MotherDearest and I were discussing raising adopted children. Specifically, from Korea. When she and FatherDearest got me, the people at the agency told them that Korean children were "a certain way," naturally, because they were Korean. So we needed to be raised a certain way. What certain way was this?
"What, like we needed to be hit on the butt 4 times before we pooed?" I asked. "We're not made differently."
"No, but maybe your nature is different. You tell me," MotherDearest said.
"It's not," I said definitively.
"But Han Sook told us that it was."
I wrinkled my nose. "What does Han Sook know? She's
Korean."
MotherDearest looked surprised. Like she could toss her hands up in exasperation. "Then there's no one to ask!" I realized that so many adoptive parents rely on advice simply because it is given by someone who knows a teeny bit more than them; and sometimes that teeny bit isn't even valid - it's merely on account of race. But what do adult immigrants to this country know about the experience of infant immigrants raised by white parents? Han Sook might as well have been giving an academic class on what Koreans in Korea believe about themselves. It would be interesting, but unfortunately, it wouldn't help me get out of therapy any faster.
At the time, I agreed and said, "Right. So we should just see ourselves as screwed to begin with and work with that." (I still think this.) But almost immediately afterward I realized what was missing. It's the same thing that is missing from the media, from children's books, and from many adoption agencies. Adult adoptee voices.
But what do we know? The color of our skin coupled with our names marks us as
someone's children. Always. We aren't adults in our own right. The identity of an "adoptee" necessarily includes that of "child." We're permanently infantilized by our status. This is why white parents at Korean camps always assume control of any conversation they have with me; I look Korean; I must be someone's
child.
Adult Korean adoptees existed when I arrived; no one thought to ask them, however. I think things have changed since then, but they certainly haven't changed enough.
And I guess I never finished my answer to MotherDearest. There is no right "way" to "treat" Korean adoptee children when you get them. We are not a math problem to solve via certain methods. The only effective place to do things "right" is by changing the parents themselves, because ultimately who parents are is what affects children the most. If parents are aware of what their children will face when they leave the safe nests they've created for them, and if parents are aware that all their children will know about their countries of birth during their formative years are the impressions that the parents give them, those parents will be sure to become the most accurate carriers of that information that they are capable of being. And while there is no way for white parents to model what it is to be an adult of their children's race, they can interact with adults of that race and/or culture so that when the children are expected to do the same as adults, they won't feel like they're jumping into cold water.