
I was at a party last Friday evening when DoxDuck, one of BeardedOne's many interesting friends, began a conversation with me about... well I don't quite remember who began it. But it was about Unitarian Universalists and "how it all works." We also discussed Buddhism. But it got me thinking about UUism again as I found myself engaging in quite determined apologetics.
I've considered myself somewhat "UU" for awhile although at the time of conversation I hadn't gone to a service yet. Har har. Is that possible? Were I a Christian in the same situation it would not be, undoubtedly. But let us begin here, where I can explain what I understand of it so far... I'll probably revise myself in the future.
As I should. (dot...dot...dot...)
Unitarian Universalism is often accused of being relativist, and what people really mean when they say that is, "You think everything's all fine and dandy where everyone is right and no one's wrong and we might as well just declare ourselves anarchists, or pot-smoking hippies in yurts at the very least." Which leads to: "Dangnabbit, if everyone is right, then no one is right." It's a catchy accusation. It sounds nice.
But if you really want to point fingers at illogical faith traditions
with doctrine, let's take a closer look at non-denominational and extreme evangelical Christian churches. Many engage preachers with little religious (or any, for that matter) education who one day felt "the call" to prosetylize / teach others and so got themselves a pulpit and began willing their personal beliefs on unsuspecting laypeople. I have been to quite a few services that even included a number of factual abuses of biblical text (which I internally corrected as a 14-year-old after having read the Children's Picture Bible). But mostly, religious teachings are derived haphazardly (even if they get the names and dates straight) from this ancient book in a way that no scholar would ever legitimize. Depending on your preacher's favorite chapters in Leviticus, you get an entirely different view of what being a member of the Judeo-Christian tradition means. It's not non-denominational. It's "Church of Bob's beliefs on Jesus," and "Temple of JC via Randy's mother Sharon, because Randy believed everything his mother ever taught him about God and he's our preacher." Your average Christian constituent is most definitely not equipped with enough information to filter what she hears from "Karl's Kiosk o' Christ."
"What it means to me" can only go so far when the fate of the world is in question. It's fine if you want to live in a cave and subside on wild honey and locusts. But the day you start sharing your visions, you'd better have had some real ones.
An association of individuals within an association of churches (UU's structure) who shy away from creating doctrine sounds dangerously similar, but it is not in the slightest. First of all, let me point out that UU churches don't even pretend to have doctrine. The fact that they don't have a specific set of inclusive/exclusive, us/them beliefs is highly publicized so that in no way will you ever be led to believe that you are receiving the full and only or even best truth anywhere. They encourage you to keep looking. They shy away from a consensus on belief.
Unitarians are fundamentally committed to "preserving the question," as my childhood pastor put it. In other words, if you feel like you know enough to be ok, or survive, or go to heaven... you should be very afraid. The very idea of having it all sorted out is incredibly absurd, conceited even. There
is a right and wrong and we should always be in search of truth. We'll never know everything, but as Thomas Jefferson believed, we'll definitely get further by trying [to know than by sitting on our arses in despair or complacency]. I think he said it better, but you get my point.
They believe that discussion and logic and science and technology are tools to be used in this search for truth. My starting premise is that what happens in this life does matter and humans have a great potential for good. My primary mode of discernment has to do with logically sorting information- be it data, emotion, experience, or anything else. I understand the world through logic. I cannot understand it through an individually-interpreted ancient text. I tried to understand it through scholarly (historical, literary, cultural, etc.) readings of that ancient text. But then I found that while there was great truth inherent in it, my primary mode of operation was still via coherent logic. There was no escaping it.
"I will believe anything of which you can convince me." -me. Not only that, I am actually convincable if you use the right ingredients.
Awhile ago I read a short booklet on UU and was frustrated with its elusiveness. "But what can I firmly say UU stands for?" I asked. How do I explain it without sounding like a freak to my censorous Catholic friends? Then I realized that this dilemma was precisely its beauty- UU preserves the question. It stands for the presentation of all perspectives as they can be represented and withheld within the realm of discussion and reason. UU has no easy answers, nor a line in the sand that distinguishes a UU belief from another, or a true adherent from one who has "not found the light." That would be too easy. UU is an attitude, an approach, a constant journey on which the traveler must be ever present of mind (and heart). Why do they organize and meet, you ask? To share, discuss, disagree, learn, and help one another toward the desired end- gaining truth and justice.
Everything is
not fine and dandy, as accused. There is right and wrong, and much of both can be found in today's world religions.
It seems very weak to me to believe (or need to believe) that your primary question has been answered, that there is no question. Or that you know exactly what the question is. We can only know as much as we know and to assume you know even just enough (Jesus loves me) to be saved or worthy of existing or anything else is to be incredibly self-satisfied.
More to come.