Tuesday, October 16, 2007

wiggle room

I think I might be a humanistic facist.

I have a military commander sitting on one shoulder and groovy Jesus on the other.

I like things that are nice and neat. I am most happy when I encounter situations that fit neatly into my plan of operation and I can think, "Boy, everything's running so efficiently!" Causes and effects are plainly seen and accounted for.

But I also have a side that knows that polarizing and compartmentalizing are scary and Jesus loves all the little children and welfare may be messed up but what else are we going to do? "Just chill out, man. We're all part of a bigger picture."

We were presented this problem in class:

You're an Army general and have just gotten news that a battle didn't go so well and there are injured soldiers stuck in a tough position with enemy fighters steadily moving in. Military policy is "leave no one behind." Even if they're already dead. Do you send in a helicopter, knowing that a rescue team's chance of survival is minimal? It's like "Saving Private Ryan" meets "We Were Soldiers." What would Tom Hanks do?

I wanted to know the exact chances of survival for the members of the rescue team and the exact chances of survival for the injured on the ground. There was no reason to be ideologically warm and fluffy here. "Leave no bodies behind!" Sure, the families of the fallen deserve to bury their loved ones, but wouldn't they prefer that others' loved ones survived if it came to a trade-off?

I was very utilitarian about it. If 10 rescuers had a predicted 90% mortality rate for retrieving 5 injured soldiers and 2 deceased ones, I would not send them in. If 10 rescuers had a predicted 10% mortality rate for retrieving the same 7 I would send them in. I'm going to assume that all human life is equal here (my humanist side talking) - if that's the case, and there's a 50% predicted mortality rate for the rescuers, I'd send in fewer rescuers up to the point where they could still get the job done. It feels crass to assign percentages of worth to human life, but to me it would be even worse to act without considering it.

In other words: I would have left Private Ryan out there. Tough luck Matt Damon, but there were schoolchildren in PA who needed Tom Hanks to come home and teach them.

Would that make groovy Jesus sad?

4 comments:

Adam said...

But Meow, life is so simple! Why do you burden yourself with such thoughts?

1234 said...

maybe i've been spending too much time in the litterbox...

Eric said...

"assign percentages to human life" is exactly what the insurance industry does. business is good these days. bleh

Anonymous said...

Dear Meow,
You've presented a hypothetical "If...Then..." scenario. I would like to spotlight our differences through my own criticism of your self-proclaimed utilitarian perspective (based off the information you've provided in the exercise, I will assume the same assumption that I feel your response was garnered under: the impression that you're the General of the U.S. Army/another very powerful, wealthy, expertly trained, advanced army):


-Since you attempted to rationalize from a utilitarian perspective, I am curious to know the boundaries of your scope. Your response was presented in a nice tiny level of involvement (10 rescuers and 7 rescuees) and the relative percentages. I'll play by your numbers for a moment;
what if the mortality rate was 20% for the Extraction team? 25%? what about 45%---it's still under your 50%. Just how many people are you willing to sacrifice in the process of saving 5 lives? Your answer allowed you to hide behind percentages and be indefinite.

What if the number of trapped soldiers from your apparent "battle-gone-wrong" was higher--what if it was 30; and realistically this would be the case if in fact the battle had gone wrong [and there would also likely be a much Higher number of KIA (not 2) soldiers]. I present this question because while in theory your percentages stay the same, your cumulative death toll increases GREATLY.

Most of my discomfort with your answer comes from my perspective that you gave little effort or attempt to "preserve the question."

Why does the Extraction group have to be so small? Why send in "a" helicopter? (singular) Why not send in 5 with a squadron of F-16's and make use of some long range satellite G.P.S. guided missiles to inflict high-quantity-high-percentage enemy casualties, and possibly buy yourself valuable time for an Extraction team of whatever size to enter the DZ and retreat back to the Safe Zone? (They've got lots of soldiers in the area, then use bigger guns/arsenal to even the playing field by eliminating/minimizing your opponents' advantages).

Argument:
-Why did you assume you had to send in actual human lives....why not offer the possibility of using robotic, computer/micro chip controlled objects (helicopters, armored vehicles, etc) for the Extraction?


*You are too bright to simply give in, and allow X amount of people to die. Give me back my hopeful, question preserving, all-possibilities seen and unseen considering, creatively imaginative, bold and radically challenging Meow. Because I know there's a Meow that exists, who wouldn't listen to "Lose-Lose" scenarios or reports of "it can't be done" nature. Give me back the Meow that refuses to play by and follow "shitty uncompromising rules/guidelines" (like those offered in this scenario) and instead boldly defies the taboo in order to create newness, wonder, and progressive solutions.