Sunday, November 9, 2008

alone

I''ve said this before, but you know how when you read a book, or hear an amazing speaker, and you are absolutely startled at how clear something becomes? Like an "Oh, but of course!" moment. This used to happen to me when I first read C.S. Lewis. He's one of the best writers out there, and not just for his ideas or mastery of words you only encounter once in a blue moon. No, he's an incredible writer because he's so dang clear. Lewis leads you through insightful and sometimes complicated theological concepts so easily that you feel like you navigated them yourself and arrived at your own conclusion.

"He's not a tame lion."

If I have any literary gift, it lies in articulating what bothers me and why. Not quite as nice as Lewis'. But still useful, in its own way, except for those instances when I don't want to be the one expressing what bothers me. Or when I haven't had enough life experience to frame it correctly.

I have empathy for those who are afflicted but who cannot self-remedy because they can't clearly communicate what is wrong and how to change it. That's a frustrating experience. Sometimes I hear dreadful remarks but can't quite explain to the speaker's satisfaction just what, precisely, is wrong. My ineptitude enables repeat-offenders.

Which is why I am frustrated to the point of exhaustion that A) there aren't more professors of color around here, and B) there aren't more progressive professors. Sounds funny, I know, but I would give almost anything [out of my locker] to hear eloquent legal academicians disagree about socio-cultural jurisprudence. I'm not well-equipped enough to do it myself. I can't handle my classmates and my conservative professors without help. I'm a fledgling.

I need intellectual support from people who share my life experiences (and who've been through more than 25 years of them). Unfortunately, it appears that those people didn't go to law school.

That professor in class with the blatantly racist student? Didn't say anything. He should've cut her off before she continued her accusations, when none of my fellow students raised their hands and disagreed with her. But he's a 70-year-old white man in academia who has no idea how to manage racist idiots. Somehow he's avoided dealing with the issue straight on. He went to law school before the Civil Rights Act, when women and students of color were considered charity cases if they were let in at all.

So even though I'm sure he disagreed with WhiteRobes, he didn't know that the right thing to do was challenge her presumption. He should have stood up for himself and the sake of reason, and if not that, for the targeted students subdued into silence by such hate.

6 comments:

KathleenKMM said...

I am coming out of lurkdom to say that I went to your school (one of the "benevolent 3Ls" of last year told me about your blog) and this was a problem when I was there too. Please be vocal about it to the administration, it's the only way things will every change and it might mean more coming from someone who isn't a 23 year-old white girl which is what I was when I was there.

1234 said...

thank you - i have brought it up to a few members of the administration and i think they're trying to work on things, but there are also unavoidable outside factors at play. for instance, minority professors are few and far between. professors tend to come from top 10 law schools, and of people old enough and with distinguished enough careers to be professors, few of them are anything but white, and probably male. the school needs to decide that its national rankings don't matter as much as recruiting professors with real experience (and those professors need to decide to come here, which is another story).

i think that having fellow not-as-brown students take a stand on what they're looking for helps immensely. this is an everyone-issue.

KathleenKMM said...

Are you planning on doing clinic at all? I did it my very last semester and it left me with a much more positive feeling about the school than I had otherwise. I can't say it undid some of the things I found frustrating (like people screaming about how "only minorities and rich kids get scholarships!" when I was neither and had one) but it reaffirmed that I did go to school with more than a few decent human beings.

1234 said...

yes, i am planning to do clinic. i'm excited about working with a majority of progressive students (and the real experience).

i should say that i don't dislike most of the students in my class; my "quality of life" is quite excellent as law schools go. i am just frequently appalled that such otherwise well-meaning people have awful views or reactions to certain things. law students aren't exactly a cross-section of american society; they're supposed to be the best and brightest, and if stupid things are coming out of their mouths on a regular basis then we have further to go than i'd like to imagine.

(and as is probably normal, the thought of several fellow students becoming lawyers IS appalling.)

my post speaks more toward the alienation that the law school system, in all its historically-based flaws, forces me to experience if i choose to be a lawyer.

one uttered hateful sentence is enough to send me crawling back into a shell of safety, sad that people who are my friends don't also experience the same pain or understand that it exists. incidents like the previous draw my differences to my attention and make me feel targeted even when there are like-minded individuals around me.

Eric said...

strange about the prof thing. going through my degree i had the opposite experience. well ok, not so much the "color" issue but i certainly had a very diverse mix of profs for all of my degree classes.

1234 said...

i'm guessing you might not have had lawyers with national reputations teaching undergrad, though. :( all of the ranked ones tend to flock to institutions of either A) high ranking, or B) similar worldviews, because they have a choice. or both, i suppose.