Sunday, March 2, 2008

meow spends time in juvie

I used to be addicted to the ABC show, "Grey's Anatomy." I don't have time to watch anymore, but one thing I always found compelling was that the medical interns were taught to treat bizarre ailments as people. Or rather, the interns were taught to treat the people with bizarre ailments as people.

One of my professors gave a lecture on client-interviewing skills and told us over and over again that it takes more than analytical mind and legal knowledge to be a good lawyer.

"When potential clients come to you for help," he said, "only a small part of their problem will be legal." There is a whole bigger picture there outside the legally relevant fact pattern. "The person coming to you will have emotional issues, will have more at stake than just her money, and doesn't just want a brief answer and dismissal." A client is more than the fact pattern she lives.

I ran into this head-first when I spent an afternoon with a public defender. (Even though I'm working in private practice this summer, I'm still interested in public interest so I called a defender in juvenile court to see if I could tag along.)

The woman had an absolutely enormous caseload and yet she still took the time to sit with each of her young clients and explain what was happening, what their choices were, and what she could do for them. So much of her job is socialworking. It was like watching good parenting. She let each of her juvenile offenders know that no matter what she was their advocate, but it was up to them to make good choices in the future and if they didn't, there were certainly penalties they'd have to accept. She was incredibly clear, honest, and precise, and yet her compassion and humor were readily apparent.

"How do you do it?" I asked. "How do you keep them all straight, and keep yourself from burning out?" The way she worked you'd think she was paid $100/hour.

"It's the ones who don't come back that keep me going," she said. "If they don't come back, it means they made it ok."

That afternoon one of her cases was a young man who'd brought alcohol on a snowmobiling excursion. Not only was he under 21, he was under 18, and his snowmobiling companion died that day.

I looked at his file and noted that he'd been in for minor offenses several times before. No photo, but a signature, and several exchanges in communication. A sad fact pattern similar to several in my casebook. Luckily for him he was under 18 and chances were if he accepted adjudication the system would track him until he was 19 and hopefully he'd be rehabilitated by then after community service and counseling and fines. Processes, processes.

Then he arrived, morose, with his two exhausted and irate parents, just ahead of the victim's grandparents, who were carrying a photo of their only grandson. The group sat together, silent, waiting to go before the judge.

We pulled the defendant into a conference room and discussed the acceptability of the prosecution and probation officers' recommendations for sentencing. He was entirely penitent and depressed, and almost beside himself.

He was so much more than the fact pattern in his file, or the fact patterns in my casebook.

He didn't argue about any portion of his sentence. Somehow, he was going to have to deal with the loss of his friend, his guilt, the victim's family, and his deeper relationship with the juvenile justice system all at once.

It's hard to see that from inside my classroom, where we'd argue and compare things like, "Well what if they found the alcohol in the ditch but he picked it up?" or "What if his friend merely lost a leg?" But in person, the ramifications are enormous. These are real people's lives, and they go on living long after their particular legal case ends.

"A good lawyer doesn't solve problems," my professor said. "A good lawyer helps people."

1 comment:

The Wrangler said...

Great post. I'm a little ashamed of telling lawyer jokes. Keep up the good work. I'll probably need a sensitive lawyer one day.