Another example that I've been here too long:
At dinner this week I overheard two classmates discussing an accident where a truck driver in a residential area drove over a pile of paper bags in the street, unknowingly crushing a small boy underneath.
The driver was found to be negligent and thus, liable.
My first question was, "How old was the boy? Was he contributorily negligent? I mean, who plays under bags in the middle of the street?" If he was too young to know any better, he could be held to a subjective standard of care, rather than the standard applied to the "reasonable, prudent person" who doesn't frolic under paper products in main thoroughfares.
I consulted my class outline.
Under a strict liability standard, the driver would be held accountable whether or not he showed proper precautions. Harm done = damages owed. Under a negligence standard, liability is up for grabs. The plaintiff (probably the boy's family) must show that the truck driver had a
duty, which he
breached,
causing the
harm.
Since the truck driver undoubtedly caused the harm (squashing), the real issue is whether the driver breached a duty. What is the applicable standard of care when one sees paper bags in the middle of the street? Personally, I think anything in the middle of the street is up for target practice as long as it is not (A) running away in terror, (B) young/stupid, or (C) recognizably valuable. But apparently the court disagrees with me, holding that the driver should have checked underneath the bags. He breached his duty; he is liable. Tough luck, truck driver.
We could ask ourselves whether it is an industry custom to run over bags in the street. However, that wouldn't hold up very well in court.
How about a Calculus of Risk analysis, using the equation given to us by the esteemed Judge
Learned Hand? (*Side note: This guy actually had a cousin named "Noble Hand." Strange family.) If the
Loss x the
Probability of Loss is greater than the
Burden of preventing it, the truck driver is negligent. How much time (money) would be lost if all truck drivers in that company got out to look under all the paper bags they saw? Would the amount gained by running over bags outweigh the loss of the occasional child underneath? Deliveries per hour versus children, people. Make your choice.
Let us examine the conduct of the decedent. If the deceased was, say, 10 years of age or older, he should have known that playing in the street was dangerous. He did not take reasonable care, even that of a subjective standard given to children. He assumed the risk: what happens in streets but that cars drive through? Under a contributory negligence standard, his family would not be able to recover damages. However, if we use the comparative negligence method for assigning damages owed, the court could assess percentages of liability for both the driver and the child (and perhaps a third party - whoever should have been watching the child).
And then I realized that I had a soul and felt bad for the decedent.
Torts midterm soon. Augghhhh!!
The end.