Thursday, August 14, 2008

same old

Excuse me? "In a generation, minorities may be the U.S. majority?"

Let that sink in.

Maybe read the article. It's interesting.

But then consider that it's completely absurd to group all minorities together against (note the word of fear) whites for mere counting purposes. Why don't demographers combine hispanics with whites? Hispanics are part white. Or trend-wise, why don't they group asians with whites? Their demographic issues are often parallel. The demographers are also running into the same old "hmm are Middle Easterners white?" problem.

Their current threat is like saying that in a generation of deciduous trees, the now dominant quaking aspen may be the Minnesotan minority. Maybe that's why it's quaking. It feels threatened. But if you split up the balsam fir, the black spruce, the paper birch, and the black ash into their own minority tree groups, each variety on its own still won't outnumber the quaking aspen. And how do you count other willows like the Japanese aspen or the Swedish aspen?

Ridiculous. Why don't they call it "evening out?" The United States is not an ethnicity; it's a citizenship. And currently the demographics of our citizenship are heading toward matching the numbers of the rest of the world, of whom we are comprised.

The white subconscious is possibly more paranoid than me.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well said! What a terrible article; it seemed written only to promote fear mongering and typical xenophobia. The good news, though, is that Asians apparently now make up a whole 9% of the population! We're up on the up and up, it seems. Watch out America, we're taking over!

B said...

Hey! Good post. I read that article in the paper yesterday, and it bugged the crap out of me, mainly because (in a typically American way) it has no historical context. First of all, "white" is not really an ethnicity. It's more of a label for the group of people who maintain rights and privileges over other people, at the expense of other people. Secondly, the definition of "white" is always changing. Two hundred years ago, Irish people were not considered "white," but now they are. A hundred years ago, Jews were not considered "white," but now they are. And I bet that fifty years from now, Hispanics/Latinos will start being considered "white," being that the label Hispanic/Latino is more about a shared cultural history than any color of the skin.

Also, thanks for the shout-out to my favorite tree!! As always, love your posts.