I keep running into Asian-Americans who insist they're white, or at least that they're "not very Asian at all." They say I seem "really into" being Asian. Some of them say this with a little bit of guilt, like they're ditching their responsibilities and I'm catching them in the act. Others honestly don't see any connection between themselves and the identity: Asian.All of this frustrates me for a reason that might surprise you - I'm not interested in convincing every ethnically Asian person here that she needs to get in touch with her roots and eat more rice. I'm not looking to inspire rage or a sudden fascination with mother countries. What really, really bothers me is that all of these people who look Asian are carrying around a burden that the majority white group never has to consider.
How often do you wonder, "How white am I? Should I be more white? Less?"
Maybe if you're Irish you make an effort to buy your significant other claddagh jewelry on holidays, but as of late it's gotten pretty fashionable to think about one's European ancestors, so I wouldn't consider it a burden.
Asian-Americans have been benched as non-American since they first began immigrating. The NAACP struggles with the multiple backgrounds of its members who are descendants of slaves, recent immigrants from African countries, and immigrants from the Caribbean and Latin America. But the greater American community sees them all as "black" and lumps their issues together. Asians are similarly lumped together, except they don't have that "American by default" category to pull them in to be included in the American identity. "Go back to China" doesn't work very well when your Chinese ancestors were here before your German ones were. Yet it is the Chinese part that is singled out for the "other" label.
Asian-Americans struggle with conflicting desires to fit in while simultaneously acknowledging that the specific and categorizable way we look determines how many strangers will react to us. Some of my friends, feeling excluded from an all-American identity, seek refuge in their Asian background and only hang out with fellow Asians, eat lots of Asian food, and listen to music from their ancestral countries. Others run in the opposite direction. I hear Asian-American friends earnestly describe themselves as bananas and twinkies in an attempt to explain why they don't speak a foreign language and why they like football. Some of them have stayed away from traditional "Asian" interests (and even Asian acquaintances) to show others that they are just typical Americans.
A lot of these non-Asian Asians grew up in areas with distinguishable Asian populations, so they had more reason to go running. I grew up with a number of adoptees in an enormous group of rural white Minnesotans, so I believe I had more power of self-determination than did my urban counterparts. No one my age in my area knew anything about Asians outside the whole bowing, scraping and slanty-eyed bit, so I could have told my classmates that Asians wore yellow on Tuesdays and they would've believed me. I was just "different;" I was lucky enough not to have "different" defined for me.
I get annoyed when people write off my knowledge about race issues (and Korean culture), assuming that I just inherently have a good grasp because I'm Korean. In all actuality, I've sought out the info because A) everyone expects me to know it, and B) my experience as a Korean-American directs my interest. Imagine feeling pressure to know what Asians are supposed to do so that you can decide whether or not you will be Asian. Asian-Americans are forced to develop an automatic sense for whether something is considered "Asian" or not. And they know whether they're doing it.
I hate this burden. I want to tell every Asian-American out there that whoever they are, and whatever they happen to be doing IS Asian-American. If they're eating sushi and playing violin, they're being Asian-American. If they love lutefisk and English literature, they're being Asian-American. They're being American. No one ever tells Irish-Americans who love burritos and French wine that they're being anything but American, and being themselves.
Stop feeling the pressure, Asians. Just be. And be aware that You. Are. American. Stop trying to run away from yourselves.
3 comments:
amazing!
Meow--
Brava, brava!!! Thank you for writing such a thoughtful post. While I am in the "white" catagory I have often felt differnt. Thanks for putting a voice to my feelings!
fuck I think I had an epiphery. I really appreciate your articulation on this matter because I am usually just shocked and at loss of words when I hear these from asians.
Side Notes:
sometimes I feel like Im reading a text book kitty.
Im moving to the twin cities by feb or march. CO counselors need to reunite.
Post a Comment