I have started a two-week trial at Lifetime Fitness in St. Louis Park. More on that later. My main point is that it is a haul and a half into the boonies - not just exhibited by the odometer on my car, but by the sorts of people I run into.
Lifetime Fitness in St. Louis Park is so popular that they have a shuttle running back and forth from another parking lot for members who don't get a spot in their main lot. I was one of those unluckies on this particular occasion, and so was a 40-year-old white guy in an orange ski cap and jeans. So he likes to hunt. Whatever.
He stared for awhile and then asked, "Are you Chinese?"
"No." I waited, hoping he wouldn't take that as an invitation to keep guessing. Wrong. They always think I want them to guess, instead of reassessing and realizing that I just want them to leave me alone.
"Taiwanese?" He scrutinized my features pretty hard.
"No."
"Korean." Damn. I had to say yes.
"Yep."
He nodded. "Thought so. You have a big chin."
(!?)
He continued, "That's too bad. I don't speak Korean."
You don't seem to be doing very well in English either.
I wanted to get him off my back, but since we were the only ones in the parking lot and I didn't want to end up stuffed in his trunk I was polite. "Are you German?"
He gave me a strange look. "No, I'm Norwegian." Then he continued, "You're an immigrant then, huh?"
Damn. "Yep."
"Naturalized?"
"Yep."
"Do your parents speak English?"
"Yep."
"Huh. That's good." He nodded. "You speak Korean?"
"No."
"Why don't you speak Korean then?"
I couldn't figure out if he was actually an idiot, or dangerous, or both. I kept playing it safe. Keep him talking until the shuttle comes. "Do you speak Norwegian?"
"Huh. Of course not!" He gave me an annoyed look, like I was missing something.
"I do," I said. The shuttle was here. I gave up. "
Ga drite buksa."
"I'll have to look that up," he said.
"You do that," I said.
We got on the shuttle and he continued to pester me with questions.
"You like to play
ping pong?" he asked.
"No."
"You seem to give slippery answers," he frowned. "I think that's a woman thing."
No, it's a leave me alone thing. Jerk.
At that point I got off the shuttle and ran away. I have a theory. You might not like it.
My theory is that what really stupid people think is actually the underlying mindset that everyone else starts out with. Including you and me both. How did I arrive at this theory?
For starters, I think we can all agree that he is stupid. Very stupid. We can also all agree that stupid people often don't have filters. They just say whatever they're thinking, which is part of what makes them stupid. Lastly, stupid people don't learn very well. They are not as attuned to what is ok, what is not ok, and they will pretty much just absorb whatever people tell them without thinking too hard about it. They just aren't as conscious as smart people when they learn. While stupid people might, on a good day, remember that the little kid in "Jerry Maguire" said the human head weighs 10 pounds, they will not stop to question the relevance of what they learn. They will not evaluate the sources or the veracity, and they will not examine their new knowledge for nuance. They will just straight up believe that all Asians are fresh off the boat and that whites are the real Americans. Or they will believe that women are manipulative with their words.
This isn't a pleasant conclusion, after I have said that both you and I started there. But if you think about it, this is the default belief in our society. The easiest thing to believe is always the starter belief. Proof lies in people like my stupid new friend, who just says exactly what he picked up elsewhere. I'm sure he wasn't born with these ideas. But it has been incredibly easy for him to own them. He just wasn't smart enough to either 1) not say them in public, or 2) question whether they should be true, like many people I know.
Any of my friends, if I told them this story, would have one of these reactions:
A) What an ignorant asshole! Kick him in the nuts.
B) No way. Do people like this really exist? -This is a privileged white reaction.
C) You should just laugh about it. -This is an ignorant white reaction.
D) In [my] experience, he is incorrect because [reason X]. -This is a brown reaction.
Both answer A) and B) put my new friend in a box. These answers relegate him to the dunce corner of society where ridiculous people live. These sorts of responses say, "He has nothing to do with me."
Let's focus on answer B) in particular. Anyone who says this is white. They should consider that maybe they just don't have very many brown friends because this is not a once-in-a-lifetime occurrence. If you are so shocked, then you must not spend very much time in the proximity of brown friends. (Note: Riding public transportation does not count. You have to actually like the brown people you're sitting next to. Then you will pay attention to them and see their interactions with other people.)
Also, the B) response is a defense mechanism to the word "racist." We have a strong emotional reaction to the word "racist." "I cannot be racist, because being racist is immoral, and I am not immoral." So anyone who considers herself rational (or just well-trained) must be shocked and appalled whenever she encounters such a backwoods concept. "Do people actually believe these things?!" Yes, of course they do. I used to. I easily absorbed what society threw at me. I just don't say inappropriate things any more because of both 1) & 2): I know it's offensive, and I also don't believe it should be true.
So let's all get off our high horses and just acknowledge that my new friend's issues with me weren't completely out of nowhere. Yeah, he was a little more intense than normal, which is why I wondered what else was wrong with him and whether that would lead to me being stuffed in a trunk, but us being all shocked about his actual beliefs is a little self-righteous. He's just not very smart. But his stupidity only stopped him from reevaluating those beliefs; he still learned them from the same place we learned them: things we see and hear from other people, TV, books, etc. in our everyday lives.
And if your answer was C), well, then that's pretty much telling me that it's ok for complete strangers to come up and comment on my face whenever they feel like it, and I should just take it like a good Asian because "I'm the bigger person." I'm not the bigger person. That's pretty paternalistic. Let me be angry. I wanted to tell him I thought he was German because he had skull-like eye-sockets; the only reason I didn't is because he was bigger than me and I'm not stupid.
If you're Asian, can run really fast, and you want to play games with him and make him feel stupid, well I guess that's your prerogative. But that behavior falls into the same category as A) and B) in that you're dehumanizing him and relegating him to the "unfit" corner of society. In doing so, you mark everyone else as "still safe," allowing you to retain your sanity.
He is a special case; no one else ever thinks that about people like me.
Lastly, if your reaction was D) you are probably Asian. My reaction is frequently D). In fact, this whole post falls into D) category. It's easier to deal with things like this unemotionally. If we got pissed off every time someone said something stupid to us we'd have to walk around angry and bitter all the time. It's best to save emotions like that for special occasions. Also, if we remove ourselves from the situation and just analyze the other guy (and not how we feel), it's less personal. Thus, the scientific-study reaction, "He is wrong because of X," isn't about us. It's about whether there is any truth involved, and not whether that truth is hurtful. Another defense mechanism. It's useful, but it's still sad that we live in a world that requires us to have it.
The poor and the childlike tell us more about ourselves than we'd prefer. I think we all need to own our original racism.
Know thyself, and then decide whether thou wants to change anything. Maybe thou won't.
Regardless of where we want to end up, I think we should engage in a constant process of evaluating what we learn (and be conscious of when we are learning). Otherwise we will end up like my new friend: kicked in the nuts, teased, and the unwilling subject of psychoanalysis.