Monday, February 22, 2010

yellow face, the play

- by David Henry Hwang, produced by the always thought-provoking Mu Performing Arts at the Guthrie.

It was awesome.

I can't wait until M. Butterfly arrives.

I went with a half-Chinese friend, and within the first 5 minutes the play had us both pegged. It was that good.

"Well maybe he doesn't have an Asian name because he has a white dad. Or maybe he's one of those... Korean adoptees."

Ha.

It was fast-paced, witty, and addressed some of the biggest themes in Asian-Americans' daily lives and as a movement, but without being preachy. It even came to some unorthodox conclusions that probably irked more than a few activists.

A note from David Henry Hwang:

The roots of this play go back to 1991 and the protests surrounding plans to bring the hit musical Miss Saigon from London to Broadway. When it was announced that the Welsh actor Jonathan Pryce would reprise his role of "The Engineer," a character of mixed Asian-Caucasian descent, some Asian Americans, including myself, protested this decision as an example of "yellow face" casting. The protestors, in turn, were denounced by most commentators as examples of political correctness run amok.

Nearly 20 years later, we continue to debate questions of minority or "blind" casting. I believe we are really struggling with two separate issues: employment and aesthetics. The employment argument seams clear to me. Despite the progress made by minority actors on our nation's screens and stages, we still do not live in a country where, say, James Earl Jones would be cast as George Washington. This would not reflect his lack of acting skills; rather, race still matters when actors go looking for work. So long as this remains the case, minority characters should be cast with minority actors; otherwise, where are these artists going to find employment?

The aesthetic issue, as with most artistic matters, is more complicated. In 1991 Brien Friel's Dancing at Lughnasa, a play set in Ireland, came to Broadway with its original Irish cast and became a hit; when the Irish actors' work permits expired, they were replaced by Americans. Some people felt the Irish cast was better, suggesting that there is sometimes value in hiring actors whose life experiences more closely mirror the characters they are portraying. On the other hand, New York's National Asian American Theater Company in 1998 mounted a revival of William Finn's and James Lapine's Falsettoland, with Asian actors playing straight and gay New York Jews, to great success. The Asian actors argued that these characters' experiences were much closer to their own than, say, portraying a Siamese slave girl in The King and I. Aesthetically, there is certainly room for healthy debate.

I believe that producers, directors and playwrights have the right to cast anyone they want. However, those who don't like their choices have the right to complain as loudly as they want. this strikes me as the best way to balance everyone's civil liberties as our American experiment moves forward.

Wonderful.

No comments: