Tuesday, November 25, 2008

"Twilight" review

Three and a half stars out of 5. Because I'm grading it on "movie," not "story." I love the story, but the movie creators didn't come up with it. So any points I might have awarded for premise and knots are moot.

*** there are no spoilers in here (at least nothing you wouldn't have gotten from the previews) ***

Script: Unfortunately, Gothic literature doesn't transfer well to 21st century teenage moviedom, even if it does take place in a dark and emotive Pacific northwest. The books had the amazing ability to make me fall in love with falling in love, and their steep dive into angst and near-death drama didn't seem overly-wrought or moody. While they admittedly weren't the best books ever written, the characters and plot were well-developed. I think they balanced true love's issues nicely with honest and sweetly-funny characters. Gripping beach reading at the very worst. The movie, on the other hand, attempted to court book die-hards by keeping the memorable tag-lines while adding things that real teenagers might say. Imagine Cathy and Heathcliff uttering things like, "Text me," between, "I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!" The effect was that I wasn't allowed to wallow in Bella & Edward's stormy emotions (per the book) because I was constantly reminded that when/if I have children, they will be encouraged to skip years 13-17. The filmmakers should have just picked a genre.

Acting: Overall, decent. I mean, Kristen Stewart is just 18, so she has time to grow. I only wish that she would have shown Bella's sense of self-deprecating humor once in awhile. Kristen seemed pretty bitchy on occasion. And Robert Pattinson? Could have mellowed out a bit and shown the wisdom that 80 years of existence might bring to a guy, but I liked his face. It's too bad he had to cover up his British accent; he might have come out better if he'd either A) practiced more, or B) just gone limey. The actor who played Carlisle displayed the perfect combination of movie-star sparkle and solicitious doctor (who happens to drink blood).

Music: Come ON, Bella's lullaby is supposed to be pretty, not creepy! And what's with all the metallic instrumentation in the background? Sometimes you can't improve on simple piano. I was really looking forward to hearing this, and I am sorely disappointed. The rest of the soundtrack is good, though, even the two songs sung by Robert Pattinson. Serious actors can sing? Sorry Gwyneth, you must share your niche.

Cinematography: Well, you can't much improve on the Pacific northwest. They probably could have filmed Garrison Keillor sitting in poison ivy there and audiences would have commented on how green everything was, and how he almost looks attractive surrounded by mountains and moss. Almost. But I appreciated all the rainy, wet, and cold vibes I got from the filters on lush scenery, and the grizzled, blue collar, and outdoorsy ones I got from the people shots.

Costume: Bella needs to be lumpier. Sorry, folks. And Edward needs to be more Banana Republic, less J. Crew. What happened to his cream sweaters and khakis? I was looking forward to putting DearlyBeloved in a similar getup if it worked for Robert Pattinson on-screen.

Overall, it was hard for me to watch it like a normal viewer would because I've read the books 4 times (each) and I can't let go of the characters in my head and my favorite parts of their journey. So half my brain dissected and made comparisons, and the other half tried to pretend it didn't belong to me so it could enjoy the story in peace.

In the end? You should see it, but don't feel guilty about waiting for it on DVD/Blu-Ray. Bonus for waiting: you can watch it in the comfort of your own home, which I assume doesn't include 100 teenage screamers encountering their first blood-sucking heartthrob.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

saw the movie, and THEN read the book. hopelessly addicted.
~kj~