Tuesday, May 26, 2009

justice, the

I realized, while listening to discussions about Obama's prospective Supreme Court nominees and then about Sonia Sotomayor herself, that the public has a very misplaced, or even cynical view of who the justices are and what they do.

"Is she liberal?" someone asked.

Ah. But that is the wrong question, my friend.

To assume that justices fall on either side of an political ideological divide not only insults their intelligence and impartiality, but it won't truly tell you how they'll rule on an issue that you care about. So you won't learn anything by requesting to see the label affixed to their foreheads.

What you want to know is how each arrives at her final decision. What is her process? Does she place more weight on history, precedent, or policy considerations, among other things?

Asking whether Sonia Sotomayor is liberal presupposes that she decides cases and then finds reasoning to support her finding. Result-oriented jurisprudence. Let's give her the benefit of the doubt and assume (until we know otherwise) that she uses the skills she gained in the Bronx, Princeton, Yale, and life to reason toward a finding that follows the reasoning. Let's expect that she is conscious of how she weighs the factors involved in each case, and of how her process differs from that of other judges who do rule differently.

To be fair, the media doesn't help. We hear the end results of issues - "Inmates Allowed To Wear Santeria Beads" - and not the stated reasoning behind them. But by no means let us presuppose that the highest court of our nation is really a cluster of result-oriented idealogues duking it out in self-interest.

No comments: