Wednesday, August 15, 2007

spilling onto the next post


All of this, of course, begs the question as to why we punish people in the first place.




Why do we punish children? Or corporate leaders who siphon money from their shareholders? How about rapists?

Does punishment create remorse over the initial misdeed? (Would that effect do anyone any good?) Or does jail time (also known as "time outs" or "grounding") simply keep evildoers away from a vulnerable society?

Why do we give a death sentence to those who kill others?

3 comments:

The Wrangler said...

Doesn't Justice have a cosmic aspect. That is, don't we have to have concern not just with curing a criminal and restoring the victim, but with what God might think of what has been done. I am reminded of the soil crying out after the blood of Abel seeps into it. Our actions have repercussions for the whole of creation. This leads to the idea of environmental justice (global warming and such), but is not limited to it.

The Wrangler said...

I neglected to put question marks in. Freudian slip!

Benjamin said...

Reform, contrition and rehabilitation are all things that we'd like to see come out of punishment. Obviously these are not very forthcoming in our American system. The problems are too deep-rooted and the solutions are too shallow.

Punishment in general - be it of a child who hit his sister or a man who killed his wife - is, I suppose, meant to convey that consequences have actions. It is meant to convey that freedom has limits and that certain uses of freedom will lead, paradoxically, to captivity. How this all works out in practice though is messy.