Wednesday, April 2, 2008

email from LegalWritingProf

This morning I also caught a mistake in the assignment instructions - a mistake that might affect your formatting - so I'm writing to bring this to your attention and to tell you how I've decided to address it. It has to do with page margins.

Some readers prefer to receive documents with margins that are uniformly one-inch margins, all around. I wanted to give you a little more freedom than that, so when I wrote the assignment instructions, I intended to allow you to set your margins anywhere within a range that was at least 1 inch and not more than 1.5 inches.
Unfortunately, this morning I noticed that the instructions actually say that "margins should be between one and one-half inches". Now, *I* know what I meant to say (between 1 and 1.5), and *you* know what I meant to say (same thing). But a strict textualist would say that the sentence says you can set your margins not between 1 and 1.5 inches, but between 0.5 and 1. And, technically, they'd be right. Yes, this is an inadvertent lesson in the power of proofreading, not to mention the canons of statutory construction.

Under the circumstances, and since the mistake was mine and mine alone, and since it's *possible* that *someone* may have relied on it, I've decided to allow any margins that conform with either of the two possible readings of the sentence - both the "rule of reason" (which is what I meant to do) and the strict literal reading. Bottom line: you can set your margins anywhere between 0.5 inches and 1.5 inches. Anything within that range will be considered in conformity with the assignment instructions.

Considering the fact that I have been struggling for the last week to *have* a brief, this is fairly entertaining. I love LegalWritingProf. In fact, I want to be just like him when I grow up. But if he thinks we are anywhere near the "where do I set my margins?" point, he might not want to know that a classmate of mine just began his paper last night.

Going to put Bailey's in my coffee tomorrow morning.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

ahahahahahaa! Your legal writing prof sounds like a character! Good luck on your brief!