their children, and that their children would eventually return to Malawi once Madonna was done taking care of them. This is actually a common misconception among birth families; in Korea as well, families often don't see adoption to America as a permanent thing. They believe that their children are ultimately Korean and will, of course, return to them once they are done being raised in the land of opportunity. Similarly, they don't see placing a child in an orphanage as necessarily permanent; it's been considered a last resort when times get tough.

Mercy's impoverished family placed her in an orphanage when her mother died because they thought she would receive better care there for the first few years of her life, but they made regular visits to see her and planned to bring her home again when they were able. Unfortunately for everyone else involved, Madonna decided that she wanted Mercy, so she did whatever she wanted to keep her. Maybe Madonna was sincere about wanting to build a Malawian school. Maybe originally she intended to bring Mercy back for regular visits. But no matter what, she actually took a child from its living and involved family. Worse, she hasn't fulfilled her promises to that child or family.

Even if she paid that family a ton of money, and even if that family just wants more money now (it doesn't sound like it though), if Madonna were actually thinking about the best interests of Mercy she would have left her where she belonged, with the people she belonged to, and would have paid for her survival and education. (What happened to sponsoring a child? Apparently Madonna has to literally bring it home and put it in a box.) As a result this poor kid is going to be torn between loving the mother Madonna will be to her, and knowing that this beloved mother actually screwed over Mercy's original family. Also, the rest of the world is aware of all of this because it's Madonna, and Mercy will grow up knowing that her story weirds everyone else out. She is a charity case.

You could argue that because she is now with Madonna, Mercy will have everything a kid could want -and more- because Madonna can afford to take champagne baths and put diamonds in her yoga mat. But at the very simplest level this is a giant case of bullying and selfishness. Madonna knowingly took a child from its family. To accomplish this, she allowed them to operate under the misapprehension that Mercy was still "theirs" and would be coming back to them. None of her promises were in writing - a gaping hole for someone who's been in showbiz for many decades.

So sketchy. So sad for that little girl.

No comments: