Does anyone else think it's strange that when we meet someone we ask, "So what do you do?"I understand that if we spend 40+ hours a week doing something, others can look at our choice to spend that large chunk of time doing a specific thing to categorize and measure us by that specific thing. But it's started to bother me lately.
When I picked a major in college I didn't realize that I'd be barraged with this question for the rest of my life. If I'd known I would have picked something easy like, "teacher" or "nun." (Just kidding... not nun.) But I wasn't smart and every single thing I studied required an explanation. Theology? ("Worldviews are fascinating.") Philosophy? ("Um...I thought it would be good for me.") Justice and Peace Studies? ("I want to learn about how the world works.") Renaissance Program? ("It's actually mostly business and economics courses... for the trade impaired.")
But now that I have "law school" to provide as an answer, the response I receive is, "Oh! How wonderful!" No questions other than, "What type of lawyer?" (Even though I hate that question too. I have no idea. Being a lawyer was almost an afterthought to going to law school.) It almost bothers me more to be so easily categorizable now. Why is "lawyer" an identity? If I were poor and lacked resources/support for a good education, would "janitor" be my identity?
Having worked in so many different positions -some with power, some without- I have experienced several vastly varying identities in a short amount of time. And these are identities placed on me by others who encounter me; I haven't changed much. Retail shoe girl, waitress, volunteer coordinator, human resources for pilots, toilet scrubber/bed-maker, information desk attendant, tour guide... can you imagine the different treatment I received at all of these? People make so many assumptions about your lifestyle from one thing: what you do for 40 hours a week.
What about the other 128 hours in the week? What about your volunteer service, your family, the books you read? What about your political affiliation? Your faith?
When I worked at an information desk in college I became friends with a "building service worker," code for "janitor." He'd mop around my desk and then resume a year-long conversation about music and Barbara Ehrenreich (he thought she was schpeemy) and Catholicism. After months of conversation I gradually learned that he'd once been a music producer in California; after retiring he moved back to MN and decided to occupy himself in a job with absolutely no respect. Why? I have no idea. I do know that most of the students who walk by him each day on their way to class are not as intelligent nor as educated as him. But they don't know that of course. Nor do they treat him as such.
If others categorized me by what I would prefer to do for 63 hours a week they would find me extremely lazy. If I had that much time to sleep I would.
I guess what I'm saying is that receiving undue respect for applying to law school rubs my fur the wrong way after having scraped and scrounged for any trace of respect during my not-so-prestigious occupations. I'm still the same person. I've always liked fresh air and Mozart and rosehip tea.
The ancient Greeks considered one's occupation merely that- a source of sustainment to keep oneself alive that occupied a certain amount of one's time. One's true identity was one's public persona. An identity of thoughts and speech and action. I suppose there's no real public forum for expressing this identity any more. We don't take the time to wonder if our garbage person is a mechanical wizard a la "Dilbert," or if our waitress has a Ph.D in biology (Barbara Ehrenreich).
I think we all need to remember that we are more than what we "do" to keep ourselves alive. If you are one of the lucky ones whose profession is actually your true calling: I am incredibly jealous. I hope to be you someday.
5 comments:
It's not about what you do that defines who you are, but people all need a starting point as to how to identify people they've only just met and probably won't remember their names anyways. I would like to think it's more about accepting the stereotypes because they provide structure but not having to conform to them.
Try being tall. At least people get as far as asking you "What do you do." I am lucky to get past the whole basketball portion.
I have learned to accept and enjoy the questions (the same ones at least four times per day).
what is your true calling?
The lesson here is that small talk is boring.
Small talk 101:
Where are you from?
What do you do?
How about this weather?
:: awkward silence ::
Post a Comment