Thursday, November 5, 2009

celibate advice

So occasionally I find myself sitting in mass (Catholic), not mouthing the words to the liturgy, and finding other things to think about.

First of all - why am I at mass? Because I like to sing. And no one sings in organized settings like devout Christians. Apparently a lot of gay men in the area had the same idea. So like I've said before it's the Christians and the gay men making music together. I fall into the gay man category.

While I'm sitting there I notice how crisp the linen over the wine chalice is and I wonder whether being tone deaf is a barrier to becoming a priest.

Then I remember that I should be listening, or that it's polite to pretend to listen and not let my eyes wander, and I tune into what the priest is saying. Generally it's something everyone can agree on, like the power of love and kindness and not being selfish and how tithing is necessary to keep the roof from leaking (even though no one wants to do it). But when priests start talking about relationships I can't hold a neutral expression.

Single chaste men have apparently been leaders and great influencers in world history. Whether or not they've done more good than harm is debatable. But if we were to look at the situation today just on its initial merits... Why would I ever listen to someone who's never been married tell me about the blessings and comforts of that relationship? Marriage advice from someone who's spent his life isolating himself from close familial relationships. Gee whiz. I recently attended a Catholic wedding with a 20-minute homily that included -I kid you not- the moonlit wedding scene from "Braveheart," the phrase "becoming one flesh," and lots of stories from the priest's childhood. (*But no tractors were involved, unlike the sermon at my wedding.)

Ridiculous. Priests may have some insight from having listened to married couples complain and rejoice over the years, but they have never actually experienced being married or having children (let's hope not). It's impossible for me to sit there and accept their authority without wrinkling my nose.

If you talk to God a lot? Sure, maybe I'll listen to you when it comes to world peace. The Catholics can learn about sinning. But anything about relationships might as well be Dick Cheney on the Oval Office intercom.

No comments: